Five hidden gems to explore this summer in tropical Key West
Key West is known for its sunsets, historic charm and endless summer spirit. But beyond all the well-known spots such as Mallory Square and Duval Street (which, of course, are must-sees), lies a quieter, more surprising side of the island. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a repeat traveler looking to see Key West from a new angle, summer is the perfect time to investigate all the island’s hidden gems.
And the best part? When you stay in a well-located, well-appointed vacation rental from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals, everything you’ll want to experience is just a short walk, bike ride or scooter trip away. That’s because we specialize in all the most desirable areas of the island, mainly the Historic District, filled with fascinating cultural attractions, architecture and charming points of interest.
To get you started on creating your own special list of hidden gems in Key West, we’re offering five of our favorite under-the-radar spots. Don’t miss them when you visit this summer!
1. Key West Garden Club at West Martello Tower
Tucked away on the southern edge of Higgs Beach lies a peaceful oasis hiding in plain sight. This Civil War-era fort is home to the Key West Garden Club, featuring lush, tropical gardens, koi ponds, and quiet corners perfect for a morning coffee or midday pause. Maintained by a non-profit organization whose mission is to offer tropical gardening-related educational opportunities to the local community, this gorgeous venue offers a respite from busy island life. Best of all? Admission is free, with donations gratefully accepted. Address: 1100 Atlantic Blvd.
2. Cuban Coffee Queen’s “Back” Locations
Key West’s Cuban Coffee Queen is a local treasure that prides itself on offering a buzzing cultural experience alongside your morning cup of traditional coffee from Havana. You’ll find special drinks, food (think Cuban sandwiches), bagged coffee for purchase and unique merchandise. While the waterfront Cuban Coffee Queen draws big crowds, you’ll find three other locations across Key West, so you’re never far from a great cup of coffee. It’s the perfect quiet spot to try a cortadito or café con leche and pan Cubano.
3. Little Hamaca Park Hike and Salt Ponds Nature Trail
Escape the buzz of downtown and take a short hike along the Salt Ponds Trail, a little-known path winding through native mangroves, with fabulous opportunities for birdwatching and catching a glimpse of wild Key West. It’s a reminder that the island’s natural beauty goes beyond the beach. Start at the end of Government Road, just off the airport loop. You’ll follow a quiet boardwalk and footpath that winds through a mangrove forest. Find out more here.
4. B’nai Zion Cemetery and Historic Jewish Section
Key West’s history is more diverse than many realize. This peaceful, often overlooked cemetery tells the story of the island’s once-thriving Jewish community dating back to the 1800s. It’s a contemplative, meaningful visit that adds depth to any cultural itinerary.
Address: Corner of Francis and Olivia.
5. Gato Village Pocket Park
Tucked between historic streets and colorful cottages, Gato Village Pocket Park is one of Key West’s smallest — and most charming — green spaces. Located near the Historic Seaport, this quiet little oasis is easy to miss unless you’re exploring the neighborhood on foot or bike. But that’s part of what makes it so special. Featuring a butterfly garden, native plants, and benches perfect for a restful pause or a casual picnic, this is a great stop for those who appreciate the hidden nooks where locals read, chat with neighbors, or sip a coffee under the trees.
Book your Key West summer vacation today
Want to stay in the heart of it all in Key West? Book this summer with Historic Key West Vacation Rentals and discover all the hidden gems the island has to offer. When you stay in a centrally located vacation home, you can ditch the car and experience Key West like a local. All our properties are just steps from Old Town’s best-kept secrets. They’re also imbued with historic charm, alongside modern comforts and are ideal for couples, families, or solo travelers. Find your perfect rental, whether you’re just passing through fabulous Key West or settling in for a month-long stay. And whether you’re sipping Cuban coffee in a secret garden or catching a peaceful sunset away from the crowds, summer in Key West is your chance to slow down and explore the island on your own terms.
Book your stay now and make your next getaway one you’ll never forget.
Published on Sunday, May 18, 2025