Guest Testimonials

Fair Winds at the Foundry - Weekly Rental

5.0

beautiful townhome convenient to everything!

Our family of 4 (2 teen boys) had a wonderful stay at this property. It was clean, well stocked with kitchen supplies for cooking, bath towels and beach towels. Management was super responsive and helpful. Location was perfect!! Easily walkable to the waterfront, Duval, Mallory Square, Fury water sports, much more. We didn’t need a rental car. The gates to Truman Annex close at 6, which made it feel extremely safe bc you’re in close proximity to Duval. Boys enjoyed the pool. We made use of the very clean and new grill outside for meals. Perfect spot 10/10!

Submitted by Lorton VA on Aug 31, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Dear Jill~ Thank you for your great review of Fair Winds at the Foundry! We are so happy that you enjoyed the property and the security of a gated community. We agree the location is perfect and hope to welcome you back again soon! The Team at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

delightful stay at chavez house

Chavez House was the perfect place for a Key West getaway. It's located on a quiet street but walkable to everything. The house was so clean--totally immaculate upon arrival, and it was well stocked with fresh linens, pool towels, and things like dishwasher and laundry pods. Small samples of Bee Kind toiletries were a nice touch (and if you've never used the lemongrass body wash, it is amazing!). The staff at Historic Key West Vacations is friendly and accommodating, and they make renting easy. The beds were comfy, and the decor has a nice beachy vibe. We loved our stay!

Submitted by Malvern PA on Aug 30, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you, Sharon, for your fabulous review of Chavez House! We appreciate your kind words and agree the home is perfect! We hope to see you again soon~ The Team at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

great location, five star stay

Large key west home on main drag with pool and amenities for any and all occasions. Good for family, friends and all the above. Will be renting again.

Submitted by Dallas TX on Aug 26, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are looking forward to your next stay! Come and bring family and friends! The Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect vacation spot

This house was perfect for our family vacation and the concierge team was fabulous. I highly recommend renting this beautiful home to be in the heart of Key West!

Submitted by Londonderry NH on Aug 18, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your fabulous review of Lilly's Pad and our Concierge Team! We love this gorgeous home and are so glad you enjoyed your time there. We hope to welcome you back to Key West soon~ The Team at HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

butterfly cottage

This property was in a great location - private yet close to everything. It was clean and well stocked with amenities. The pictures were exactly what we found when we arrived. The property managers were very good with communication and very helpful and friendly. Would definitely stay here again or another property from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals.

Submitted by Springdale AR on Aug 17, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay at Butterfly Cottage! We are so happy to hear you appreciated the location, privacy, and communication. We strive for 5 star guest experiences! We can't wait to welcome you back to Key West soon~ The Team at HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

the great escape!

We decided to celebrate my son's 21st birthday in Key West and we couldn't have found a better place to stay the Potter's Cottage. Great experience, clean and a great location, we highly recommend you stay here when you are in Key West, next time.

Submitted by Saint Petersburg FL on Aug 14, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your great review of Potter's Cottage. We agree it's a fabulous cottage! We hope you're planning your next visit with us~ The Team at HKWVR

Casablanca Grande - Nightly Rental

5.0

fantastic

My experience in this house was wonderful; my children enjoyed the pool from start to finish. Thank you

Submitted by Doral Fl on Aug 11, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind review and we're thrilled you got to spend some good pool time! Come and stay with us again! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

great rental- key west

Everything was in order, clean and great location. No parking but we didnt need it.

Submitted by Longville MN on Aug 06, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What nice and kind words. We hope you'll come and stay with us again! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

awesome experience!

House was great. Tons of space for the whole family. It is close to everything! Pool is awesome and cooled us off great!! Rental company was great as well. House is well kept and really clean! Thank you will be back soon!!

Submitted by Conway SC on Aug 05, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Your trip sounds wonderful and we hope you'll come and make some more memories with us! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

property awesome as usual but...

Grill needs to be replaced. It is thoroughly rotted out on the internals. Otherwise this property is awesome as usual and the company is great to deal with. I have been staying here for many years now.

Submitted by Bartlett TN on Aug 04, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind and honest review of Poinciana Treetop. We hope you know us well enough by now that we would have made the grill situation right for you while you were here! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

great family trip`

We are regular Key West visitors and love coming down for music, restaraunts water sports and everything else Key West has to offer! This home has a great location for everything! Walkable to alot of diferent things as well! Home was spcious and has a very relaxing back deck and pool area. Parking is tight but we did squeeze in a small car and 2 golf carts. Definately would stay here again!

Submitted by Nokomis Fl on Aug 04, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are thrilled you enjoyed your time at Villa Josine! We hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

a fantastic stay

what a comfortable and a fantastic stay. we enjoyed this pristine two bedroom two story Villa .everything was a spotless. I really enjoyed the attention to the details which had been given carefully to this very comfortable Villa in the heart of old key west. it's steps away from a cocktail or a great breakfast right in the heart of key west. and the communication was wonderful with the management. they kept sending texts and followed up on any of our needs. they had a recommendation for a quick fishing trip which I was interested in .it was a party boat fishing trip and it was very reasonable it was called salty dog fishing.thank you for a great stay.

Submitted by Naples FL on Aug 01, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That sounds like the perfect stay in Key West! Now that you know how great Petite Maison is, we hope you'll come back soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Royal Poinciana Cottage- NEW Nightly Rental

5.0

small

It has a kitchen, bed and bathroom. Really all you need. The place sufficed for a few days. I would guess it at 250 sqft.
It was clean.

Submitted by Newport KY on Jul 31, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review Royal Poinciana Cottage. Hope you'll come and stay with us again! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Robinson Crusoe Cottage-NEW Nightly Rental

5.0

great vacation

We loved our cottage and the pool! It was so private and helped us have a great vacation. The unit also had everything that we needed.

Submitted by Winter Park FL on Jul 31, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That is so nice to hear! We want you to come back again soon and speak some more time in that pool. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

La Casita en Cima- NEW Monthly Rental

5.0

best location ever!

We stayed for a month in this rental property during July and loved it. The location can't be beat; Duval street was less than 2 blocks away. Our neighbors on the street were very kind to us including the roosters! Key West is a very special place to us and this is mostly because of the people who live and work on this island. This rental location enabled us to hop on our bikes and go anywhere. The backyard was a little piece of heaven which I appreciated daily. The waterfall sound in the pool, iguanas roaming in the trees above, palm trees swaying in the island breeze created a private, tropical paradise. Being able to text with the property manager was extremely convenient and hassle free. The maintenance crew was incredibly kind and helpful. The beds are comfortable and the mid stay cleaning was a fantastic service. For one week, both our daughters joined us. I will say the furniture in the living room could be more optimal with a small 'L' shape sectional. There was one small couch and a small chair. It made a movie night difficult when there was 4 of us. Other than that, I have zero complaints! It was lovely, and we will definitely return.

Submitted by Granville OH on Jul 30, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a kind and poetic review of La Casita en Cima! You make it sound magical and return-worthy. We will discuss the couch ~ what a great idea. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

beautiful home in the perfect location

From the ease of booking, to the communication with Cindy & Tippi, to the absolutely stunning accommodations-we would 100% stay here again. The location is right in the middle of all the fun on Duval street and easily walkable to other activities. The home is clean, fresh, and beautifully decorated with everything we would need for the 4 nights we stayed. We can’t wait to come back again.

Submitted by Canton OH on Jul 29, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We 100% want you to come back again, and soon! Maybe the memories of Cloud 9 will entice you to start making plans. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

potter’s cottage

Great time! House was clean and well stocked with all our needs and close walking distance to everything. Can’t wait to come stay again!

Submitted by Seminole FL on Jul 29, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are anxiously awaiting your next visit! Potter's Cottage is here waiting for you! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

cocktail pool is a real treat

We loved our stay at Potter's Cottage. We were a party of four staying in the middle of July, and the highlight for us was gathering in and around the cocktail after sunset to unwind and relax. Perfect.

Submitted by Asheville NC on Jul 29, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice thing to envision! We hope you'll come soon and do it again. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

another great week in key west

Wow is what my wife and I said after walking through the front entrance.
Pool was great as was the house.
Extremely private as soon as you enter.
House was super clean and had everything you could need to stay a week there and never go out to eat, utensils and appliances.
Booking was a breeze, they’re always helpful and they checked in several times during our stay.. will book again with them in the future

Submitted by Yorktown Heights NY on Jul 26, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice and kind review of Cloud 9 ~ we love it too! Can't wait to see you again soon. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect spot for key west family vacation home base

Lilly's Pad is just as advertised, and just what we hoped for. Near the quieter end of Duval, beautifully furnished, immaculately clean, 4 baths, 3 bedrooms, and the delightful 'cool off' pool in the back couldn't have been better for our trip. We'd stay again in a heartbeat.

Submitted by Sykesville MD on Jul 17, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice review and we thank you! Please come and make some more memories with us at Lilly's Pad! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great stay for our girls trip!

The house was adorable and clean. The beds were comfy. A great getaway!

Submitted by Sayville NY on Jul 17, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind review of Chick-a-Pea Cottage! We hope you've already made plans to come and stay again, soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

great location!

This was such a great find. We really enjoyed the location. Very close to the main street and all the restaurants. The property also feels very private and quiet but close to all the action. The host communicated very clearly and proved all information needed for a great stay. The place is very clean, comfortable bed, good water pressure, and thoughtful details like plenty of towels and essential. Would highly recommend and would stay again.

Submitted by Whittier CA on Jul 15, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review and we're thrilled you came! Please come back again (remember to book directly)! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Queen Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

willis stay at quee5n conch

We had an amazing time in Key West with friends, especially being able to stay in the house we use to own. Great memories!!

Submitted by Tallahassee Fl on Jul 15, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That is such a great story and we love Queen Conch! Please come again ~ you always have a vacation home in Key West! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great house, perfect location

Super nice house in an unbeatable location. Fit 7 of us perfectly. I would definitely stay here again.

Submitted by West Palm Beach FL on Jul 14, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We agree ~ Chick-a-Pea Cottage is a favorite! Thank you for taking the time to review it. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Inn Cogneato Cottage - Monthly Rental

5.0

bahama village house

Great house, very comfortable, perfect location

Submitted by Monroe GA on Jul 14, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It is so nice to hear you enjoyed Inn Cogneato! Thank you for taking the time to review it. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Seas The Day! - Weekly Rental

5.0

perfect getaway

Our rental was perfectly located and supplied with all we needed to get started for the week! The pool was a wonderful amenity as we didn't realize how the beaches were in Key West. We did a LOT of walking and took advantage of bikes that HKWVR helped us reserve. It was a very easy process! Being so close to Duval Street with shopping and a huge variety of places to eat was perfect for our family!

The place itself kept cool in the heat of the summer and we had no problems with anything in the condo. Be aware that the kitchen packs all your needs in pretty tight! The back porch was an added bonus.

Everyone from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals who texted/messaged/called us were very helpful and kind for us first-timers!
We would definitely come back to this area and condo!

Submitted by East Peoria IL on Jul 10, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love your review and thank you for taking the time to do so. We hope this won't be your last time to Key West ~ now Seas the Day! can be your very own vacation home here. The Team @ HWKVR

Poinciana Paradise - Group Rental

5.0

nice house

The house is separated into 2 unconnected units. Identical units, one upstairs and one downstairs. It was very clean, bright, and had everything we needed. There was a very nice screened porch off the downstairs bedroom, with a ceiling fan. It was in a very good area, walkable to Duval St.

Submitted by Griffin GA on Jul 08, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the helpful review of Poinciana Paradise ~ we love your description! Hope you'll come and stay with us again ~ either at Poinciana Garden (downstairs) or Poinciana Treetop (upstairs) or both ~ Paradise! The Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

cute, clean, updated cottage

This 2/2 cottage is clean, cute and updated with all the amenities you could possibly need. The outdoor area is perfect for drinking coffee in the morning. The location is centrally located for all things historic olde town. We loved the location.

Submitted by Grand Prairie TX on Jul 07, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are thrilled you enjoyed your time at Butterfly and we agree it's in a perfect location! Cuban coffee?? Yum! The Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great location

Superb stay in Key West. Perfect location close to the action but away from the late night noise. Great accomodations with everything you need. Pool was a plus.

Submitted by Miami FL on Jul 06, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy Chick-a-Pea was part of your good memories of Key West! Come and make some more with us! The Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

cozy cottage

Property description is accurate - Location was exactly what we wanted! Close enough to walk to everything, but just far enough off the main drag to get a good night's sleep! Everything is clean and offered everything you'd need!

Submitted by Seminole FL on Jul 03, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a perfect review for future guests of Solaris Garden! Thank you kindly for taking the time to review it. The Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

cozy cottage

The house was very comfortable and quiet. At the same time less than two blocks from Duval Street. The house felt very luxurious except the bath and beach towels. That is the only change I would make. They were very small. I was surprised. The hosts were amazing and very helpful. I when I go back to Key West this is my first choice to stay again. Yes you want a small car.

Submitted by Decatur IL on Jul 02, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind and honest review of Butterfly Cottage and we will definitely take a look at the towels situation! The Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

very nice home on a quiet street.

We have stayed at several Historic Key West Vacation Rental properties over the years and as always, this one did not disappoint. Loved the decor and whimsical artwork throughout the house. Having en suite bathrooms for every bedroom allowed privacy for all our guests. Looking forward to next year!

Submitted by Bentonville AR on Jun 27, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you choose us and we can't wait to see you again! Thank you for the kind review! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

june 14 to 20 trip

The location and cleanliness was fantastic

Submitted by Marietta GA on Jun 25, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We think you're fantastic for taking the time to review us so kindly! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

just the right balance of everything....

Solaris Garden is tucked away on a very quiet street, but steps away from all the activity Key West has to offer. The home is very well kept and has the total bungalow feel to it. Has a private bathroom off the bedroom a nice secluded front porch for sitting out or laying out on. The exposed wood on the ceiling is a perfect touch. Home comes with everything you need to include cleaning items down to laundry detergent pods as their is a washer and dryer outside off the bedroom. Unfortunately the dryer was not connected so I just had to hang everything up to air dry, but I consider that a champagne problem in Key West. The management company was wonderful and very accommodating. I would absolutely recommend this as a very quaint and secluded place to stay where you will feel safe and almost everything is within walking distance to include Southernmost point, Mallory Square and the historic marina area. Great price also! My thanks for a wonderful time!

Submitted by Pittsburgh PA on Jun 18, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank YOU for the kind review of Solaris Garden ~ we are going to use 'champagne problems' from now on. Hope we'll see you again, and soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Fair Winds at the Foundry - Weekly Rental

5.0

great location

Beautiful place and great location. I would rent again and again

Submitted by New Haven IN on Jun 13, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope you do! Starting January 2026, Fair Winds @ the Foundry will be a monthly rental ~ you can come and stay for a whole month! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

La Casita en Cima- NEW Monthly Rental

5.0

lovely home

I rented this beautiful home for May and was not disappointed at all. Very well-kept, lovely backyard environment, Highly recommend this rental

Submitted by Las Vegas NV on Jun 13, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for reviewing our new home La Casita en Cima. We are delighted to hear you enjoyed the home and hope you'll come and stay with us again soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Casablanca - Nightly Rental

5.0

we didn’t want to leave

This place had everything we were looking for.

Submitted by Baytown TX on Jun 12, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That just sums everything up ~ thank you for the kind words! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect location with private quiet street

Excellent experience we will stay here again.

Submitted by Miami FL on Jun 10, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are happy to hear you enjoyed the location of Poinciana Garden and hope you'll come and enjoy it again, soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Royal Poinciana Cottage- NEW Nightly Rental

5.0

pleasant stay!!!!

We had a wonderful stay! The rooms were exactly as shown in the pictures - clean, comfortable, and well-maintained. The property itself was great and had all the essential amenities we needed. And the pool was a plus! We really loved our time here.

One small recommendation: the pull chain for the ceiling light in the bedroom was really really short. It’d be great if it was longer for easier access.

A special shoutout to the lady at the front desk - she was truly amazing and made our trip even better. She gave us fantastic tips about the area, including great food recommendations. She was an absolute gem!

Overall, the service was excellent, and we would definitely recommend this place to others.

Submitted by Omaha NE on Jun 08, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

A pull chain for the ceiling light is a great idea and I've passed it along, as well as your compliment to our favorite person also, Tippi! Thank you for taking the time to give us all such a nice review. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great stay in key west

Great location - nice and quiet house close to the action on Duval

Submitted by Nashua NH on Jun 07, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are happy to hear you enjoyed the location of Chick-a-Pea Cottage and hope you'll come and enjoy it again, soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

la maisonnette~ gated condominium

Loved the location and the vibe - the condo was perfect
Parking was challenging - even with the golf cart !!

Submitted by Leominster MA on Jun 06, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to heal you enjoyed your time at La Maisonnette ~ we hope you're making plans to come back and stay with us again, and soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

5 star experience!!

5 star experience! The property was very clean, comfortable and well appointed with everything we could’ve possibly needed. Great kitchen, amazing pool, and overall very comfortable for our group. This property is very walkable to pretty much anything you’d want to do or a very short uber. The team at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals communicate extremely well and ensured our every need was fully met. It couldn’t have been a better experience with them and they truly made this trip top notch for our group, we’ll definitely be back!

Submitted by Georgetown TX on Jun 05, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are looking forward to your next stay at Southard Comfort and hope it's soon! Thank you for taking the time to review us so kindly. 5 stars back at you. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect get away

The whole process from reservation to check out was flawless. The home was exactly what we were looking for and more. Close enough to walk to restaurants and museums, close to the Duval Loop bus route which made getting around town a breeze. The home was tastefully decorated and the pool and front porch were added bonuses.

Submitted by Davenport FL on May 31, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love your description of your stay at Potter's Cottage and thank you for taking the time to review us! We hope we'll see you again in the future. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Margarita Cottage- NEW Nightly Rental

5.0

margarita cottage review

Overall, this is a great location for one or two guests. Location is wonderfully located near many great restaurants (highly suggest Santiago’s bodega (tapas), Kaya island eats, and square grouper), el siboney is right caddy corner with Cuban food and coffee if you need), sight-seeing locations and is quiet and peaceful. The pool is nice to have as well for in between days to just chill and sun (or shade).

Only downsides: bed is a little springy so could potentially be a problem if with a bedmate that moves around a lot in their sleep, you’ll disturb each other. Secondly, the air-conditioning unit is located in the kitchen/dining corner, even with fans and attempting to angle the vents the bedroom area was notably warmer then the other half of the space: in hotter months this could make it difficult to sleep.

Towel, soaps and other amenities are great quality, and property management is quick and informative. Everything is well maintained and clean

Submitted by Durham NC on May 30, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind review of our new Margarita Cottage ~ we took your advise and got new mattresses! Now we just need you to come back and see how we did. The Team @ HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

adorable house - exceeded expectations

We had 4 people and rented the bottom unit in May. The interior is exactly like the photos and you're instantly in Key West vacation mood. The backyard pool area is gorgeous and we drank coffee out there in the mornings and were tempted back there every afternoon for a few hours of glorious pool time between checking out the town and sights. Loved the convenient location and we did not have any close-by roosters crowing. Upstairs neighbors were friendly and we shared tips on what to do in KW. I suspect, due to the not-low-budget accommodations, that this house doesn't attract the young partying crowd.
A couple of tips: there are some mosquitoes at night but we found a bunch of bug spray under the kitchen sink. Bring hair conditioner - it's not provided and the shampoo is only enough for a couple of days if you have women using it :), also living room chairs are too stiff, not comfy, but couch is fine.
I would highly recommend for all the reasons the previous Reviewers gave and I hope I can go back because, even though Key West is tiny, there's "still so much to be done" and we weren't able to visit the Dry Tortugas this trip!

Submitted by San Jose CA on May 25, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are already looking forward to your next stay ~ let us know when you're coming back and we'll be happy to help look into booking a Dry Tortugas trip for you! Thank you for the nice review ~ and the great tips! ~ The Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

a week exploring the keys

Absolutely impressed with Horse Conch property. The location was perfect. Parking was no problem at all. The pool and garden area are like a private tropical resort. The only issue was the comfort of the pull out sofa bed. This could benefit from an upgrade to ensure all guests comfort.

Submitted by Greensburg PA on May 23, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of Horse Conch (your neighbors said you were really nice!) and we hope you'll come back and stay with us again soon. Thank you for the note about the sofa- we will look into that. ~ The Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

The Conch Cottages-NEW Nightly Rental

5.0

fantastic private compound

We travel with 2 other couples and this rental was perfect! Comfortable private cottages surrounding a beautiful pool area. Everything you need and an easy walk or bike to the quiet end of Duval.

Submitted by Fresno CA on May 21, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You make The Conch Cottages sound magical ~ 'perfect' is a great word! Thank you for the kind review! We can't wait to see you all again. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Hibiscus Cottage-NEW Nightly Rental

5.0

good times!

Just right

Submitted by Waynesville GA on May 18, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Well thank you for the kind words! We think you're 'just right' as well. ~ The Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

key west vibe on cloud 9

Great vacation! Location, pool, cleanliness, and concierge communication were all top notch. Such a great home. Private, but very convenient to all Duvall has to offer. The only negative is the stairs to upstairs living area. Very steep. Just be aware if anyone has mobility issues.

Submitted by Parkersburg WV on May 18, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Those are our favorite words "Great vacation!". And thank you for giving future guests a heads up about the stairs. ~ The Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect in paradise

Property was wonderful. Property was full of charm and made us feel right at home - would absolutely recommend this property

Submitted by Cedarville NJ on May 17, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We think you're wonderful for leaving us such a kind review~ we hope you'll make it back to Key West again soon. ~ The Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great trip!

Loved loved loved Potters Cottage. It was the perfect place for our trip and accommodated our family of 5 perfectly.

Submitted by Elizabeth PA on May 17, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice review of Potter's Cottage! Thank you, and we hope we'll see the whole family again! ~ The Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Casablanca Too - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect stay in old key west

We loved our stay in Casablanca Too on our trip to Key West. It's easy walking to restaurants and the historic district. We were a short walk to bike rentals that we took advantage of, and used the whole stay. The hot tub and amenities were nice add-ons to enjoy. Sitting on the front porch was perfect for morning coffee! Brunch at Blue Heaven was worth the wait, also Seven Fishes was delicious! Take a sunset cruise with Barefoot Billy's, excellent time :) Would highly recommend this property for a couple wanting to relax and enjoy a quiet vacation.

Submitted by murfreesboro TN on May 16, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It sounds like you had the perfect vacation time here in Key West! We hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

solaris garden

Solaris Garden was very comfortable, beautiful and well appointed for two people and the location was ideal. It was quiet but close to everything. Historic Key West Vacation Rentals texted us promptly with needed information and checked on us via text during our stay. Highly recommend!

Submitted by Conway AR on May 14, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice review of Solaris Garden! Thank you for taking the time to do so. We are looking forward to your return! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great location & classic cottage

My husband and I stayed at the Solaris Cottage for a week vacation. It had everything we needed for our stay. The sofa had been recently upgraded and was big enough for both of us to lounge comfortably. The cottage was clean and had a cute outdoor area. The location was just a short walk away from Duvall Street but very quiet. No need for a car, we rented bicycles. We would definitely stay here again.

Submitted by Troy MI on May 14, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are looking forward to your next stay! Thank you for the kind review and we're here anytime you're ready to come back! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

first time visiting key west

First time to Key West and we glad we picked Horse Conch to stay at. Everything was as described and hosts were very proactive to make sure our stay was going smoothly. Everything we needed was available and the place was well taken care of and very clean. The backyard pool and pool area was awesome. Very peaceful and secluded. Glad we chose Horse Conch and would highly recommend staying here.

Submitted by Crawfordsville IN on May 14, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of Horse Conch! We hope you're making plans to come and stay with us again and telling friends they can stay near you at Rooster Conch or Sea Conch! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Seas The Day! - Weekly Rental

5.0

wonderful condo in key west

We had a great visit to our favorite place. The condo in the Truman Annex had everything we needed and was in a perfect location. We walked to everything and came back to a quiet, peaceful and safe location in the evenings.

Submitted by Bath NY on May 11, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are thrilled you enjoyed your time at Seas the Day! Please remember it will be a monthly rental starting January 1 ~ so come and stay with us for a whole month next year! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

beautiful key west home ��️

The home was beautiful. It was very clean. It was very spacious. Everything we needed was provided. The pool was clean and nice to have after a long day out on Duval street. It was a great location. We even enjoyed our other roomie, who we named Gus, the local rooster. The rental company does a great job communicating and helping out.

Submitted by Inverness FL on May 07, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are glad everyone got along (Gus) and enjoyed their time in Key West! Come and stay with us again, please! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

enjoyed our trip

Great spot in a quiet part of town. Short walk to the seaport and Duval

Submitted by North Plainfield NJ on May 05, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We agree with every word of this nice review! Come and stay again! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

La Casita en Cima- NEW Monthly Rental

5.0

5 stars

5 stars

Submitted by Cincinnati OH on May 04, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We give you 5 stars too! Thank you for coming and staying with us! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

loved potter's cottage

This cottage was lovely. Perfectly decorated. Cozy yet spacious enough. We appreciated how very clean it was, too. It was a great location. One block off the craziness, so we could easily walk to Mallory square and all the bars & restaurants. Perfect setting! We rented a golf cart for a few days to get groceries and travel all around the island, but we were fine just walking for the remainder of our trip. The pool was the best! We spent our days enjoying that and the back yard, and enjoyed late-night people watching from the front porch as they strolled by at the end of the night. Would definitely stay here again and recommend it!

Submitted by Charlevoix MI on May 04, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice review of Potter's Cottage, thank you! We hope you'll come and stay with us again, and soon. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Tropical Dream - Monthly Rental

5.0

tropical dream april 2025

Tropical Dream is a fabulous home in a great location. Close to the waterfront, most all key restaurants and music venues are walkable. The home is spacious and comfortable for a monthly stay. The downstairs bedroom is perfect if someone needs to work. There is computer monitor, keyboard and even a printer! Lastly, the wrap around second story porch and sundeck provide for great sunning and people watching on the street below. The pool does not get a lot of sun until early afternoon, but the sundeck gets it all day! Highly recommend Tropical Dream

Submitted by Antioch IL on May 02, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so thrilled you enjoyed your time at Tropical Dream (a whole month of memories!). We hope you'll come and stay with us again, and soon. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

happiness

Best Airbnb we have rented in Key West. Charming and well appointed. Location is excellent, unit was clean and nicely decorated. The management was very response and easy. We were missing nothing. We will definitely be back.

Submitted by Kill Devil Hills NC on Apr 30, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are looking forward to your next stay! Remember to book directly with us ~ we love that! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

4 night weekend in key west

We were 3 couples in our 60's on a 4 day visit to Key West. The house was a tad smaller than we expected but it was extremely well appointed and centerally located so that we could walk everywhere. The onsite parking spot was great.

Submitted by Mendham NJ on Apr 29, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Lilly's Pad! We hope you all will come back and stay with us again, and soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

absolutely perfect!

Very clean, central location and has all the right amenities! This home is close to all of the fun but far enough away for peace and quiet. We will absolutely be back!

Submitted by Grafton OH on Apr 29, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are awaiting your return! Please make it soon. Thank you for the kind review of Poinciana Garden. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

great experience

Convenient location; walk-able to the historic district, Bahama Village, Duval Street and the Sunset Pier. Quiet, no traffic. Clean and cozy.

Submitted by Topsham ME on Apr 28, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice review of Poinciana Treetop! It is indeed in a quiet but convenient location ~ just perfect in Key West. Please come and stay with us again, soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Reel Paradise - Monthly Rental

5.0

key west hidden paradise

The place was perfect!!! The response time to any questions was immediate, friendly and professional. The home was immaculate, the location was great and the neighbors were amazing!!! Definately returning next year!!!

Submitted by North wildwood NJ on Apr 28, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We can't wait for your return next year! We are thrilled you enjoyed your Key West time at Reel Paradise! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

cloud 9 rental

Rental is in a awesome location in key west. Everything you need including a big pool. The steep stairs were difficult for some with bad knees. Beds were very comfortable. The only con is the taxes and fees are very high.

Submitted by Wonder Lake IL on Apr 24, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to provide your feedback! I’m delighted you enjoyed the fantastic location and the range of amenities we offer, especially the large pool and comfortable beds. Your input regarding the steep stairs is much appreciated; We will certainly keep that in mind to better assist future guests. We understand that Key West taxes can seem high, but we strive to be transparent on our website so you know upfront what you're paying. If you have any further comments or suggestions that could enhance our service, please don’t hesitate to share. Your insights are invaluable to us! The Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

wonderful property, close to everything

We had a wonderful stay at Chick-a-Pea Cottage. The entire property, inside and outside, was very clean and comfortable. We cooked dinner one evening, which included using the outdoor grill, and the kitchen had all manner of utensils, stemware, cutlery, glasses, etc. necessary for a dinner party. An all-around fantastic stay. The management company stayed in contact to ensure all was well during the stay. I would highly recommend this property. Location is perfect.

Submitted by Fort Lauderdale FL on Apr 23, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Chick-a-Pea Cottage ~ taking good memories home with you is key. Please come and make some more memories with us! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

april vacation

Perfect day for up for 2 couples. Spacious, immaculate, quiet. Very private deck surrounding back of house. 2 blocks off of Duval in the center of Old Town you can walk everywhere. Convenient outdoor laundry, shower. We’ll be back for sure.

Submitted by Fairfax VA on Apr 19, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are waiting for your next visit ~ you will have so much fun! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Queen Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

birthday trip

This was a great unit for 4 couples. The layout was very cool and the pool was awesome. Very convenient to all the places we wanted to visit.

Submitted by Chapel Hill NC on Apr 15, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So happy you enjoyed your time here in Key West and at Queen Conch! Hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again, soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Grand Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

fabulous vacation in key west

The house was perfect - even better than the description. Immaculate, well stocked, and the heated pool with the fabulous back yard was truly remarkable. I would highly recommend this house and will be happy to return some day!

Submitted by Alexandria VA on Apr 11, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope 'some day' is sooner than later! Thank you for the kind review. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

great stay!

We had a great time! Bed was comfortable, good water pressure in the shower, place was impeccable clean. Nice linens. Kitchen was well stocked. The grounds are well maintained and beautiful. Duvel St is just around the corner. The only drawback is loading and unloading. We will definitely like to come again.

Submitted by Holly Springs NC on Apr 10, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope you'll come again soon. Thank you for the kind review of La Maisonnette! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

spring break at chavez house

Perfection.

Submitted by Brookfield WI on Apr 10, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

One word really does sum it all up! Thank you! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

amazing little cottage

Great location the house was clean and very inviting.

Submitted by Hudsonville MI on Apr 10, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That sounds like the perfect vacation rental to us! Thank you for taking the time to review us so kindly. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect get away

This was the perfect spot for our quick get-away. The quiet area and private porch were fabulous for starting the day.

Submitted by Brighton MI on Apr 09, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love that porch as well ~ so happy you got to experience it as well. Please do come again! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Serene Lily - Weekly Rental

5.0

fabulous week

We had a fantastic stay at Serene Lily. The place is gorgeous and spacious. The decor was beautiful and the place was spotless. We love staying in the Truman Annex with the gated community. The location was perfect - close to Duval and Mallory Square for the sunsets yet very quiet. We really appreciated all the little extras that the hosts supplied so we didn’t have to run out and buy hand soaps, garbage bags, laundry detergent, etc. this was our 5 th time in Key West and this was by far the nicest place that we’ve stayed.

Submitted by Topsham ME on Apr 08, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Serene Lily ~ we think it's just lovely as well (and the location! Chef's kiss!). We hope you'll choose us for your 6th time as well. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

chick a pea - chica perfect!

We had a wonderful 5 days at Chick A Pea Cottage. Location was perfect. Short walk to great shopping and unique dining away from the touristy type location. Well appointed and excellent beds/linens.
Communication with HKWV rentals was fantastic. We even left behind a prized stuffed rooster which was quickly located and shipped back to its owner. HKWV rentals also coordinated a golf cart rental which was a great idea for our group - ages 6-91. Would stay here again for sure.

Submitted by Northville MI on Apr 05, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time in Key West and at Chick-a-Pea Cottage! Bikes and golf carts are a great way to get around the island ~ especially for diverse groups. Please come and stay with us again, anytime! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

a jewel in key west!!

Fabulous location, and beautiful, well-maintained home. Very Comfy beds, beautiful/quality decor, quiet neighborhood but within easy walking distance to Duval, nightlife, Mallory square, trolly, restaurants etc. Great parking, but we didn't need to use our car at all!
Pool was wonderful and kitchen was equipped with everything possibly needed. Lots of thought was put into all the little "extras" provided to guests. One of THE BEST Airbnb's we have ever experienced. Will definitely recommend and revisit!!
Quality decor
Loved extras of soap body wash etc
Very well equipped kitchen

Submitted by Sarasota FL on Apr 04, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind and well thought out review of Sea Conch. We're thrilled you enjoyed your time and hope you'll be back soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Rooster Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

i'll be back

Met all expectations.

Submitted by Scarsdale NY on Apr 02, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You met our expectations as well! Hope you'll come and see us again and soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

La Casita en Cima- NEW Monthly Rental

5.0

old town rental

The house we rented was perfect! It was exactly as it was described and we loved it! Immaculate and tidy and well furnished and stocked we feel we found our KW forever home! We did have an issue with the pool light needing attention which was remedied immediately and could be happier with the service. Everyone who serviced the property was friendly and helpful and we look forward to our visit in 2026!

Submitted by Nantucket MA on Apr 02, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so thrilled you enjoyed your time at La Casita en Cima! It's a wonderful new home to us and we are so happy we get to share it. Can't wait to see you in 2026! We've already got you booked! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

lilly pad

Great stay for our daughter’s wedding. Convenient to everything, clean and cozy

Submitted by Richmond VA on Apr 02, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Congratulations! We hope everyone will come back for their anniversary! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Blue Haven- NEW Monthly Rental

5.0

heavenly pool

We had a great month staying at Blue Haven! The deck and pool are great, that was where we spent a lot of our vacation. The house is comfortable for 6 people. The guest house has been beautifully updated. The main house has the best equipped kitchen we have ever seen in a rental. Comfortable beds and seating. The only downside is the airplane noise, it didn’t bother us but it may bother sensitive renters. Quiet neighborhood, removed from the chaos of Duval Street but just a 10 minute bike ride away.

Submitted by Oak Hill VA on Apr 02, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind review of Blue Haven ~ we love that pool! Being on an island means you're close to... everything... so we're glad you enjoyed the non-plane times. Come again! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

rain forest like setting

The property was great, set up like a small resort with awesome landscaping making you feel like you were in your own little rain forest. House was clean an inviting. Location was perfect, we could walk to anywhere we wanted to go. We will be back!

Submitted by Berrien Springs MI on Apr 01, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love the greenery at La Maisonnette too, and its convenience to everything Key West. You can start the day out peaceful and quiet and within seconds be in the middle of everything fun! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

best rental experience ever

The team at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals was the best we've ever had. The staff was not only welcoming but over-the-top acommodating, allowing us to store our luggage before and after our rental times. The property was delightful and just our style. We will be back!

Submitted by New Kensington PA on Mar 29, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are happy to help with luggage and meet new people! Thank you for choosing us and allowing us to keep track of your things while you explored. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

wonderful rental on a quiet street

The description of the property was accurate. It is on a very quiet street but within walking distance to the fun of Duval Street and the beaches. We did not bother with renting a car and just walked to everything on Key West. The bed was comfortable, and everything was in working order. There are roosters, but they are all over the island, so not a complaint on the rental. That is just an overall heads up if traveling to Key West. We got used to them within a couple of nights, and they do quiet down. The property owner was awesome. Loved the concierge service. Made planning and booking things so easy!! Highly recommend this place.

Submitted by Scottsville NY on Mar 28, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so kindly for the lovely and honest review of Solaris Cottage ~ if you stay long enough you don't even notice the local roosters! They're basically family. Come see your family again soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

we had an amazing stay at villa josine!!

This home was everything we wanted and more than we expected. It was very clean and very well appointed, including comfortable beds and living room furniture. The location was absolutely perfect too. Thanks to Historic Key West Vacation Rentals for making our trip so memorable!!

Submitted by Destin FL on Mar 25, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for being such great guests ~ and thank you for taking the time to review Villa Josine so kindly. We hope you'll come back soon and make some more memories in Key West. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

fantastic stay in key west

This is a great house in a great location in Key West.
The house was clean, it was quiet - and the location was fabulous.
The best recommendation we can give is that we would absolutely return to the same place.

Submitted by Long Valley NJ on Mar 23, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

The fact that you want to come back to Dreaming on Duval is absolutely the best recommendation! We hope it's soon because we love seeing happy, familiar faces. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

spring break

My 4th time to stay book with this company. All have been 5 Star. Houses are gorgeous and VERY clean.

Submitted by Poteet TX on Mar 23, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

May the 4th visit be with you! We are so happy to have you come and stay with us and can't wait for your next visit. Thank you for reviewing us so kindly. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Casablanca - Nightly Rental

5.0

paradise

We loved staying there. The locks were a bit tricky, but can be figured out. It is so nice, we will be back.

Submitted by Galveston TX on Mar 23, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love that you loved staying at Casablanca! We will take a look at the locks ~ you can tell us how we did on your next visit! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Sanctuary on South- Monthly Rental

5.0

enjoyable

We enjoyed our stay.

Submitted by Eden Prairie MN on Mar 18, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope you're planning to come back and stay with us again. We love our monthly guests who come and live like a local. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Queen Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

keep coming back!

This was our 4th year staying at this amazing property. It now feels like our home away from home! We love the front porch and the amazing back yard (it has to be one of the biggest in the Old Town area!). It is in the best location; walkable to everything. The staff at HKWV is always the best!! Can't wait for next year!

Submitted by Fredericksburg VA on Mar 17, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are already looking forward to your next stay at Queen Conch! Thank you for being great guests and we appreciate your taking the time to review us so kindly. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Maisons de Luxe - Nightly Group Rental

5.0

maisons de luxe for a wedding week

Stayed there for our daughters' wedding.last week.Fantastic location, fantastic property, easy flow for 10 people.Great outdoor with dipping pool. Highly recommend if you want to stay on Duval.Short walks to many fine restaurants, activites ( see the butterfly Conservatorium,Hemmingway house, etc.) and, of course, bars.

Submitted by Louisville KY on Mar 16, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Congratulations to your daughter and your families. Hope you'll come for anniversaries and other big family events! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Copa Cabana - Monthly Rental

5.0

southernmost

Loved the property and the location.

Submitted by North Royalton OH on Mar 16, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed Copa Cabana and living like a local! Please come back ~ Copa Cabana awaits! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Seas The Day! - Weekly Rental

5.0

not the key west from 1975

Great location. Easy walk to everything.
We first went to Key West on our honeymoon
It has chanced a lot.

Submitted by Troy MI on Mar 16, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you got a chance to come back to Key West ~ we hope you'll come back again, maybe as a yearly anniversary get away? ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

lovely cottage

This is an oasis from busy Duval Street. perfectly located, about a 15 minute walk to Mallory Square, about a five minute walk to the southernmost point. Easily walkable to Hemingway house and Truman House. And beautifully decorated, they thought of everything. Plenty of towels, kitchen, tools, etc. Super responsive to text messaging, reply within the hour, every single time.Would definitely stay here again. (A heads up: the upstairs shower is really only suited for people under 5‘6“. The bedrooms are spacious up there, but that shower style is crazy short. The master shower is nice and tall.)

Submitted by Chapel Hill NC on Mar 16, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind and informative review of Chick-a-Pea Cottage! We think guest reviews like yours really give the next guests an idea of what to expect. We are looking forward to your next visit and we hope it's soon! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

fantastic house!

We love Petite Maison! This is our 2nd time staying here and definitely not our last. The location is perfect! Just off Duval, quiet but close to a wonderful coffee shop and restaurants

Submitted by Manlius NY on Mar 11, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It's like Petite Maison is your own vacation home in Key West! We're looking forward to that lucky 3rd time visit. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

fabulous place to stay!!

The house was exactly as described and so convenient to everything Key West. The owner was so proactive about suggestions for restaurants and entertainment.

Submitted by Leland NC on Mar 09, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of Potter's Cottage. We hope you'll return again and enjoy more Key West suggestions! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

great little place in the middle of paradise

Nice place to stay with easy access to all you’d want to see in KWFL.

Submitted by Harleysville PA on Mar 06, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

KWFL is waiting for you to come back and stay with us again! Thank you for being our guests. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

vacation in key west

The Historic Key West Vacation Rentals Agency was a pleasure to deal with. Call them directly in lieu of going through VRBO or AirBNB and have to pay for their added fee with nothing to show for the added burden. The agency even provides free concierge service (coordinated golf cart rental and information on things to do) which is unavailable through VRBO or AirBNB, and a place to store your luggage while waiting for rental check in time. Outstanding accommodations. We rented a six passenger golf cart for our travels in Key West. Parking is a challenge in the Keys. The house we rented could accomodate one vehicle plus the golf cart. Our party was six adults. The home worked very well . It had upstairs one king bed with an adjoining bath and two small bedrooms each with full or queen size beds and a shared bathroom. The first floor easily accomadated 6 adults with 1/2 bathroom, washer & dryer, large 6 seated dining room, large family room with a small TV, a small kitchen but well furnished. I would recommend an upgrade for the coffee pot to be one that supported Keurig as well as ground coffee. Fridge, stove, dishwasher, sink, microwave, pots and pans, utensils and dishwasher. The outdoor pool and patio area around it was a real plus, and where we spent most of our time. Decorated perfectly with a tropical flare and very private from the street and other homes. A grill and outside shower were an added bonus. Location was convenient to places to eat & small grocery stores. Some form of transportation was needed to go to larger grocery store and beaches on the East side of the Island. Although not terribly far to walk to the action spots on Duval street. It was a good distance to Mallory Square and the West side activities and the Golf Cart was used for those trips and to visit the Southern Most Point, Hemingway House, the Butterfly House and Garden. Our overall experience, principally as a result of our wonderful accomadations was outstanding.

Submitted by New Bern NC on Mar 06, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice and thorough review of Southard Comfort, Key West, and HKWVR! Thank you! We agree ~ bikes or golf carts are the best way to get around when you're not walking (or the free Duval Loop Bus). We love the pool area as well, and are so happy to hear it worked out for everyone in the home as well. We're already looking forward to your next stay! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Fair Winds at the Foundry - Weekly Rental

5.0

cozy townhome

We've been coming to KW for 20 years and have found this property to be one of the best. From its location to all the amenities - they have thought of everything. I work from home and even the wifi could keep up with all my reports. It would be nice to have a book with check in and check out information - I felt bad for asking questions, that with a little looking thru my emails, I could have found BUT when you are in Key West you forget all your worries! Great property and we will rent it again (and when we get our house built, we will send our overflow guest in this direction!).

Submitted by Purcellville VA on Mar 06, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind review of Fair Winds @ the Foundry! We look forward to your next stay. If you would like further instruction on utilizing our Guide link for property/area information, please reach out next time! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

wonderful

We had a relaxing and fun filled vacation in Key West. Our cottage was adorable and beautifully maintained. Plus the location was perfect. It’s close to Duval St with all the fun shops and restaurants but it’s on a quiet side street.

Submitted by Wyncote PA on Mar 04, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Butterfly Cottage. We think it's a wonderful home and are so glad you were able to spend time with us in Key West! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Sunny Daze Cottage- NEW Construction- Monthly Rental

5.0

a little gem in old town

Enjoyed our stay here very much. The property is beautifully decorated, very well equipped, and in excellent condition. There is a large private courtyard with comfortable outdoor furniture where we spent a lot of time. Everything was brand new, which was really appreciated. The location in the heart of Old Town couldn’t be beat. Wouldn’t hesitate to recommend and would definitely return.

Submitted by Portland ME on Mar 03, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice and kind review of Sunny Daze ~ we are loving this home and so glad you got to spend a month there (and we love that courtyard as well). We are thrilled you enjoyed your time here with us in Key West. Please do it again, next year! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Tropical Dream - Monthly Rental

5.0

wonderful keys rental property

Very positive stay in all regards. Has all the necessary amenities. Very pleasant patio area. Great location. Quiet but easy walk up to Duval or harbor area.

Submitted by Rochester NY on Mar 02, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind review of Tropical Dream! We hope you're already making plans to come and live like a local again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Serene Lily - Weekly Rental

5.0

great location, beautiful home

The house is conveniently located just two blocks from Duval St. walkable to everything. Very nicely furnished home, two king bedrooms upstairs, living room, kitchen, dining area and powder room downstairs. Comfy beds, very attractive. Would be comfortable for 4 people. Tight for 6.

Submitted by Oak Hill VA on Mar 02, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind and honest review of Serene Lily ~ we hope you'll come and stay with us again! Please make it soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

great stay in key west!!!

We had a wonderful week in Key West. Solaris Garden was the perfect size for my wife and me. It was exactly as advertised. It was clean, well maintained, spacious and well stocked. The location was excellent. We were able to walk or ride our bikes to great restaurants, the marina, and any of the sites we wanted to see. The rental company was gracious and helpful, especially when we arrived and departed. We would definitely rent Solaris Garden again and have already told many friends about it. Thanks for a GREAT vacation.

Submitted by East Amherst NY on Mar 01, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for being such great guests ~ we hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again. We love seeing happy, familiar faces! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

quaint, great location, get-a-way!

This was a terrific little place to stay! Great location, very clean, and very comfortable!

Submitted by Genoa City WI on Feb 28, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you, Jennifer, for your kind review of Poinciana Treetop! We appreciate your compliments on location, cleanliness and comfort. We hope to welcome you back again soon~ The Team at HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

don't pass this rental up...

Perfect for our 10 day vacation... all on one floor, newly renovated with top of the line furnishings and equipment. Two bedrooms, two baths, both with walk in showers. It's in a quiet location in walking distance to many sites and restaurants. We enjoyed many meals on the wrap around deck with table and chairs in shaded areas. Good customer service from the property managers.
There's also an outdoor grill, hot tub, and parking.
We've already booked for 2026!

Submitted by Bethesda MD on Feb 28, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your 5 star review of Butterfly Cottage! It is definitely a guest favorite. We are thrilled you are coming again and can't wait to welcome you back to your vacation home! The Team at HKWVR

La Casita en Cima- NEW Monthly Rental

5.0

lacasita

Great location, well managed and a nice floor plan for guests.

Submitted by Saint Paul MN on Feb 26, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay at La Casita en Cima! We are so happy that you enjoyed the location and floor plan. We hope to welcome you back to Key West in the future for a 5 star stay~ The Team at HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

sea conch on southard - awesome property/location

We (3 of us, my wife & son) stayed at Sea Conch on Southard for three nights ....we are frequent visitors of Key West dating back ~40 years and live in FL. This is a very well appointed property and in a prime location. We had the first floor which is secluded from the upstairs so privacy's maintained. The property managers were great to deal with.

Submitted by Venice FL on Feb 26, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you, Mike, for your fabulous review of Sea Conch! We agree that it is an awesome property in an awesome location. We appreciate your kind words and hope to welcome you back to Key West in the future! The Team at HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect key west getaway – comfortable, well-equipped, and great

We had an incredible stay at this beautiful home in Key West for my 40th birthday! From the moment we arrived, we felt welcomed and comfortable. The house was very comfortable, spacious, and well-appointed, making it the perfect place to relax and unwind.

The pool and fountain were absolute highlights—such a peaceful oasis to cool off after a day of exploring. Another big plus was having a washer and dryer, especially for a week-long stay! The house was also fully equipped with everything needed to cook at our leisure, which made it feel like a true home away from home.

The location couldn’t have been better—walkable to tons of great restaurants, bars, and stores, making it easy to experience the best of Key West without needing a car.

One of the most memorable moments for me was spotting the framed Yankees poster upstairs from the last game at the old stadium. That’s where my husband and I got engaged, and seeing it here brought a huge smile to my face!

We also had the pleasure of bringing our friends Jim and Patty along—Jim had never been on a plane before, and what a perfect place for his first flight! This trip was full of unforgettable memories, and we are so grateful for this wonderful home.

Submitted by Grand Island NY on Feb 25, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope you had a fantastic birthday, Gina! Thank you for your fabulous review of Southard Comfort. It is a great home in a great location. We hope Jim and Patty enjoyed their stay as well. Perhaps this can be a yearly tradition? Come back again soon~ The Team at HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

great location in key west

We had a wonderful stay at this house right off Duval. It made walking to all the best locations so simple. The house has plenty of space for our four guests.

Submitted by Baton Rouge LA on Feb 25, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We appreciate your taking the time to review Petite Maison so kindly! We hope you'll all come back and stay with us again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

pleasant stay in key west

We enjoyed our stay at Southard Comfort with our young family. Our kiddos especially loved swimming in the pool, which was nice and warm. We had brought our own swim toys and was glad that we did. The house was walking distance to pretty much anywhere you want to go in Key West though we did rent a car and appreciated that it had its own parking spot.

Submitted by Rochester NY on Feb 21, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a fun memory you made with your family! We hope you'll all make it back again soon. You have your own vacation home here in Key West. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

great outdoor area

Poinciana Garden is in a good location just a couple of blocks east of Duval Street and within an easy walk of the the Hemingway House and lighthouse. The unit has a very nice outdoor area with rocking chairs, dining space, and screened sitting area. The unit was very clean and the kitchen adequately furnished. We believe this unit is a good value.

Submitted by San Antonio TX on Feb 21, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for taking the time to review Poinciana Garden! We love that you enjoyed the home and your time on Key West. Please come back again soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Hibiscus Cottage-NEW Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect cottage and location

We had a wonderful stay at the Hibiscus Cottage. It has obviously had a recent renovation but did not lose the look and feel of an old conch house. Comfortable furnishings and a surprisingly large master with an en-suite bath that would rival that of a five star hotel. We enjoyed coffee on the front porch swing and breakfast from Fausto’s on the private deck. The property itself is also so beautiful with lush tropical gardens surrounding your every move. To top it off, the location is unbeatable. One block off Duval and just a few blocks from Mallory Square and many of the great restaurants in Key West. We will not hesitate to rent this little gem again.

Submitted by Manteo NC on Feb 21, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind review of Hibiscus Cottage ~ you make it sound just lovely! We are so happy we could host you again in Key West and look forward to your next trip! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Casablanca Too - Nightly Rental

5.0

great time in key west!

Casablanca Too was exactly as advertised, perfect for the two of us. An easy bike ride to everywhere.

Submitted by Norwalk CT on Feb 21, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are thrilled you enjoyed your time at Casablanca Too. We hope you'll come and do some more bike riding again soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

great family trip!

The family loved the house and the pool. Visiting Rooster was a big hit.
Location was perfect. So many wonderful things to do and we will definitely go back to do more. House was in great shape.

Submitted by Homer Glen IL on Feb 19, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You met our friend the rooster! He said he enjoyed his time meeting you as well. Hope you come back again soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

awesome “treetop” experience

This was our second year at the “Treetop” and will hopefully not be our last. We are already planning for our next stay in 2026. This property definitely deserves a five star review-it has every amenity that we need from clean, spacious living areas, full kitchen, two glorious balconies, parking and even washer and dryer accessibility. Plus the location on Whitmarsh Lane is very private and in close walking proximity to downtown.
Also, the staff at Historic Key West is first rate, always available, extremely affable, friendly and helpful. Our stay is always extremely memorable and we hate to leave!

Submitted by East Quogue NY on Feb 18, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love this review of Poinciana Treetop! We can't wait for your next trip ~ can you come down twice a year? ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect family vacation stay

This charming, well styled home couldn't have been more convenient. Location is ideal, right off Duval, but quiet.4 private rooms for our family to spread out. Outdoor space was awesome for down time. Renting a golf cart was the cherry on top.

Submitted by Warrington PA on Feb 18, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Chick-a-Pea Cottage! We hope you'll come and stay with us again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Casablanca - Nightly Rental

5.0

wonderful house!

The house is perfect! It’s very clean and has everything you need. The kitchen is fully stocked with plates, glasses, etc. The bathroom had a nice shower and plenty of towels. We love the location! We parked our car and never used it. You can walk everywhere. The backyard is amazing. The pool is beautiful. We swam every day and loved sitting in the yard relaxing. We will be back.

Submitted by Newtown Square PA on Feb 17, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You make your visit sound perfect ~ we're so glad it was! Thank you for choosing us, and we hope you're coming again soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Rooster Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

rooster conch key west

We had a wonderful 2 week stay at the Rooster Conch in Key West. The unit was everything it said, very clean, stocked (so helpful they provide a list of what is stocked). The property was well maintained while we were there. Excellent location being close to everything but quite. Will definitely be back.

Submitted by Madison Heights MI on Feb 17, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your two weeks at Rooster Conch! Thank you for the kind review. We are already looking forward to your next visit! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

The Escape at Sunset Key - Monthly Rental

5.0

a wonderful escape!

We rented The Escape at Sunset Key to escape winter in New England, and it was a truly wonderful place to do just that! The location on Sunset Key is fabulous - with access to the pool, beaches, fitness center, spa and the incredible Lattitudes restaurant. Access is also very easy to Key West and all that Duval Street has to offer! We found it a true getaway from winter.

As you would expect with most any extended rental, we encountered several issues along the way. But the rental management company was very responsive, and helped ensure that the problems were adequately resolved and we were able to enjoy our stay.

We will definitely consider returning for another Escape!

Submitted by Wellesley Hills MA on Feb 16, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It sounds like you had an amazing time at The Escape at Sunset Key! The beautiful location, excellent amenities, and easy access to Key West must have made for a perfect winter getaway. It's wonderful to hear that we could address any concerns you may have had. We strive to make your stay enjoyable. Have you thought about when you might return? We're looking forward to welcoming you again! The Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

fabulous + fun holiday ����

Loved our rental! Location was perfect, quiet at night! Immaculate and cozy, upstairs porch is lovely! A hidden treasure off the Main Street! We biked everywhere! So many great restaurants and so many fun things to do! ��

Submitted by Myrtle Beach SC on Feb 16, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Petite Maison and we hope you'll come back again, soon! Thank you for taking the time to write such a nice review. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect

This place was awesome, vey clean and 1 block off of Duvall.
We had such a great time having our coffee on the deck and then our wine in the evening on the deck. So relaxing and comforting. i would recommend this place and we will be back!

Submitted by Delavan WI on Feb 15, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

I am happy you were able to unwind on the deck! We can't wait for your return. We hope it's soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Grand Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

wow!! great place!! super clean!! great service!!

We take family trips around 3Xs a year and within the US always stay at VRBOs. This is without a doubt a 5-star rental. The concierge service from Cindy from booking to golf cart drop off was superb. She helped with every wish, with all and any arrangements including activities and dinner recommendations. The property was super, super clean, grounds well maintained and the living space for the 8 of us was a perfect layout. Great large island table with seating for 10. Plenty of seating area inside and out and the back yard was very peaceful with the running waterfall in the pool. Two front decks to enjoy your coffee from or WINE. You are on Duval Street at the southern point so there is some light noise from the morning street sweepers, navy planes and of course ROASTERS! Nothing that interrupted your sleep or I would deduct from this rating. Wonder location! Highly recommended!

Submitted by Woodridge IL on Feb 09, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much of the kind review of Grand Maison ~ and of our Cindy! We hope you'll put Key West (and us!) on your yearly rotation. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

great experience

The wife and I had a great 5 night stay at the Horse Conch. It was clean and had plenty of room for the two of us. We enjoyed afternoon swims in the pool after a day exploring Old Town. The location was easily within walking distance to our favorite Key West shops, restaurants, and entertainment!

Submitted by Kure Beach NC on Feb 08, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Horse Conch and hope you'll come enjoy some more Key West time with us! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Azur Palm-Oceanfront Monthly Rental

5.0

azur palm

Azur Palm is a beautifully decorated condo with all the amenities you need for a home away from home vacation. A peaceful retreat to enjoy from sunrise to sunset listening to the ocean gently crashing against the shoreline. The location is perfect, far enough from busy Duval, but close enough to walk to the Southernmost Point.

Submitted by Glenview IL on Feb 05, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the nice, descriptive review of Azur Palm! We hope you'll come and enjoy living like a local again soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

great stay and great location

Great location. Quiet Street but close to Duvall.
Nice room. The porch was great and relaxing.

Submitted by Pemberville OH on Feb 04, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you, Stacey, for your review of Poinciana Garden! We agree that the location is great! The new porch is getting rave reviews as well. We hope to see you again soon in sunny Key West! The Team at HKWVR

Maisons de Luxe - Nightly Group Rental

5.0

wonderful vacation

Great location, Pictures DONT do it justice!! The entire experience was top notch.

Submitted by Pennsauken NJ on Feb 03, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice thing to say ~ we hope you'll come and stay with us again! Anytime. ~Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Rooster Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

rooster conch

Pretty "dog-gone" good.

Submitted by Pittsboro IN on Feb 02, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review and we hope you'll come and stay with us again. We promise we'll fetch more nice reviews from you! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

great location

Management was exellent.

Submitted by Newtown CT on Jan 27, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you, Bruce, for your 5 star review of Horse Conch! We agree that it is in an excellent location. The outdoor area is fabulous. We strive for satisfied guests and hope you will stay with us again soon! The Team at HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

small but tidy apartment with great location

Great location, small but tidy apartment, comfortable furnishings, lack of space in bedroom and bath but nothing you can't work around, no dishwasher (wasn't important for me but would be if you cooked a lot), washer dryer is shared with downstairs renters and was nice to have, very impressed with communication with Historic Key West Vacation rentals.

Submitted by Nashville TN on Jan 23, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your review of Poinciana Treetop. It sounds like you had a pretty good experience overall! The location is certainly a highlight, and it’s fantastic that you found the furnishings comfortable. Space is a valuable commodity in Key West, and we are glad that Poinciana Treetop offers just enough to make it a comfortable stay. Communication is key, so it’s awesome that Historic Key West Vacation Rentals was impressive in that regard. We hope to see you again soon! The Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

relax

We loved the unit and the location. Clean, newly remodeled, just the right size for two people. The garden, pool area was so quaint, quiet and relaxing. A couple small items, the grill needs a face lift and some attention. People should know it is a coin operated laundry so you can bring quarters with you. The unit itself could use a few more dishes, I.e. stoatge dishes for left overs, martini, on the rocks and a cocktail shaker. We stayed three weeks so it gives one a different perspective than just a couple overnights. The bike rack was a nightmare. One of the gentlemen that stays there parks his car on top of them so it is soooo hard to get in and out. Overall I would definitely recommend this cottage for a KW visit.

Submitted by Columbia TN on Jan 23, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for sharing your feedback! We're glad to hear that you loved the property and the location. We appreciate your suggestions regarding the grill and the need for additional kitchen items. It's always helpful to know what could enhance the experience for future guests. We're sorry to hear about the challenges with the bike rack. Your insights from a three-week stay are incredibly valuable, and we’re glad to know you would recommend the cottage to others visiting Key West. We hope to see you again soon~ The Team at HKWVR

Grand Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

fantastic experience

What a great home-base from which to explore Key West and relax. The location on the quiet end of Duval is convenient to restaurants, shops and the beach. The management company (Historic Key West Properties) is very professional and easy to work with and its concierge services provided excellent recommendations and seamlessly arranged a golf cart and bikes for us.

The house itself was spotless, well furnished and thoughtfully arranged. The four bedrooms, all with ensuite baths, fit our group of 6 perfectly. The outdoor space, complete with pool, was a favorite hangout spot for our adult children and their friends. It's one of those houses you walk by and think "What a great place to stay, wish we'd booked that" - and this time we did! Highly recommend!

Submitted by Weston MA on Jan 22, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time with us at Dreaming on Duval. We can't wait for you to come back and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

fabulous & private

Great property. We were very comfortable & it’s very convenient to walk to everywhere we wanted to go.
Beds were comfy.
Only downside was noise. The pool backs onto a bike/golf cart rental yard & their music and repair noises were pretty loud during the afternoons.

Submitted by Plymouth MA on Jan 16, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind and honest review of Chick-a-Pea Cottage. We are sorry about the noise, but the good news is it's during the day. :) Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

great location

We loved this unit. The location is fabulous-right in the middle of Old Town, most everything is an easy walk. The unit is charming and the neighborhood is peaceful and quiet, a nice porch light and motion sensor lights make you feel safe and welcome when coming home late. The bed and furnishings are very comfortable. It was great to have the washer/dryer on site. Seriously consider renting bikes for your stay-they make the whole island accessible without needling a car (parking very limited).

Submitted by Piqua OH on Jan 15, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of Solaris Garden ~ and we agree, bikes are best on Key West (did I just invent a new slogan?). Please come and stay with us again, any time! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

butterfly cottage

This was a lovely rental. The kitchen was fully stocked and the bedrooms were very comfortable. We loved having the hot tub! Plus, the location was close to great restaurants and shopping.

Submitted by Omaha NE on Jan 14, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a kind review of Butterfly Cottage! We hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again, soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

another wonderful experience with hkw rental

This rental service provides professional, responsive, informative service every time. Our home away from home was clean and stocked with exactly what they promised. Location was great and every staff/service person we encountered was courteous. Highly recommended.
Location was perfect.
This particular house is a bit noisy inside...due to few rugs, lack of insulation, and other design/structural aspects. We had 6 adults so it was tolerable but glad we didn’t have kids to put down for naps/bed. ;)

Submitted by Caledonia MI on Jan 13, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind and honest review of Chavez House ~ we hadn't heard this before but we will take a look into it, and when you come back tell us how we did. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

great trip and great home

Ever lovely home, great location. I will definitely rent again.

Submitted by Venice FL on Jan 12, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope you're already making plans to come and see us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

close to everything , yet quiet.

Great location. Near restaurants and the water, yet quiet.

Submitted by Minneapolis MN on Jan 12, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We're thrilled you enjoyed your time at Poinciana Garden! Please tell us when you're coming back and so we can make your stay a full 5 star! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

amazing upstairs apartment

We stayed in this adorable one bedroom apartment over the Christmas holidays. It was clean, cozy and perfect for us and our little dog. The fenced in backyard and bike racks were an added plus. We loved sitting out on the balcony in the evenings for happy hour and the location was perfect. We will definitely book with Historic Key West Rentals again and again and again!

Submitted by Ft Lauderdale FL on Jan 11, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy the whole family enjoyed their time at Poinciana Treetop! We can't wait for you to come back ~ we love seeing happy, familiar faces! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

just lovely!

We absolutely loved our stay at the Sea Conch. The location was amazing, close to all the shops and restaurants, and within walking distance of nearly everything. The parking space next to the house was also phenomenal. The inside was charming, spacious, and very comfortable. Our children loved the heated pool out back and we spent many evenings enjoying the beautiful trees and plants and cozy covered patio out back. It was just wonderful.

Submitted by Lake Worth FL on Jan 07, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You make your stay sound magical ~ and we are happy Sea Conch was part of that! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

The Pink House - Monthly Rental

5.0

pink house - december 2024

Very pleasant stay. The property is perfectly located on a quiet street in the center of old town. Short distance to all must see attractions and popular restaurants. Focal point is definitely the lush landscaped backyard with enjoyable deck area and heated pool. Two parking spaces are a plus. The property is well maintained and well stocked with expendable supplies. Property management company is extremely professional and quick to respond to any issues.

Submitted by Carrollton VA on Jan 04, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind review of The Pink House! It sounds like you enjoyed your time 'living like a local' in Key West. Hope we'll see you again next year! And maybe even sooner. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

key west

Place was really nice and great location. Management company provided clear instructions and were easy to work with.

Submitted by Brooklyn Park MN on Jan 04, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That is so nice to hear! We hope you'll come and enjoy some more Key West time with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

awesome!

Beautiful apartment, close to everything and a great pool area.

Submitted by Maumelle AR on Jan 04, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are happy that you enjoyed your time at Horse Conch! We hope you'll come and stay with us again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

location, location, location!

This was the ideal property for our stay! Being 1 block off of Duval and able to walk to just about everything we wanted to experience made this rental perfect. Our 2 kiddos especially loved the ability to swim 2-3 times a day too!

Submitted by Wichita KS on Jan 03, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That sounds like the perfect vacation! Hope you'll come and stay with us again, and often! ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Solaris Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great stay

Great home/location - no complaints

Submitted by Orlando FL on Jan 03, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That's so nice to hear! We thank you kindly for taking the time to review us. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Solaris Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

cozy hide-a-way

We enjoyed our stay in this cute and comfy rental, that was tucked away on a side street, just a couple from the action on Duval St. We enjoyed the front porch every day, sipping coffee/drinks, reading quietly, made possible by the privacy fence and bushes. We used the kitchen every day, perfect for starting and ending our days with home cooked meals. Although we never did use it, there is a cute courtyard out back with grill, table/chairs. The air conditioning kept us nice and cool. The shower felt great each day.
During the day we roamed around the city, taking in the sights, hit the beach, checked out local preserves, sipped at the local watering holes.
There are plenty of touristy things to do, such as museums, trolley, conch train, drag shows... and more shopping than you can imagine.
As for parking, it was easy and we scored a spot right around the corner every day, just steps from the rental.
Need to know: the neighborhood rooster makes his presence known each morning; however the broom on the front porch will help to shoo him away.
Pack your bag, stop to get groceries and you’re good to go!

Submitted by Gorham ME on Dec 29, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Your description of Solaris Cottage is fabulous ~ thank you for taking the time to let everyone know what a nice time you had! We hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

xmas trip

Great stay

Submitted by Easton MD on Dec 28, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are happy to hear you had a great time at Villa Josine. Please tell us when you're coming back again ~ we'd love to see you anytime. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Casablanca Too - Nightly Rental

5.0

excellent review

It was excellent. The house is lovely. Nicely renovated kitchen and common areas. Parking spots are VERY convenient. Loved having the small outdoor space with grill. Wonderful location. Very kind and proactive host!

Submitted by Houston TX on Dec 27, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay at Casablanca Too. We hope we can see you again and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect kw stay

Potter’s cottage is the perfect location if you want to experience all kinds of Key West attractions. Everything is walkable from this spot and it was also quiet at night for sleeping. The house was well equipped, clean and provided plenty of space for four adults. We enjoyed the backyard every day of our stay from coffee and breakfast in the morning to afternoon pool time and then late night card playing with cocktails. We had a great time!!

Submitted by Indianapolis IN on Dec 17, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of Potter's Cottage! For everyone who doesn't know, you can see the exact location of the home/s under the calendar/s so you can see how close it is. We are ready for you to come back and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Paradise - Group Rental

5.0

great stay for a group!

We met a group of friends in Key West and it was nice to have separate spaces but one place to stay. The back yard area was nice to gather together each day. Close to Duvall and everything we needed. The place was clean, the beds were very comfortable, and the kitchen had everything we needed to grab a quick breakfast.

Submitted by Olympia WA on Dec 17, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a kind review ~ thank you so much! We hope you'll come and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

poinciana stay just perfect

Poinciana Treetop in Key West was just perfect....Old Florida vibe....pristine...quiet yet close to Duvall...comfortable with easy access to everything wonderful about Key West!!!! And Emma at KW Vacations was the best!!!

Submitted by Venice FL on Dec 11, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review ~ and we agree, Emma IS the best! Please come and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

great location!

Location was very convenient!

Submitted by Annapolis MD on Dec 10, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That is fabulous to hear! We hope you'll be back to stay with us, soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Pair-A-Dise - Nightly Rental

5.0

great retreat

Excellent location, quiet, comfortable. We rented both units so the shared outdoor space was perfect for our needs.

Submitted by Louisville KY on Dec 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

This sounds like a lovely stay at Solaris Pair-a-Dise (Solaris Garden and Solaris Cottage) and we hope you'll all come back and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

great family trip

Somehow the pictures don't do the house justice - it is huge! We spread out across three floors and it was wonderful. Grandparents in the main level master, parents with kids on the second floor, and another couple upstairs. We only had 8 but could certainly sleep many more. The pool was perfect size for toddler kids to swim back and forth and great for older folks to soak in too. The management company is incredibly responsive and helpful. I was worried about noise on Duval but it wasn't an issue at all - its a quieter end of the street. 10/10 would stay again!

Submitted by Arlington VA on Dec 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

10/10 we expect you to come back soon! Thank you for the kind review ~ I think it gives future Dreaming on Duval guests an idea of how wonderful the home is. We look forward to seeing you again soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place to stay!

We enjoyed the Butterfly Cottage, it was beautiful and we enjoyed our coffee every morning on the deck.

Submitted by Chester VA on Dec 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Coffee on the deck every morning sounds lovely! We hope you'll take these memories with you and then come and make some more. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

best kept secret!

My wife and I absolutely loved our stay at La Maisonnette, in Key West, FL. The condo was well appointed, close to all major attractions and nestled on a side-street away from major traffic. The communication prior to arrival was likely the best part! The management company communicated all important steps to the check in process and provided us with an abundance of details.

Submitted by Cape Coral FL on Nov 26, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of La Maisonnette! We hope you'll come and stay with us again (and give us another awesome review)! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great long weekend - butterfly cottage in key west

Wrapping up a fantastic stay at Butterfly Cottage. One couple plus our friend. Total comfort for three. Would have also been fine with a fourth. Let’s just say that we couldn’t keep talking about how well done this layout was. Two king ensuite bedrooms. Kitchen with island and every conceivable necessity for a weekend trip. Coffee maker. Ice maker. Disposal. All drawers were labeled. All outlets were labeled. All doors had these little clear wall bumpers to protect but also prevent mishaps. The wrap around deck was great. Privacy if we wanted individual sides of the deck. Multiple sitting areas, a hot tub, exterior laundry. Off street parking. We were told parking for a small car. We rented a small SUV which fit fine. But we also had a few scooters we rented on island and a four seater cart. Room for all vehicles. Attentive staff via text message not so much because we needed anything but because they just checked in on us periodically. Even accommodated an early check in. All in all a great stay at a great property. We’ve used other rental companies in the past but will 100% be booking them again.

Submitted by Pittsburgh PA on Nov 25, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We cannot wait until your next visit ~ and thank you for the great rundown about Butterfly. We think it will help other guests' making a future decision. Now please hurry back! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Serene Lily - Weekly Rental

5.0

second visit.

We love Serene Lily. This is our second time staying there and it was great. Great location, well-maintained, mostly quiet, comfortable. We’re likely to return.

Submitted by Boyds MD on Nov 20, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Third time is the charm, so if you enjoyed your first two times, think how much you'll enjoy your third! Hope it's sooner than later. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Maisons de Luxe - Nightly Group Rental

5.0

great complex

Our group of 10 rented Maisons de Luxe and it was perfect! We spent the day lounging by the pool and grilling and the nights out on Duval. Was a little worried being right on Duval but the house is very well insulated and could hear absolutely zero street noise late at night or in the morning. Beautiful property that was well maintained and spotless. Will definitely stay here again!

Submitted by Washington NJ on Nov 18, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are already looking forward to your next stay and hope it's very soon! Thank you for taking the time to give Maisons de Luxe such a kind review. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

dreaming on duval

Fabulous property - very spacious and warm. All the comforts of home with ample seating for a meal, an outdoor conversation or gathering in the den.

Submitted by Kernersville NC on Nov 16, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Dreaming on Duval! We hope everyone will come back for some more making memories Key West time. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Grand Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place

Beautiful home with great location to experience all that KW has to offer.

Submitted by Rock Hill SC on Nov 12, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for a great review of Grand Maison! We hope we'll see you again in the near future. And then again after that! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

potters cottage

Charming cottage-KW vibes! Cottage is in a great location-walkable to Southernmost, action on Duval, great restaurants and Higgs Beach.

A quiet respite as well if you choose. Indoor decor was comfortable and well maintained-especially loved the cozy side library space. The pool was the perfect size with lots of sunny areas and cozy shaded seating-ceiling fans were a huge plus.

Communication from management company throughout the booking and stay was fantastic. We will be back!

Submitted by Newport KY on Nov 07, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are already looking forward to seeing you again ~ you now have a vacation home here in Key West with us! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

The Pink House - Monthly Rental

5.0

the pink dream

Review of “The Pink House”
As we crossed the threshold of the Pink House and laid eyes on the conch shell door knocker we knew we were in for a special stay.
This home is decorated throughout with a very special attention to detail.
Kudos to the lead decorator ��.
The well appointed kitchen is quite the place to gather to cook, relax and laugh.
The kitchen separates 2 living rooms with one used for total relaxation and reading and the other for laughter and making the special memories with a nice TV in the background.
The 2 large bedrooms upstairs are absolutely wonderful and the large walk in closet was a huge surprise.
Relaxing outside surrounded by palm trees and a lovely scenic pool with a separate cocktail pool for gathering around reminded us that we were indeed staying in a special slice of paradise.
It is quite the spot to reminisce about the days gone by.
To the owner of “The Pink House”, thank you !!
To our friends at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals, we appreciate all of your help and also all of the important updates and for the ongoing pool maintenance and the handling of all the cans to the curb on trash day.
You are one very high end organization focused on all of your renters so thank you very much.
Sincerely,
John and Christine Kelly
Pitman, New Jersey

Submitted by Pitman NJ on Nov 03, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

John & Christine ~ What a lovely review and we thank you so much for taking the time. I have shared your review with everyone. We are looking forward to seeing you again, and hope you know you have a vacation home here in Key West with us anytime! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

nice, quiet place

This is a great place to stay if you want to be close by all the fun stuff but away from the noise. The management company is very responsive.

Submitted by Madison Heights VA on Nov 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for a great review of Poinciana Treetop! We hope we'll see you again in the near future. And then again after that! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect stay in key west

The home is a classic key west historic home! So much love is put into the restoration and maintenance of this home. 3 couples stayed for 5 nights. Two couples who travel well together didn’t mind the close quarters upstairs in the jack n Jill bathroom. We also had a quarter bathroom in the laundry room to use & the men loved the outdoor urinal. The pool was perfect for late night swims & morning dips with a cup of coffee. Large parking spot for our car and a back gated area for our bikes. The kitchen has everything we needed. The management organized everything perfectly for us. Cheers to house keeping because this house was the cleanest home I have ever rented. This home brought us so much joy, even a few friends who stopped by to say hi were so in love with it. The location was amazing, 5-20 minute bike ride to everything in the heart of key west, far enough to enjoy the quiet mornings.

Submitted by Tukwila WA on Oct 29, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We and the owners of Southard Comfort thank you for taking the time to review the home so kindly! We hope you'll all come back and make some more memories with us ~ we love seeing happy, familiar faces! Our housekeepers say 'thank you' as well (we love them!). ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

what a beautiful place

Everything in the house was as described. Well appointed and conveniently located. Management very easy to contact and responsive.

Submitted by York PA on Oct 28, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a lovely review for Chavez House! We hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Grand Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect house

This house was amazing in every way! Great location. Well equipped and decorated. It was the perfect place for a friends getaway. I’d go back in a heartbeat!

Submitted by Catonsville MD on Oct 24, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Our hearts are beating with anticipation~ please hurry back! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Rooster Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

happy honeymoon

We enjoyed our stay at Rooster Conch. Lovely unit and location. Great customer service. Loved the breezes on the covered porch. The lady who cleans does a super job.

Submitted by Lake Lure NC on Oct 22, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for taking the time to review Rooster Conch ~ I've let our housekeeper know you mentioned her/them because they work hard to make us look good! Please come back ~ maybe for your anniversary (or before?)? ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

amazing location and well maintained home

We were 8 friends that spent a few days touring Key West. We had an amazing time!

Submitted by Richmond Hill NY on Oct 21, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope everyone's already making plans to come to Key West and make some more memories! We're here when you're ready! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

charming house in a great spot

This house is perfect for families and couples. The downstairs and outdoor area offer plenty of room, the pool is excellent, and the location is close enough to Duval but also far enough that you're protected a little from the insanity. We've stayed in Key West a number of years and Historic KWVR is the best host we've had by far. Thank you!

Submitted by Atlanta GA on Oct 19, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We thank you so much for taking the time to say such nice things about Southard Comfort, and us! We hope we'll see you again, and soon, and often! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

generational trip

This was the best house and location. Two blocks from duval street so nearby to walk to many places but far enough not to hear the noise. The company was fantastic and so responsive. We had a couple of minor issues and they were at the door almost before I hung up the phone. We would definitely go back and encourage anyone to rent this villa.

Submitted by Cary NC on Oct 18, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time in Key West and hope we'll see you again soon! We don't like issues but are glad you brought them up for us to rectify as quickly as we could. ~Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

absolutely perfect!

Our family of 9 ranging from 14 to 77 yrs old enjoyed this lovely property while in Key West for our Granddaughter’s wedding. Everyone had their “own space” and the location was perfect for walking almost anywhere we wanted to go. I have to confess, this is a picky bunch ��and Everyone Was Thrilled!

Submitted by Richmond TX on Oct 15, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear *everyone* enjoyed Dreaming on Duval! We hope you'll come back again, maybe for another joyful event. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect key west rental

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at this charming key west home. Location was quiet but still walking distance to many Key West attractions. Home was clean and comfortable with a wonderful small pool to keep us cool in key west humidity.
Owner was attentive to our needs and saftey as a hurricane approached Florida.

Submitted by Newport KY on Oct 10, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It's so nice to hear you enjoyed Southard Comfort ~ we think it's a wonderful home as well. Come again next year! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

fall trip 2024

Very cute, clean, spacious, well stocked and so convenient to everything!

Submitted by Cumming GA on Oct 09, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We agree with you 100%! Thank you for taking the time for the kind review. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

just returned from 5 day stay

Wonderful 5 day getaway with parents and 2 adult couple children.3 full size bedrooms were perfect.Great service and communication with the mgnt. team before and during stay. House was just as described,plenty big for 6 adults, nicely decorated Key West Vibe, spotlessly clean and ready before our check in time. Perfect location, walk or bike to all attractions,restaurants. Quiet neighborhood.Bikes were delivered ready upon arrival. Can't say enough good things about our stay. Bring your family here , you'll love it . Already looking for next year.

Submitted by Landenberg PA on Oct 09, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind words about Chavez House ... and us! We can't wait until next year either! We love seeing happy, familiar faces. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

great little oasis

This is a fabulous rental. Very clean and tidy with everything you need. Decor is great too and up to date. The pool is a bonus too. Location is perfect and we didn’t have any issues parking our golf cart on the street. Would definitely stay here again!

Submitted by Bolton CT on Oct 08, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope you'll stay with us again! We are happy to hear you enjoyed your time in Key West at La Maisonnette. ~ Jennifer & Team@ HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

incredible dream stay!

My wife and I stayed at Poinciana Treetop and it was the best decision we made. Clean, plenty of space for us, and made us really our stay amongst the locals of Key West. The team at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals were very responsive and helped us with any questions and concerns we had.

Submitted by Bowie MD on Oct 07, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice review and it's wonderful to hear you enjoyed your time! We hope you're already making plans to come and make some more memories in Key West. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

40th birthday surprise!

This was my first time to key west and this house definitely elevated our experience! The 3 main bedrooms were super spacious and the communal spaces, both indoor & outdoor, were great especially for our party of 10. Despite the property being directly on Duval street, once inside or in the backyard, you felt very private. The rental company were lovely to work with every step along the way and even checked in during our actual stay.

Submitted by Glenwood NJ on Oct 03, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to have been a part of your first time in Key West! We look forward to your second! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

couldn’t be better

Exactly as described on line. Management company communications were perfect. Location made it walkable to the Hemmingway House, Mallory Square, the Truman Little White Hoyse, Duval Street shopping, and several great restaurants.

Submitted by Cumming GA on Oct 03, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Lilly's Pad and can't wait for your return! Please make it soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect getaway in key west

The location is ideal, you are just blocks from Duval Street. The house was impeccable. There was more than enough room for all of us. The backyard/pool area was gorgeous and secluded. It was your own little paradise. I would highly recommend!

Submitted by Fort Myers FL on Oct 01, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a fabulous way to describe Villa Josine! I've let our housekeepers know you described it as 'impeccable' ~ they work so hard to keep our homes in that condition. We're glad you noticed. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Pair-A-Dise - Nightly Rental

5.0

loved it

Everything was perfect, location, the units were very clean, walking distance to everything. Patio was lovely. Communication from management company was so helpful!

Submitted by Hollywood FL on Sep 28, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again! Thank you for the kind review of Solaris Pair-a-Dise ~ we want all of our guests to be this happy. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

beautiful stay for a 60th birthday week!

Historic Key West Vacation Rentals provided a great experience before, during and after our stay at Cloud Nine. The location provided a private retreat while being conveniently located to all Key West offers. The house, courtyard and pool were perfect for a birthday celebration for a family of 6. The house was spacious, clean, and whimsically chic.

Submitted by Fayetteville AR on Sep 28, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice way to describe Cloud 9! We hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again, and soon! Whose birthday is next? ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

this is it!

Perfectly clean and great location!

Submitted by Hawthorne FL on Sep 28, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so kindly for the nice review of Horse Conch! We hope you'll come and stay with us again ~ remember, you can bring the whole crew (up to 14 people!) at Queen Conch. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Maisons de Luxe - Nightly Group Rental

5.0

perfect getaway

We just ended the most perfect friends getaway. The location of this property is perfect if you want to just park your car and experience Key West. We rented scooters / golf carts 1.5 blocks away. Everything else was well within walking distance. This property is laid out very well. There are 4 bedrooms in the main house all with their own bathrooms. Note that one bedroom has 2 twin beds which cannot be rearranged. An additional 2 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms, kitchen, living, and balcony are in the guest house. A private tropical oasis is situated between both homes with a pool and plenty of lounge chairs to enjoy the sun. A covered porch with tv was perfect for watching football. The property was clean and the management was quick to respond with any questions. Check in process was easy. Bananas is a great breakfast place located directly across the street. La-Te-Da is an amazing restaurant for dinner and drinks. You can arrive in Key West via car or plane. We were not aware that United and American flew jets into this island. We will definitely be back.

Submitted by Montverde FL on Sep 24, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind and thoughtful review of Maisons de Luxe and Key West! We are hoping you're making plans to come and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

paradise!

Beautiful home and excellent location! The property management personnel were so helpful in planning our activities leading up to the trip. The pool area was a highlight for all!! Will be back!

Submitted by New Milford CT on Sep 23, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It sounds like you had fun at Chick-a-Pea Cottage. We hope you'll come and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect paradise

We couldn't of selected a better rental to stay in. Everything was perfect from location, description of the rental, attention to detail, customer service! I would recommend this location to friends and family! Keep the good work up!

Submitted by Middle Grove NY on Sep 19, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you, Keith, for taking the time to review your stay at Potter's Cottage! We strive for guest satisfaction, attention to detail, and communication- and we are so glad you noticed! We hope to see you again soon in sunny Key West~ Lori and the HKWVR Team

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

great stay

Location was great. No complaints

Submitted by Quincy IL on Sep 19, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you, John, for taking the time to review your stay at Solaris Garden. We agree that it is a great location! We hope to see you again soon in Key West~ Lori and the HKWVR Team

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

slice of heaven

Poinciana was the most beautiful little home. We fell inlove pulling up. It was fresh and warm! The bed was so comfortable! We slept like babies. Which is odd because we never do away from our own bed. The a/c unit was fabulous. It kept the place cool but also dry. Humidity is insane. But inside I was cool and not sticky. Not even the floors. The washer and dryer was a super plus. We just loved everything about this place. Will forever stay here when visiting KW. Ohhh. . Let's not forget it has PARKING!

Submitted by Salem VA on Sep 18, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You are right ~ Poinciana Treetop does have parking ~ plus comfort and glorious A/C! We are looking forward to your next stay, and then the next, forever! Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

beautiful comfy home

The home we stayed in exceeded my expectations. The pictures on the website looked nice, but once we entered the home, we were very happy. The bedrooms were large and comfortable. The living area was also large and very comfortable, and the pool was absolutely perfect a very private oasis. Most important was how clean home was. Although we never actually met property management in person, they were completely friendly and very accommodating.

Submitted by Berkeley Springs WV on Sep 13, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a kind review of Villa Josine (and of us!). We look forward to your next stay, and we hope it's soon. More memories need to be made here in Key West! Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

butterfly cottage beauty

Awesome place to stay! It was beautifully done and very close to everything.

Submitted by Tampa FL on Sep 09, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the nice review of Butterfly Cottage! Come back and make some more Key West memories with us! Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Pair-A-Dise - Nightly Rental

5.0

so much fun in key west

We absolutely loved our stay in Key West, the house was wonderful, with the 2 separate apartment style rooms downstairs we were able to have privacy and time spent with my parents. They stayed in the back room with the beautiful garden area, and we stayed in the front. A golf cart fit perfectly in the small parking area and was great for getting around all week. The house location is perfect for quite peaceful time, and just minutes from all the fun and noise of Duvall Street. The house was clean and provided everything we needed. Definitely on our visit again list. The management concierge team was so helpful and kind to deal with, they helped us book our excursions, golf cart and even provided lots of information and suggestions.

Submitted by Cleveland GA on Sep 09, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We're so happy you enjoyed yourself at Solaris Pair-a-Dise and hope you'll all come back and stay with us again! Or you can come and stay in either Solaris Garden or Solaris Cottage. We love seeing happy, familiar faces! Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place

a great place in a great location

Submitted by Chevy Chase MD on Sep 06, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for taking the time to review Villa Josine! We hope you'll come back and make some more memories in Key West! Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

best little rental in kw

We loved the Butterfly Cottage. It was super convenient, completely updated and precious. The beds were extremely comfortable and the outside sitting area was a great place to wind down. We would definitely stay here again!

Submitted by Denham Springs LA on Sep 04, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of Butterfly Cottage ~ we love having nice guests in our home, so you are welcome back anytime! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

chick-a-pea was perfect

The house is so cozy and nice. The beds were amazing! And the management staff was the best ever! I absolutely loved staying there. It was so close to everything and the house was so awesome, cozy and private.

Submitted by Parkland FL on Sep 04, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Well, thank you for the kind review of Chick-a-Pea Cottage ~ and us! We think you were a great guest as well and are already looking forward to your next visit (please make it soon)! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

peaceful vacation!!

The house is amazing. Great for a large group and set up for hosting for sure. The location is perfect. We had an amazing time.

Submitted by Allen TX on Sep 03, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice review and we're thrilled you enjoyed your time at Dreaming on Duval! Please come back again soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

southard comfort is an a+

Amazing home in a great location of Old Town! This property has everything you need and close to several good restaurants and a convenience store close by. This place does have an off-street parking spot, but all you need are bikes down there that you can rent from a place a few blocks away. This property is definitely worth booking short or long term!

Submitted by Omaha NE on Aug 31, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Southard Comfort ~ and agree that bikes (or golf carts) are the best way to get around and explore the island! Please tell us when you're coming back ~ we'd love to have you! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

lovely place to stay!

Wonderful! Loved the artwork. House was very cool. Easy to walk to town - about 5 minutes. HKWVR was extremely accommodating, especially Aubrey. It was too hot to use the back patio area and grill, but it is so quaint!

Submitted by Cincinnati OH on Aug 28, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So nice to hear you enjoyed your time at Solaris Garden! We hope you're already making plans to come and stay again. Year round is great in Key West, but fall/winter is nice for the deck! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

definitely lived up to the name!

The property was exactly as described and as shown in the photos. It was a wonderful, comfortable and very clean home. Can't say enough good things about it!

Submitted by Huntersville NC on Aug 26, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind review of Cloud 9! We can't wait for you to come and stay with us again (hopefully soon)! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Pair-A-Dise - Nightly Rental

5.0

awesome

Excellent rental , well furnished, close to many restaurants and things to do , I would stay here again

Submitted by Las Vegas NV on Aug 20, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope that your next stay will be soon! Thank you for your kind words about Solaris Pair-a-Dise. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

awesome!!!!

We have stayed at this property several times and look forward to coming back every year. Perfect house, perfect location, perfect everything!!!!! Historic Key West Vacation Rentals is alway great to deal with!

Submitted by Jeffersonville PA on Aug 19, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for being a repeat guest (we value you!) and for the kind words about Dreaming on Duval (and about us!)! We can't wait for your next visit! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Maisons de Luxe - Nightly Group Rental

5.0

3 generations celebrating 80th birthday

Perfect house for 12 people. Pool and covered porch were great for hanging out. Really nice to have en-suite bathrooms for each room.

Submitted by Houston TX on Aug 14, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Maisons de Luxe ~ together and separately! Please tell us when you're coming back for more good times. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

amazing stay!

We had 6 in our group and we will definitely be back! The pool and outdoor sitting area was a perfect bonus to our wonderful vacation in Key West. Chick-a-Pea Cottage is conveniently located to all the great spots.

Submitted by Oxford MS on Aug 07, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So glad to hear Chick-a-Pea Cottage was a great part of your vacation! We look forward to your coming back and making more memories! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Queen Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

great family vacation spot

We had an absolutely fantastic stay at this vacation rental! It was the perfect spot for our family getaway. The house was spacious, providing plenty of room for everyone to have their own cozy corners and spots to relax. We loved gathering in the large living area for family games and movie nights. The kitchens were fully equipped, making it a joy to cook meals together.

The location couldn't have been better. We were close to everything—shops, restaurants, and local attractions were all just a short walk away. It made exploring the area so convenient.

One of our favorite features was the outdoor space. We enjoyed morning coffee on the patio and evening swims in the backyard. The kids had a blast playing games outside while we relaxed and took in the serene surroundings.

Overall, this rental was perfect for creating cherished family memories. We can't wait to return! Highly recommended for anyone looking for a comfortable, well-located spot for a family vacation.

Submitted by Wilmington NC on Aug 05, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We can't wait for you to return and make some more memories, either! Please come again, soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Grand Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

great house

The Grand Maison meet all of our expectations and then more. HKWVR staff was so nice and helpful. They went out of the way to help us with our bags when we arrived in Key West. Very satisfied with the location. Location across from the Banana Cafe and La Grignote. Both great places to eat. We enjoy the Duval Loop Bus (which was free and was AC). Can't wait to go back!!!

Submitted by Nashville NC on Aug 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That's so nice to read that you enjoyed your time at Grand Maison and all of its perfectness. The Duval Loop Bus is such a great way to get around, and out of the heat. We're looking forward to your next stay! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Tropical Dream - Monthly Rental

5.0

tropical dream

We had a great time at the place.

Submitted by Shinnston WV on Jul 30, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That is wonderful to hear! Come back and spend time like a local in paradise again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

kw getaway

Perfect hide away and perfect location
For all activity. House is new. Clean and outstanding.

Submitted by Pembroke Pines FL on Jul 29, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We're so happy to hear you enjoyed Butterfly Cottage! We think it's a great home as well. Please come back soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect for couples

Perfect little getaway for two couples. Had all the amenities we needed. King beds were comfortable. Would come back!

Submitted by Fern Park FL on Jul 29, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Petite Maison! Hope you'll all come and stay with us again soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

great vacation spot for family or just a nice couple trip!

Nice and very clean up to date! Had everything we need private fence in and just a block away from all the excitement of Duval Street.

Submitted by Port Orange FL on Jul 25, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Poinciana Garden! Hope you'll come and stay with us again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Serene Lily - Weekly Rental

5.0

kw for our party of 5

Absolutely perfect location - for a family of 5. We loved all the details in the home from the extra towels to the beautiful decorations. It was such a nice week spent in Truman Annex. Our first time in KW did not disappoint.

Submitted by Highland Hs OH on Jul 21, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are happy to hear your first time here went so well! We hope it won't be your last! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

summer getaway

We absolutely loved this house!! Great location, steps to Duval but still a quiet street. A lovely, clean little place with all the comforts of home. The pool is the perfect temp on a hot summer day and the property is very well kept.
The property managers were not only super nice but they are available to help with any questions or concerns at any time. They even offered to find us accommodations if we missed our flight due to the cyber outage. Which for us was not necessary as we arrived by boat. Great people !
We had a fantastic stay and can't wait to visit this adorable house again !!

Submitted by Naples FL on Jul 21, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We can't wait for your next stay! Please let us know when you're coming (we hope it's soon). Thank you for the kind review of Chick-a-Pea Cottage! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKVWV

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

exceptional property and property management

We had a great experience at the Petite Maison! The location was perfectly located off Duval Street, south of all the hectic part. Perfect for walking everywhere. The property was well maintained and true to the pictures displayed. The property management was attentive and very helpful. We would definitely rebook in the future.

Submitted by Kansas City MO on Jul 21, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are already looking forward to your next visit with us! Please make it soon. Thank you for taking the time to review Petite Maison so kindly. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Casablanca Too - Nightly Rental

5.0

great

Location, privacy and cleanliness was top notch. Communication and check in/out were great. Beautiful property with lots of privacy and outdoor space.

Submitted by Dallas TX on Jul 17, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your kind review of Casablanca Too! We are so happy that you enjoyed your stay and hope to see you again soon! Lori @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

fantastic location and beautiful home

Dreaming on Duval was walking distance to most everything , but we did rent a golf cart through HKWVR. The furnishings were both comfortable (including all the beds)and beautiful. Space was great for our extended family of 10. We loved people watching from the front porch, cooling off in the pool, and walking to dinner, shopping and many sightseeing stops. Management company was excellent with communication.

Submitted by Reydon OK on Jul 15, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you, Stacy, for your excellent review of Dreaming on Duval! We agree it is a great home in a fabulous location! And we are happy to hear that we communicated effectively. Come back and stay with us again soon~ Lori @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

key west getaway

We met some friends down here and had the best time! Butterfly Cottage is absolutely adorable and in a great location within walking distance to everything!

Submitted by Castle Hayne NC on Jul 10, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your kind review! We agree- Butterfly Cottage is a great home in a great location! Come back and stay with us soon~ Lori @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

quiet place just steps from duval st

I was surprised how quiet it was so close to Duval street. Place was clean and management company stayed in touch during our stay making sure we were comfortable. No contact check-in was smoother than I anticipated. We walked to Mallory Square almost every evening to watch the sunset and ate at one of the many restaurants on our walk back.

Submitted by St. Paul NC on Jul 09, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Watching the sun set at Mallory Square is one of my favorite parts of the day. So happy you got to enjoy it (a lot!). Hope we'll see you again, and soon. I'm pretty sure you have a lot more restaurants to try. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

hidden gem

We loved our week at Solaris Garden. Was perfect hideaway in easily walkable location on a quiet lane in old town. Cool, comfortable, nicely decorated, charming. Nice outdoor area with lush tropical plants.

Submitted by Lakewood CO on Jul 08, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You make Solaris Garden sound dreamy! We can't wait for you to come back ~ we hope it's soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

our week in key west

La Maisonnette in Key West was better than we anticipated.
The place is immaculate, location is perfect and the owners are on top of it, making the stay even more smooth.
I highly recommend it as we have stayed in a dozen or more places in Key West over the years.
Thanks for a great trip.
Doug and Enza
Indianapolis, In

Submitted by Indianapolis IN on Jul 08, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Doug and Enza! Thank you so much for the kind review! We are here and ready to have you come and stay with us again, anytime. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Rooster Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

amazing!

Beautiful property in a quiet safe area. We loved floating in the pool and sitting and relaxing outside under the lovely tropical plants. The unit was clean, had cute decor and everything that we needed including some pool towels. Rental company was very responsive and provided clear communication (our "neighbors" accidentally locked themselves out and they received help immediately). Would 100% stay here again!

Submitted by Indianapolis IN on Jul 05, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Isn't the pool at Rooster Conch amazing? So happy you enjoyed yourself and hope you'll be coming back again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

wawaweewa, great success!

A wise man once told me, “the sign of a great hotel (or Airbnb), is if you walk in, and it feels like you’re the 1st person to ever stay there”. Lilly’s Pad passed the test with flying colors! My group of advanced scuba divers, had an amazing stay. Everything in town was just a short meander away. Shop’s, restaurants, bars, the beach, the “scary bar on the corner of rainbow lane”.....quiet location, but close enough to the action. The communication with the staff was easy & immediate. The house was not just immaculate, but beautifully furnished, well stocked, with very comfortable beds. The outdoor area was very private and chill. I would highly recommend this home. A shout out to the Key West crew, Rhonda, Bella, “Sloppy Johnny”, Dumpster Band, Girl on the Bike at 3AM, Gorilla Girl, Traveling, Dancer with the bad contract, Stalker Sally and all the great characters we met in Key West. Amazing trip!

Submitted by Cedarhurst NY on Jul 05, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You do trips like I like to do trips. Fun with quick catchphrases to round up the whole thing! Please come and stay with us again and give us more soundbites to share. ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

great rental

We had a wonderful time at this rental. There was ample space for 4 adults. The pool environment was fantastic. The house was clean. The only downside was when there were tenants upstairs, as you could here them walking (or running kids) over your head. We would definitely stay here again.

Submitted by Hanover PA on Jul 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay at Sea Conch! It is a great home and outdoor oasis! We apologize if the guests upstairs were not respectful of the shared space- we could have reached out with a friendly reminder. We look forward to seeing you again in the future! The Team @ HKWVR

Inn Cogneato Cottage - Monthly Rental

5.0

key west experience

We thoroughly enjoyed our month stay in June 2024 at Inn Cogneato. The cottage was perfect for my wife and I and a great location. The management company Historic Key West Vacation Rentals handled our entire stay perfectly with great communications, mid-stay cleaning, and weekly pool cleans and periodic pest control. We were at Key West airport to return home on 29th June 2024 and booked up again with Historic Key West Vacation Rentals / Inn Cogneato Cottage for 2025. Thank you to everyone!

Submitted by Glasgow LKS on Jul 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your kind review of Inn Cogneato! It is a delightful cottage in a great location. We are happy that we were able to make your stay perfect and can't wait to do it again next year! See you then! The Team @ HKWVR

Villa Azul - Monthly Rental

5.0

villa azul

Great location on quiet lane. Huge mango tree on property drops fruit during mango season. Very difficult to keep deck and pool usable.

Submitted by Beaufort SC on Jul 01, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you Helen, for taking the time to review your stay at Villa Azul. We appreciate it! We apologize for the inconvenience of the mango tree- delicious fruit but very messy in season! We would have been happy to assist with cleaning them up had we known. We hope to see you again in the future! The Team @ HKWVR

Grand Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect oasis

Truly an Eden in the middle of everything!

Submitted by Sonoma CA on Jun 29, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review Grand Maison! We are happy that you enjoyed your time there and hope to see you again soon! Lori and the Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect key west stay

This place was perfect. Clean, close enough to walk everywhere, has everything and great beds. I would recommend this place to anyone.

Submitted by Huntertown IN on Jun 29, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you , Chris, for your great review of Butterfly Cottage! It's a great home in a perfect location. We hope to see you again in the future! Lori and the Team @ HKWVR

Grand Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

simply the best !

This home was everything and more that we could have asked for! We were a party of 7 celebrating a graduation! Kelly- from concierge had balloons and champagne waiting on arrival. House was beautiful, big and best location on Duval Street! Kitchen was fully equipped- we made a huge buffet breakfast one morning- pool was beautiful and perfect size for our group. My only regret is that we did not stay longer!

Submitted by Philadelphia PA on Jun 25, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We regret you couldn't stay longer as well, but that just means that you need to come back again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

amazing home in key west

Beautiful home centrally located in Key West! Living area is very spacious and the kitchen is state of the art. Company was very helpful and informative prior to our arrival and made sure to keep us updated with everything going on.

Submitted by Raleigh NC on Jun 25, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Villa Josine ~ please come and make some more memories with us, and soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Queen Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

great layout for mulitple couples!

We have stayed multiple times in the Queen Conch. The layout great so that couples or families can have their private space but also have shared spaces. We have also stayed at other proerties managed by Historic Key West Vacation Rentals and have never been disappointed. Communication and customer service is excellent.

Submitted by Bentonville AR on Jun 24, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love it every time you visit and hope you'll continue to come and make memories with us! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

great girls getaway

This was an excellent house in the most perfect location for our girls trip to Key West. The house and property are extremely well maintained. The property location is right in the heart of the Duval area. There are so many shops and restaurants with in walking distance. Our stay was perfect!

Submitted by Independence Or on Jun 18, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you had a good time at Dreaming on Duval! We hope you and the Girls will make it back (together or separately) to stay with us again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great accommodation

It was excellent. Cottage was charming.

Submitted by bloomington IN on Jun 18, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We find you charming as well! Thank you for taking the time to review us so nicely. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect! loved it! very happy!

We stayed at the Poinciana Garden 1st floor duplex for a few nights. It was very nice, extremely clean, and perfect for my husband and I. Loved having the private hot tub and the location of the property was awesome. Very happy customer and wished we could have stayed longer.

Submitted by Littleton CO on Jun 16, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We wish you could have stayed longer, too! Maybe next time you will, and we hope it's soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Grand Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

great house / great location

It was a perfect house for us and our adult children and their spouses. We all had a great time! Each bedroom had its own private ensuite bathroom. It is a beautiful home in a great location - walkable to basically everything. Both the pool/patio area and the kitchen/living room area were wonderful for our family just hanging out. We hope to visit again!

Submitted by Houston TX on Jun 11, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope you will visit again as well ~ and soon (please and thank you!). Thank you for the kind review. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

key west vacation

Astor meets Key West

Submitted by Astor FL on Jun 11, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a beautiful way to describe Lilly's Pad! Thank you for that visual. Please come and stay with us again, anytime. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect!

Loved everything about this home. It was beautifully maintained and very comfortable. Super location close to everything. Already missing Key West.

Submitted by Norfolk VA on Jun 09, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It's so nice to hear that you enjoyed your time at Lilly's Pad. Thank you for reviewing us and our Team so nicely! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

great house and location!

House was very comfortable and looked like the pictures. Concierge service was excellent. Loved the location!

Submitted by Dallas TX on Jun 08, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We thank you for taking the time to review us so kindly! We hope you'll return to stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

the lilly’s pad vacation home

The Lilly Pad is a beautiful relaxing vacation home. The house was very clean and the perfect size for the 6 adults. The Concierge at historic Key West vacation rentals made all the arrangement for me. She contacted the golf cart company to make sure it was delivered to their office waiting on us when we arrived. She also reserved our sunset tour and snorkeling trip for us. They do an excellent job. We had a problem with the hot water and their Maintance department came out quickly and replaced the water heater Johnny on the spot. And the 2 repairmen were very nice to talk to while they worked, he even gave us some mangos that were growing close by. We all highly recommend Historic Key West vacation rentals and their staff.

Submitted by Cordele GA on Jun 04, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It's so nice to hear that you enjoyed your time at Lilly's Pad. Thank you for reviewing the home and our Team so nicely! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

fantastic!

We love La Maisonette. This is a beautiful little bungalow in a perfect location. The place was spotlessly clean and decorated very nicely. It was equipped with everything we needed for our stay. We loved sitting outside either on the porch or in the beautiful courtyard. Everyone on the property is friendly and helpful. It is such a nice community. We would love to return some time and highly recommend to anyone who would like to stay in a beautiful place walkable to almost anything in EYW. Thanks for a wonderful week!

Submitted by Charlotte NC on May 30, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for coming and staying with us! We are already looking forward to your next visit. Please make it soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

amazing rental

Villa Josine was perfection! The house was not only beautifully decorated but it was immaculately clean. The pool was beautiful and the deck was the best place to relax with our morning cup of coffee and tea. The property location was pure perfection, convenient to ride bikes everywhere. The concierge service offered by the rental company was so helpful with all of our needs from bike rentals to booking things to do like snorkeling, parasailing, and a sunset cruise. I can’t recommend this rental or the agency enough! We will definitely be back!!!

Submitted by Budd Lake NJ on May 29, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for your kind words. We're already looking forward to your next visit! Please make it soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Casablanca Too - Nightly Rental

5.0

great stay in key west

Perfect place for a couple. Loved the location, far enough away from the mayhem of Duval Str but close enough to get the by about a 20min walk or short drive or Uber. Loved the hot tub and made good use of the Bbq. Everything you needed for a great break !

Submitted by Abu Dhabi AZ on May 26, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Casablanca Too! We hope you'll come and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

bucket. list key west vacation

The home was spotless, beautifully decorated, and with a super comfortable bed. It was off the beated path but close enough to walk everywhere in Key West. The emergency number and quick reply was greatly appreciated when I left my phone inside the apartment and needed the texted key code to get back in!A couple of restaurant recommendations...Blue Heaven for dinner (gorgeous patio) and Sunny Eggs for breakfast (best I ever had!). I would recommend this spot to anyone traveling to Key West.

Submitted by Lakewood OH on May 24, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for your kind words about Poinciana Treetop! We are already looking forward to your next visit, and we hope it's soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great lodging pick

This house was perfect for my girls trip for 3. It was nicely decorated, very clean and provided everything we needed. The pool area was a must for an afternoon break, especially since we visited during record high temperatures. Restaurants and shopping was close by so we could walk most places, which we also appreciated. Absolutely perfect in all respects, no negatives. Management company was accessible if needed.

Submitted by Franklin OH on May 21, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It sounds like the perfect Girls' Trip and we hope you'll come again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Rooster Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

long weekend away

Rooster Conch was a perfect little retreat, the unit itself was fantastic, well maintained and equipped with everything you need. Location was very convenient, close to Duval and situated on a quiet street. We have used HKWVR several times, property management always provides excellent customer service.

Submitted by Edgewater MD on May 20, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love seeing happy, familiar places, and are so happy you have a vacation home here in Key West! We'll see you again soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

a great week in paradise

The rental was clean, we loved the decor, and HKWVR responded immediately to our questions and problems. The location is great, right in the middle of things, but it's very quiet.

Submitted by Memphis TN on May 19, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Isn't Solaris Garden great? We hope you're already making plans to come and see us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Serene Lily - Weekly Rental

5.0

loved serene lily

As usual, an excellent stay! Loved Serene Lily, our favorite HKWVR so far. Beautifully decorated, great location, a wonderful place to stay. A plus was off street parking for the golf cart, a necessity for getting around Key West.

Submitted by Chesterfield MO on May 18, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed Serene Lily and hope we'll see you yet again! Thank you for being a great guest. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

wonderful!

Beautiful and very clean cottage in a fantastic location! Walkable to everything!

Submitted by South Bend IN on May 17, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We will let our housekeeper know you appreciated the home's cleanliness. Our housekeepers work hard! We hope you'll come and see us again, soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

great stay

We had a lovely time staying at La Maisonnette! The house is very comfortable, clean, accommodating. It was the perfect size for two of us for 4 nights. Also the small pool in the courtyard is very nice and was a nice place to relax and sun bathe. It's hard to note from the pictures but the home is located in a courtyard with other bungalows. There's beautiful tropical trees and plants so it feels secluded from the other homes located in the same courtyard. It's in a good location walking distance to most of the restaurants, attractions, etc.

Submitted by Jackson Heights NY on May 15, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at La Maisonnette! We can't wait to see you again, and we hope it's soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

butterfly cottage

Perfect, beautiful place to stay, super clean..and of course location, location. We were able to walk everywhere! Loved it!

Submitted by Newnan GA on May 14, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Butterfly Cottage! We hope we'll see you again in the near future. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Queen Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

queen conch review

Great house, perfect location off Duval. Pool was fantastic and the house had everything we needed. Would definitely stay there again and I highly recommend HKWVR.

Submitted by Boyds MD on May 14, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the nice review! We highly recommend you too! Please hurry back. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

a fabulous key west vacation rental

Super clean, well equipped vacation rental in a fantastic location. We would definitely rent it again on our next Key West vacation. The management staff is also wonderful. Highly recommend.

Submitted by Tyler TX on May 14, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the nice review of HKWVR and Lilly's Pad! We are here, eagerly awaiting your return! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Casablanca Too - Nightly Rental

5.0

casablanca too great!

Everything about the accommodations as well as the management exceeded my expectations. My wife and I would recommend this AirB&B to anyone and will probably return sometime in the future!

Submitted by Port Richey FL on May 14, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love to hear that we exceeded your expectations~ that's exactly what we always hope will happen. We are eagerly awaiting your return. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Fair Winds at the Foundry - Weekly Rental

5.0

great vacation

Our second time at Fair Winds and we are very pleased. It is clean and located close to all the best places to see. We will definitely be going back

Submitted by Hermitage PA on May 12, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Third time will definitely be the charm, so please hurry back! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

good location with a peaceful garden

We had a very enjoyable stay at this property. Although it is located in a busy area, it was very quiet and peaceful. It was very convenient to walk around downtown and to other areas of Key West. We brought a car, but we did not use it while we stayed here. The overall property is in wonderful condition. The garden area was very nice and we spent a lot of time there during our stay. Communication was also very good, and we felt very welcome.

Submitted by Belle Plaine MN on May 04, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time and felt welcome! That is always our goal. We hear all the time how great the location for La Maisonnette is, and how quiet. We love that. Come and stay again! We're waiting. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

a wonderful villa!!

This was one of the BEST vacation rentals we have ever been in! The Villa is so well maintained and beautifully decorated and remodeled inside. Everything was top notch. We loved all the artwork! It is nicely laid out, room for everyone and places to get away from another if needed. It is very well stocked in all the rooms. The linens are wonderful too. Not cheap and inexpensive like other rentals we have been in. The kitchen has everything you would need. It was nice to have a washer and dryer as well. The pool was an added plus and we all used it multiple times everyday. It is super clean as they have weekly pool service. The parking was easy especially if you have an extra car that needs parking on the street. But the parking area included is larger than we thought. We had 2 golf carts that fit nicely. The Villa is in a great area so we pretty much walked to dinners in the evening. It’s very safe as well. It was fun to have the carts to get into town. Everything is so close! Every restaurant we went to was excellent. The Historic Key West Rental company was a joy to deal with. Everyone I spoke to was so helpful. They even arranged our cart rental for us. Their concierge Cindy was beyond helpful! She sent out a huge list of things to do and see while in Key West. I can’t wait to go back and spend more time exploring the town and especially staying at Villa Josine. I would not hesitate staying at any of their properties. They are a fantastic group to work with! I loved the fact that they really made you feel welcome and were happy you were there. Great experience!!

Submitted by Gig Harbor WA on May 04, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you had a nice time at Villa Josine, and we appreciate your taking the time to write such a nice review. We will pass along the message to Cindy and the rest of the team. We hope you'll come and make some more memories with us again, soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

three couples visiting key west for four nights

This house suited the needs of a four night trip to Key West by three couples that travel well together. Well maintained, pretty and traditional Key West property, complete with nearby crowing roosters in the morning. About eight blocks from Duval Street. We found it okay to walk TO Duval Street in the afternoon but quite a slog to walk BACK from Duval Street late at night after dinner and drinks. Took an Uber. Biggest heads-up about this house is the bathroom arrangement. The descriptions contradict...3 baths stated in one place and 2.5 baths stated in another place. In reality, there is only one full private bathroom in the MBR, a second full private bathroom that is between the other two bedrooms in a "Jack and Jill" arrangement. The third "bathroom" consists of a toilet and lavatory in the laundry room and a shower outside by the pool. A bit misleading but technically 3 bathrooms all together! If you travel well together...not an issue. If you require more privacy...could be a problem...particularly if there are snorers that rattle the louvered doors throughout the bedrooms and bathrooms. Anyway, nice place and good service. We'd return.

Submitted by Saint Helena Island SC on May 03, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We all know that walk back home from anywhere! We hope you'll come back with your close friends and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Azul - Monthly Rental

5.0

spacious and comfortable

We enjoyed Villa Azuls large great room of dining/living room/kitchen that together make for very comfortable living space. The kitchen is well appointed with cookware and serving utensils. Upstairs suite is really large! Beds in all rooms are very comfortable. Bedding is quality. Outside living on the table/deck and pool makes a wonderful place to sun, play cards and take a dip. However,there was a lot of debris coming down off the mango tree and we swept our deck often. The pool house is small but very comfortable and the guest we had in there were happy with it. The one way Curry Lane is very narrow and often Ubers did not come down. We walked to the end for pick-up. We went to Harpoon Harrys, Boathouse and BO's for some of our favorite dining spots. 5 Brothers for morning coffe and breakfast sandwiches is really close.

Submitted by Antioch IL on May 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the honest review of Villa Azul! It is on a tiny, classic Key West lane (in description). We're happy you enjoyed your time with us. We look forward to seeing you again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

dreaming on duval

One of the best luxury rentals I have stayed in. Comfortably accommodated 8 guests --well laid out living arrangements, clean, convenient and lots of little touches to make the stay special (outside ice machine, pool towels, etc) and the staff at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals were great to deal with--helped us with golf cart and bike rentals, let us leave their luggage at their office until house was ready, etc. Top notch experience all around

Submitted by East Stroudsburg PA on Apr 29, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Dreaming on Duval! We hope you'll come and stay with us again, and soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

excellent stay!

Totally satisfied with the accommodations. Only issue was the parking ,but we got lucky and found a spot 2 blocks,away. Great location.

Submitted by Austin TX on Apr 29, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of Solaris Cottage! We do recommend that if you don't need a car, don't bring it ~ parking all over the island is at a premium. "Walkable to so many Key West activities, you won’t need a car, just a pair of sandals or a bicycle." Hope we'll see you again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

april vacation

Great rental with a convenient location.

Submitted by Southington CT on Apr 28, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It sounds like you enjoyed your stay! We hope we'll see you again, soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

just really great!

Would 100 percent recommend this property (as described!) and Historic Key West Vacation Rentals. For our first visit to Key West - property was perfectly located, clean(!), and well stocked.

Submitted by Charleston SC on Apr 27, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We were your first!? We hope we'll see you for your second visit. Thanks for being a great guest. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfection!

Cloud 9 was the perfect property for our group of 3 couples. The location is central to everything and made a walkable city even more accessible. The house is gorgeous, exceptionally clean and well appointed. We loved having our own pool and separate spaces. Life is short, splurge for the stay here.

Submitted by Hamilton OH on Apr 27, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed our Cloud 9! We hope you'll come and splurge again, soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect spotless rental close to everything!

The home is large but cozy, spotless and beautifully decorated! The pool was warm and clean, outdoor landscaping made space very private. We were able to get groceries delivered in 15 minutes - very convenient. We did not rent a car and were able to walk everywhere without any issues. The hosts were easy to reach and we felt home was very safe.

Submitted by South Bend IN on Apr 24, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed Key West like it should be enjoyed ~ walking (or biking), carless. Please come and stay with us again, anytime! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place to stay

We came to town for a friends birthday with 2 other couples. The house was a good size for all of us to be able to spend out. The beds were comfortable. Close to the marina and other neighborhood restaurants.

Submitted by Chesapeake VA on Apr 24, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It's nice to hear you all enjoyed your time at Chavez House! Please let us know when you're coming back. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

family vacation to key west

Lovely place. Lots of room for two families. Very private. Ideal location. Would definitely stay here again!

Submitted by Charlottesville VA on Apr 21, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So happy you enjoyed Dreaming on Duval. We hope when you say you'll stay again, you mean soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

anniversary trip

Awesome stay!

Submitted by Garfield AR on Apr 18, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope Key West and Solaris Garden will be on your anniversary list every year! Thank you for taking the time to give us such a kind review. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

peaceful and comfortable home away from home

My husband and I were so glad we booked Solaris Garden through Historic Key West Vacation Rentals. It is on a quiet lane with beautiful trees and plants around the patio. Easy to store the bikes. The kitchen and bathroom have all you need including good knives, wineglasses and a fabulous shower. Bed comfortable. Laundry and clothesline useful. The living space was thoughtfully and artfully designed. The minisplit, fans and air conditioner kept the temp just right. We also appreciated the concierge services provided that gave us a worry-free week in Key West. Thanks folks for your help getting the taxi, providing baggage storage when we arrived and helping with bike rental. We will be back!

Submitted by Leverett MA on Apr 17, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That's awesome! Please come and stay with us again! We love seeing happy, familiar faces. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place!

Great apartment—-very clean, loved the outdoor space.

Submitted by Concord NH on Apr 15, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Isn't that space great!? Hope you'll come and enjoy it again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

excellent

A box checked off the bucket list. Location of house was perfect and within walking distance to everything we wanted to see and do. We did have a problem with the a/c unit not cooling properly but management and maintenance got the problem fixed rather quickly. Overall a great vacation.

Submitted by Trion GA on Apr 12, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So happy to hear your bucket list item was successful! And we're sorry to hear about the A/C but it's nice to know we rectified it quickly. Please come again and make some more memories. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Serene Lily - Weekly Rental

5.0

superb rental experience.

The property was immaculate and exactly as described. HKWVR was very responsive and proactive with communication. We would absolutely rent through HKWVR again.

Submitted by Columbia SC on Apr 09, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for noticing and giving such a nice review! We love our home and our guests and can't wait for your return. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Casablanca - Nightly Rental

5.0

nice place for a short vacation

Nice place with a pool but some items would need to be upgraded

Submitted by Paris A75 on Apr 09, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the nice and honest review. We are looking into the home to see what we can do to make it better for you the next time. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

our lilly's pad experience

Great experience from the start. Information on web was on point. Communication was great with management company and I cannot say enough about the property. Fully stocked with everything you can think of, in great condition, nicely furnished and in a great location. Property was spotless when we arrived.

Submitted by Houma LA on Apr 08, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind review of Lilly's Pad ~ we are so happy you enjoyed your time and can't wait for you to come again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

heaven on duval

House is perfectly located in Duval. Clean, perfectly appointed (attention to every detail), rooms are spacious and professionally decorated. HKWV responded promptly to any question during our stay. Home is secure. Bedding is luxurious. Definitely high end. Will definitely book again if we go.

Submitted by Niles OH on Apr 08, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for noticing our operations teams' attention to detail. They work hard to make our homes beautiful and clean for you. Please come and stay again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect peaceful location.

Property located close to Duval but located on a quiet side street. The property was spotless and updated and the rental company made everything effortless.

Submitted by Vestal NY on Apr 07, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you, Susan, for your great review of Butterfly Cottage. We are thrilled that you had a 5-star experience and hope to see you again soon in sunny Key West! Lori & the Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

a gem of a rental!

This home is one of the best vacation rentals I have ever rented! The house was well-maintained and very well stocked. From extra blankets to plenty of dishes, pots and pans, extra towels, toilet paper, dishwasher tablets, etc. All of the furnishings were comfortable (beds, couches, table and chairs, etc) and the outdoor furniture was also plentiful and comfortable. The location of this house is an A+! Right off Duval Street but very quiet and tucked away. The pool was small but plenty for us to dip in when we got hot. I would suggest asking the pool temp to be lowered during hot months as it was very warm. We didn’t realize we could ask for that. Overall, this was a really great rental. We would recommend it highly!

Submitted by Nashville TN on Apr 07, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for your kind review of Chick-a-Pea! We love everything about this home! Come back and see us again soon in sunny Key West~ Lori & the Team @ HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

beautiful home and pool!

The Sea Conch was clean and comfortable. We used the pool every day. HKWR staff was quick to respond to questions and one service request. We will be back!

Submitted by Golden Valley MN on Apr 07, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review Sea Conch! We strive for guest satisfaction and are happy we were able to quickly assist you. We can't wait to see you again~ Lori & the Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect anniversary getaway

Solaris garden is perfect for a couple looking for a quick getaway to Key West. Location was absolutely perfect. House had everything we needed for a comfortable stay

Submitted by Souderton PA on Apr 06, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay at Solaris Garden. We are so happy that you enjoyed your time here~ come see us again soon! Lori & the Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

beautiful key west home

Exceptional 4 bedroom home with stunning backyard and great 4 bedroom layout for our family. Perfect location just two streets from Duval (shops and restaurants). We’ll definitely be back!

Submitted by Winter Park FL on Apr 06, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you , Holly, for your great review of Villa Josine! We agree that it is an exceptional property and hope to see you again soon~ Lori & the Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

a charming cottage in old town key west

We had a great stay at Potters Cottage! The house is well appointed and wonderfully maintained. It was perfect for our family of 4. There are 2 beds plus three sitting areas with couches (1 pulls out). The furniture inside and out was comfortable! The kitchen had everything we needed to make and serve Easter dinner- we were thrilled. The pool was literally a step away and was a great place to relax and refresh at any time. The washer and dryer were large and easy to use. Two minor drawbacks- the house does not come with parking or a residential permit. We were never able to grab the spot in front of the house. The upstairs bedroom area is accessible by a narrow, step staircase which may be challenging for some travelers. The rental company, Historic Key West Vacation Rentals, was great to work with. We look forward to returning!

Submitted by Moorestown NJ on Apr 05, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Potter's Cottage ~ and thank you for pointing out that the stairs may be steep for some (a common trait of Historic homes). We are already looking forward to your next visit! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Fair Winds at the Foundry - Weekly Rental

5.0

very happy!

This was our first time staying in Truman Annex & we could not be happier.
The house was perfect for my family of four. We loved the location, the patio area and my daughters loved the privacy of the third floor bedroom that they had to themselves. The house was stocked with plenty of towels, extra pillows, blankets and beach towels and plenty of paper products to last the whole week. We are looking forward to coming back!

Submitted by Ocean City NJ on Apr 05, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are excited to hear that you'll be coming back ~ more memories are ready to be made here! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

great location

The house was perfect for the two of us. Great location to either walk or bike to any area you wanted. Quiet street. Areas to lock your bikes. The place was clean and had all basic necessities.

Submitted by Los Angeles California on Apr 04, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Solaris Garden ~ we are already looking forward to hear that you're coming back! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Tropical Dream - Monthly Rental

5.0

best rental property ever

I’ve been renting in key west for 7 years and this is by far the best rental property I’ve had!

Submitted by Southport NC on Apr 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So nice to hear you enjoyed Tropical Dream ~ we think it's a great home, too! Please come stay with us for your 8th year in Key West! We love seeing happy, familiar faces! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

will definitely rent from hkwvr again!!!

Clear instructions throughout the stay. Excellent response when looking for specific things to do in KW, plus an excellent guide was provided for what was going on during our stay!

Submitted by Mineral Bluff GA on Apr 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for mentioning our new Guide ~ we've been working hard on it and are glad you appreciated it. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Azul - Monthly Rental

5.0

superior customer service

Brenda and her team do everything and more to make a vacation worry-free.

Submitted by Dallas TX on Apr 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you, Lucy, for your kind words! We appreciate your feedback and want your next stay with us will be a 5 Star experience. We hope to see you again in sunny Key West~ Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Fair Winds at the Foundry - Weekly Rental

5.0

fun @ the foudry!

Absolutely loved our week stay at the foundry! We travelled over spring break with our teen girls. The location was perfect...close to everything! We rented bikes...bikes everywhere! No need for a car. Loved the community pool and the Truman annex area is superb...by far the most beautiful area in key west.

Submitted by Van Wert OH on Mar 31, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Everyone loves the Truman Annex and we're so lucky to have Fair Winds at the Foundry for sure! Please bring everyone back again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

another great stay at sea conch

Wonderful again! Great space, great pool and an amazing location - close to everything but away from the noise! We’ve already booked again for next year!

Submitted by New York NY on Mar 31, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love seeing familiar faces walk through our doors! Thank you for the nice review and the return visit. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Grand Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

grand grand maison

Lovely house in perfect location on Duvall. Close enough but just far enough south to be quiet in the evenings. House equipped with everything you could want. Hope to go back and stay again

Submitted by Stuart FL on Mar 31, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are already looking forward to your next stay with us at Grand Maison. You need to come and make some more memories! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

as described!

This house is exactly as described. Right off the action on Duval, but as soon as you enter the property, you’d never know it. The house is definitely on the pricier side but it’s all about the location. We rented a golf cart which was perfect for getting around. The pool was nice (but on the smaller side if you have a lot of kids). House was very clean and big enough for our family of 6.

Submitted by Doylestown PA on Mar 31, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It's so nice to hear you had a good time at our beautiful Cloud 9. We hope you'll all come back and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

fantastic key west getaway

This cottage was perfect! It was less than a block off Duval St. we could walk everywhere- to restaurants, shops, etc.... We loved the back/side yard with the pool, the lounge chairs and the cabana. It was heavenly. The pool adjusted temperature so it was cooler in the day and warm at night. It was just superb. This cottage had a nice little kitchen, if you wanted to cook, washer/dryer if you need to do laundry and a dining and living room area. There was a king bed (super comfy), a queen bed (comfy), a room with 2 singles (not comfy) and a room with another single (didn’t use). Plenty of bathrooms. There were numerous towels in every bathroom ready for us to use and beach towels for the pool. So thoughtful. The team was incredibly communicative at this property. Would DEFINITELY stay here again.

Submitted by Lake Zurich IL on Mar 28, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you Kim, for taking the time to provide your thorough review of Chick-a-Pea Cottage! It is a perfect property and we love it too! We can't wait to host you again here in sunny Key West~ Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

peaceful lane

Had a great time in Key West. This rental was all I needed. Quiet street, yet just 2 blocks from plenty of action on Duvall. Plenty of towels, two balconies. private balcony off bedroom made a good spot to sip coffee. Would stay again.

Submitted by Brandon Mississippi on Mar 27, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Audie- Thank you for your wonderful review of Poinciana Treetop! We are so happy that you enjoyed your time with us here in Key West. We hope to see you again soon~ Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great time

Lovely home for my wife and me. Close to Duval.

Submitted by North Plainfield NJ on Mar 26, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you Vincent, for your kind words! Potter's Cottage is a great property in a perfect location. We hope you will come back and see us again soon in sunny Key West! Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

super house and location

Great house. We were 4 couples. Living space was excellent. Loved the heated pool and private backyard. One couple did have to sleep in the twin beds. Beds were comfortable and bathrooms were nice. Nice to have laundry especially since it poured rain. We were able to get both our cars in the driveway without hanging over the sidewalk. House is 3-4 blocks off of Duval. We never used our cars. Will rent again for sure!

Submitted by Key Largo FL on Mar 26, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you Cynthia, for your great review of Villa Josine! We agree that it is a great house and property. We look forward to seeing you again soon in sunny Key West~ Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Fair Winds at the Foundry - Weekly Rental

5.0

enjoyable

Terrific property in a great location. The 33 steps to the 3rd floor bedroom were a bit of an issue. The AC went out one day and the temp soared into the 90's. However, with one phone call, a maintenance man came to our unit even though it was after he had gone home for the day and within a few hours, the AC unit was repaired. The one thing I did not like was the hassle created by their check in and check out policy. You cannot gain access to your unit until 4:00pm (we arrived at noon) and must be completely out of the unit by 10:00am (our flight was at 6:00pm). The mgmt co allowed us to store our luggage at their office during the before and after hours; however, the office is two miles away from the unit. So, we had to Uber our luggage from the airport to the mgmt co's office, then Uber into town for lunch and wait the four hours until the unit became available. We then had to Uber back to the office to retrieve our luggage and then take another Uber with our luggage to our unit. We then had to repeat the process upon departure. In all, it required 8 separate Ubers - an expensive hassle. It would have been so much better service if someone at the office would have simply driven our luggage to and from the unit or if we could have stored our luggage on site. Nevertheless, I am already looking forward to our next visit.

Submitted by Muskegon MI on Mar 25, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind and honest review of Fair Winds at the Foundry! Our office is indeed 1.5 miles from Fair Winds and while we'd like to say it's OK to leave your luggage at the house/s when your flights come in early, we can't because we cannot be responsible for luggage left on properties without supervision, and it's unfair to our housekeepers to ask them to keep an eye on them while they're cleaning. But ~ if you choose an earlier/later flight again, we will do what we can to help! We are looking forward to your next visit as well ~ let us know what we can do to make it smoother. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

charming!

Fell in love with the tastefully decorated space, the super comfy beds, and morning coffees on the upper-level deck. The location was close to the historic district, yet peaceful - all we heard were rooster wake-up calls! Looking forward to a return visit!

Submitted by Lewes DE on Mar 24, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you, Sylvia, for your great review of Petite Maison. We love that you loved it! Come back and see us soon here in Key West~ Lori @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

amazing location

We loved our stay at the Petite Maison. Lovely home that is right off Duval but tucked away so it is still quiet. Definitely recommend.

Submitted by Dallas TX on Mar 24, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Cathryn- thank you so much for taking the time to review Petite Maison! We are so happy that you loved it as much as we do. We hope to see you again in sunny Key West~ Lori @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect stay!!

Absolutely loved this perfectly located, nicely appointed house! So many nice places to sit and enjoy - both indoors and outdoors. Three of us stayed but it would have been comfortable with more people. Will definitely stay here again!!!!

Submitted by New Jersey NJ on Mar 24, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your great review of Potter's Cottage! We love that you enjoyed your time here in Key West and can't wait to see you again soon! Lori @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

butterfly cottage

Awesome house, location, and staff

Submitted by Dakota Dunes SD on Mar 24, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review Butterfly Cottage- we appreciate your kind words and are so happy you had an awesome time! We hope to see you again soon~ Lori @ HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

great spot!

Our second stay in this cozy little apartment in the treetops! Convenient to everything, nice and clean. Washer and dryer. And they allow my dog. That's what we are looking for and they deliver. Thanks again! We will be back.

Submitted by Kennebunk ME on Mar 18, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We know that the third time is the charm ~ you'll be hooked forever! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Serene Lily - Weekly Rental

5.0

first rate stay

Serene Lily has many things going for it. Top of the line appliances. Comfortable and attractive furnishings. Convenient and private location. The folks at the rental agency were always promptly responsive and courteous.

Submitted by Rochester NY on Mar 17, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your month at Serene Lily and hope you're ready to come back and have some more Key West time! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

great stay

While small it was comfortable for 2 couples, renovation was well done. Great location, close enough but far enough away to not be kept awake at all hours.

Submitted by Emmaus PA on Mar 17, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Petite Maison. Please tell us when you're coming again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

something for all your moods - from retreat to all out party!

This was our first time staying at a HKWVR property... and I can tell you - what you see in the photos of the property are what you get! Up to date, clean and well maintained properties that even the pickest of renters would have a hard time finding fault with. A top notch property and a top notch staff made our experince the best ever! Thank you team HKWVR!

The Cloud Nine property offered us our own secluded oasis that was literally steps from all the action. We had the best of all worlds - we could stay within the tranquil inner suroundings of our own courtyard - enjoy the charm and warmth the immediate neighborhood had to offer or, step the pace up with Duval only a 1/2 block away.

Submitted by Coldwater MI on Mar 15, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

I couldn't have said it better! Thank you so much for being a great guest and we hope you'll come and make some more memories with us. You now have your own vacation home here in Key West! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

southard comfort

Great property and location. Backyard area and pool were the highlight.

Submitted by Roanoke VA on Mar 15, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love that backyard and pool and are so happy to hear you did as well! Come back and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

ladies weekend

Cottage was spotless and perfectly located. We could walk everywhere from the house-everything within 1 mile. Back yard was perfect for lounging and relaxing.

Submitted by Atlantic City NJ on Mar 13, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Perfect review for Chick-a-Pea Cottage. Thank you for taking the time to say such nice words. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

peaceful spot, close to everything

Loved our stay. The layout of the property was perfect for us. 2 bedrooms downstairs, each with en suite bathrooms. Upstairs is a living room, a kitchen, & our favourite space, the outdoor covered porch with comfy furniture. The street is quiet, but only a few minutes walk to Upper Duvall. We were able to walk to some of our favourite Key West spots - La Grignote, Banana Cafe, Seaside Cafe, Blue Heaven, & the Hemingway House.

Submitted by Plymouth MA on Mar 12, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Petite Maison and hope you're ready to make some more memories with us! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Rooster Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfection

Perfect

Submitted by St-Lambert-de-Lauzon QC on Mar 11, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That's the 'perfect' word for Rooster Conch ~ and we thank you for using it! Come and stay with us again, and soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

lilly’s pad

Lilly’s Pad and my experience with Vacation Homes of Key West was exceptional. The house was extremely clean, well-equipped, and very comfortable. The outdoor patio and pool area were outstanding. Its location close to Duval was also great! Aubrey at Vacation Homes of Key West was exceptional in meeting all of our needs, ensuring our stay was perfect, and keeping us well-informed.

Submitted by Poland OH on Mar 11, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for your kind review of Historic Key West Vacation Rentals (and Aubrey!). We love hearing kind words and hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

!016 duval was spectacular!

Our family traveled to Key West for a family wedding. There were four families in this home. It was perfect for our needs, It was well located, nicely appointed and offered lovely in side and outside eating areas.
had wonderful amenities, including a lovely seating area around the pool.

Submitted by Bethesda MD on Mar 09, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So glad you enjoyed your time at Dreaming on Duval. We love to hear that you had a good time and enjoyed this beautiful home. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

another week in the most unique town in florida

From the start of the reservation process to saying goodby to the office staff after they held out luggage, everything was as good as we expected.

Submitted by West Bath ME on Mar 09, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It's never 'goodbye', it's 'see you later!'. And that's what we hope, is that we'll see you later (soon). ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Fair Winds at the Foundry - Weekly Rental

5.0

location, location, location

The location of condo #26 is outstanding. The unit at the end of a row of condos allows for three huge windows along the outside wall.
We knew that it would be a three story unit. The seemingly endless steps up and down turned out to be too strenuous for our group. A minor note: the railings are installed too high.
The living room sofas are in desperate need of replacement. There isn't anywhere comfortable to sit. At times we resorted to the wooden dinette chairs.
Since we prefer fine dining, the best meal we had all week was at Louie's Backyard.
The management company provided excellent customer service.
We were unaware and didn't research the fact that it was 'swarming season'. The termites that swarm (dusk to sunset??) can get into the house.
The unit will be recommended with the advice that thirty one some odd steps might be a drawback.

Submitted by SEATTLE WA on Mar 09, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind and honest review of Fair Winds at the Foundry. It's a good reminder that the home is 3 stories and does have stairs. We have relayed your recommendation regarding the couches to the owner. We hope you'll come back and stay with us again, and soon! Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

great vacation

Beautiful, placid oasis in Old Town. Immaculately clean. Lovely courtyard and inviting pool. Loved our stay. Rental staff were very professional annd responsive. It was a pleasure interacting with the first rate team.

Submitted by Falls Church VA on Mar 08, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

I have shared this with our Team and we are all blushing from your kind words. Thanks for being a great guest. Hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again, and soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

petite maison

Home was very clean and in the perfect location if you are looking to walk and explore Duvall St. while in Key West. The bedrooms do not have closets and the floor space is limited for those of you who travel with lots of luggage!

Submitted by Smyrna GA on Mar 06, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Good note about luggage ~ we appreciate that. We hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

fantastic place to stay!

Villa Josine was as beautiful in person as in the photos. The outdoor pool area was a little taste of paradise, especially with the covered veranda and comfortable furniture. The inside was tastefully furnished, the kitchen was perfectly stocked, the beds were comfortable, and we had plenty of space meet, eat and play! The location was ideal for us - we walked everywhere with no problem. The responsiveness of property management was very good - our ice machine froze over and it was fixed the same day. I would highly recommend this home for your next trip to Key West! We’ll definitely be back!

Submitted by Henrico VA on Mar 05, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You're making us blush with all of your kind words! Thank you for taking the time to review Villa Josine and we can't wait for your next stay. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Seas The Day! - Weekly Rental

5.0

seas the day

As advertised, it's a beautiful property!

Submitted by Fairport NY on Mar 04, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you! We try to be clear with our descriptions and pictures of our homes. Hope you'll come and stay again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

lilly's pad - an idyllic rental

Spent 2 glorious weeks at Lilly's Pad and loved every minute. The accommodations are so nice and new, the location is just perfect, just steps to the quiet end of Duval, and a quick bike ride to ANYwhere. Bikes, golf cart and a private boat charter were all arranged by HKWV concierge, planned seamlessly. The idyllic and tropical back porch and pool setting cannot be beat. This home is a true winner.

Submitted by Indianapolis IN on Mar 04, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It is so nice to hear that you had a great time. We love our Lilly's Pad and are glad you did too. We can't wait for your next stay. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

great time in key west

Renting was an easy process. Everyone answered questions promptly and told me exactly what to expect.

Submitted by Elkins WV on Mar 03, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That is exactly what we hope to accomplish for our guests! We know it makes things easier for everyone. Come again, please! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great cottage in old town key west

Pristine 2 bedroom cottage in great old town Key West location. Quiet neighborhood (other than occasional roosters, but those are everywhere) within walking distance to the many restaurants, bars, attractions in Key West. Immaculately finished spaces inside and outside. Loved it!

Submitted by Burtonsville MD on Mar 01, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed Butterfly Cottage and some of our locals (roosters). We hope we'll see you again soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

an excellent stay

The location is unbeatable, very clean, beautiful, and cozy. It really has everything you could need or want with amazing staff ready to welcome you. Would highly recommend.

Submitted by Grosse Pointe Farms MI on Feb 28, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Well thank you kindly! We highly recommend you as a guest and hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect for our three couple weekend getaway!

The house was clean, comfortable, attractive and well-stocked for our long weekend family get-together. We loved the secured outdoor patio area and the heated pool, cooked a great meal in the well-equipped kitchen, and enjoyed the central location. The house was relatively quiet for being so close to Duval St. We were lucky to have beautiful weather and loved the lush green landscaping also!

Submitted by Manasquan NJ on Feb 27, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay at Cloud 9. We appreciate the details! Come back and see us again soon~ Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

chavez house

Great location, excellent accommodations, wonderful heated & private pool, outstanding property management - very helpful & responsive!

Submitted by Seabrook NH on Feb 26, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for your kind review~ we are so happy you enjoyed your time at Chavez House! We strive for guest satisfaction. Come and see us again soon! Lori & the Team at HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

sun in february!

We had a great time celebrating my 80th and 44th birthday of one of my daughters. Loved the location (quiet end of Duval) with many shops, restaurants and ice cream near by. Lots of room for our growing family (10 of us). Very clean and top-of-the-line appliances.

Submitted by Charlottesville VA on Feb 25, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay at Dreaming on Duval. We hope your birthday celebration was fabulous! Come back and see us again soon~ Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect place

Clean and cared for house. Great location close to restaurants and bars but still quiet. Stocked with everything you need for a vacation. Communication was simply and very helpful.

Submitted by Arlington MA on Feb 25, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your great review of Potter's Cottage! We agree that the location is perfect and we try to supply all you may need. Come back and see us again soon~ Lori and the Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place

The house was very clean and the beds were comfortable. The kitchen/house had everything we needed. The pool was fantastic. We had great communication with the rental agency. They were very helpful. We had a great stay.

Submitted by East Rochester NY on Feb 25, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Awww thank you for your kind words! We are so happy you had a great stay! Villa Josine is a beauty~ we hope to see you back in Key West soon! Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

family getaway

Great stay. I would recommend this property.

Submitted by Colombier NA on Feb 23, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay at Chick-a-Pea Cottage! We love this home and location~ we hope to see you again soon in fabulous Key West! Lori and the Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

solaris garden for one week

Loved the quiet, the location was great near restaurants and the grocery store

Submitted by Fairfield CT on Feb 23, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your review of Solaris Garden! The location is ideal and we are glad you enjoyed it. We hope to see you again soon in sunny Key West~ Lori and theTeam at HKWVR

Casablanca Grande - Nightly Rental

5.0

p

The and pool we both amazing! Me and my family of 5 had the best time.

Submitted by Northfield MN on Feb 21, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you all enjoyed your time at Casablanca Grande! Remember, you can also rent one side or the other (Casablanca Nightly and Casablanca Too). Come back again soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

wonderful time was had by all

Second year in a row staying at Sea Conch. Love the location and property. The pool was so relaxing and enjoyable. House is well stocked.

Submitted by Waddell AZ on Feb 21, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love seeing familiar faces and know that the 3rd time will be 'the charm', so please make it soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

vacation

Very Good

Submitted by Fort Myers FL on Feb 20, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of Poinciana Garden! Hope we'll see you again in the near future. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great stay in a cozy cottage

The cottage was great and the location very walkable. Loved both the front and back porches and having bathrooms on both floors. It was a homey stay, much better than hotel rooms! We loved it!

Submitted by Fairfax VA on Feb 20, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the nice review! Please come and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

beautiful and relaxing stay

The inside of the space was lovely and comfortable, and had everything we needed. I really liked that the aesthetic of the space had an ocean and beach vibe without being overly gaudy or using lots of bright colors. It was tastefully done. The space is perfect for just two or three people. The outside area was very beautiful and relaxing. There are multiple duplex condos around a central courtyard , so there are other people there, but it was still quiet for the most part, considering that. Customer service with the rental agency was excellent and top-notch. We would return here again!

Submitted by Swannanoa NC on Feb 19, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope you're making those return plans right now so that we can see you again soon! Thank you for the kind review ~ we love our La Maisonnette and are glad you did too. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

best vacation rental ever

Everything was perfect

Submitted by Mount Pleasant SC on Feb 19, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Really? That's so nice to hear! Hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

great house, great location!

We enjoyed our time at Villa Josine. Each bedroom had its own bathroom, the kitchen was furnished with anything that we wanted. The covered back porch area is nice, we sat out there every day, especially in the mornings. The heated pool was great. It’s a fun place to stay because it is close enough to walk to so many good restaurants and music.

Submitted by Fayetteville AR on Feb 18, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We feel like you summed up Villa Josine perfectly! Thank you for the great review and we hope you'll come and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect location and lovely house

The team managing the home were great. Proactive communication, quick responses, and lovely to deal with. The house was nice. Nice small pool in the back and well appointed kitchen.

Submitted by Bethesda MD on Feb 17, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the very kind words ~ we're all blushing here. We hope you're already making your way back to Key West to stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

cute, cozy retreat.

Nice hone, met all our requirements. Well stocked.

Submitted by Cincinnati OH on Feb 17, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind words about Lilly's Pad! We hope you'll come and stay with us again, and soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

lovely stay!

We all loved our week at the Petite Maison for Mile 0 Fest! Great location, great layout for 2 couples and the service from the wonderful staff at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals couldn't be better.

Submitted by Aledo TX on Feb 16, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a wonderful review for Petite Maison and we hope you can come for future Key West events! There are lots of fun ones to choose from, all year round. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Rooster Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

great stay

We had a great week at the rooster conch. The apartment was clean and well furnished and exceptionally quiet. The pool was wonderful. You do share the property with two other apartments but everybody got along great and it was very secluded. The location is so terrific and you can walk to everything.

Submitted by Naperville IL on Feb 15, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are thankful you enjoyed your time at Rooster Conch and can't wait for you to come back and stay with us again, soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

chilling at chick-a-pea!

We just returned home from a lovely stay at Chick-a-pea cottage and would highly recommend. We are often visitors to Key West and this was a great cottage for many reasons.

The location is fantastic is being located right off of Duval, but is still exceptionally quiet. You haven't been to KW, this cottage is on the more quiet end of Duval (close to the Southernmost end). There were five of us staying in the cottage and it was incredibly comfortable for a group that size. 6 would be great as well. The small bedroom off the kitchen is bijou, but adorable. Probably best for anyone who is an early riser (or a heavy sleeper) as it opens onto the kitchen.

The combined living room and dining area are well appointed and comfortable. The decor overall in the entire cottage is tasteful, adorable and "beachy" without being over the top.

My husband and I stayed in the master bedroom and the bed was SO comfortable. If you like plush and soft beds, you'll love this one. I find rentals sometimes skimp on beds and was pleasantly surprised to find a mattress that I really liked! Kudos to the owners. We were traveling with my mom and my husband's mom as well as one of my best friends. They all reported their beds were a tad hard but overall okay.

The outside area has a wonderful cabana where we spent most mornings with coffee and evenings after dinner chatting. The pool was perfect and appreciated having four lounge chairs.

The parking area and walk up to the deck of the cottage is gravel. Just something to be aware of with suitcases and if you have anyone older and more unsure on their feet.

The Historic Key West Vacation Rentals property management team were excellent! We had an issue with the wifi and they were incredibly attentive and quick to respond. It didn't get resolved while we were there, but no fault of the management company or the owner.

Would highly recommend this cottage and we'll definitely keep it on o

Submitted by Bristol TN on Feb 09, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Your review for Chick-a-Pea was amazing and we appreciate you taking the time to provide these details. We can't wait to see you again, and we hope it's soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

beautiful, well-appointed, comfy, great location

Fantastic 2 Bdrm house with private deck, grill, hot tub. Well-appointed kitchen, comfortable beds, 2 full baths, clean. Quiet location, but easy walk to Duval St. Been to Key West many times and this was the best rental I have found.

Submitted by Warwick RI on Feb 07, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for taking the time to give us such a kind review. We look forward to your next visit! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

great hidaway

Fantastic property. Close to everything you want to do in key west. Clean and well appointed. Management company was helpful and accommodating. Would definitely stay here again.

Submitted by Pace FL on Feb 06, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the nice review of Cloud 9! We think it's a fabulous home and we're thrilled you enjoyed your time. Please come back, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

4 day stay

Good location. Clean, nicel6y decorated unit. Parking a challenge due to volume of cars on the street--very difficult to get in and out of assigned spot

Submitted by California MD on Feb 03, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your kind and honest review of Poinciana Garden. Yes, it's on a tiny narrow lane (as mentioned in the description) so while it does have parking, large cars just don't fit. It's true Key West living. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Casablanca Too - Nightly Rental

5.0

great rental home!

We've been to KW many times and have stayed in different homes and hotel properties, and really enjoyed our stay in Casablanca Too. The home has everything needed for 2 guests. Location was great and the communication from the property managers was outstanding. The off-street parking space and hot tub are an added bonus! Will definitely stay here again.

Submitted by Indianapolis IN on Feb 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are already looking forward to your next stay at Casablanca Too! We're here and waiting. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Serene Lily - Weekly Rental

5.0

serenity now!

Wonderful house, quiet community, walk to everything! Attended the Mile 0 Fest. Awesome location to go to and from the shows. Near all the good cocktail bars: General Horrsplay, 915, The Roost, Bagatelle.
House had all modern updates with comfortable beds and comfortable furniture. Rear private patio and easy access to community pool Would benefit from adding patio table and chairs to enjoy, and clear instructions about needing the pool and gate key especially when returning to the community after 6p.

Submitted by Ambler PA on Feb 01, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind (and constructive) review of Serene Lily! Hope you'll come back and stay with us again, please and thank you. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

butterfly cottage

This is a wonderful cottage: comfortable, quiet, clean & conveniently located. Everything we wanted to see was within an easy walking distance. The cottage itself was very cosy & cute. We wouldn’t hesitate to stay here again and would highly recommend it!

Submitted by Hot Springs National Park AR on Feb 01, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Please hurry back and make some more memories at Butterfly Cottage! Soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

horse conch jan 2024

great location, nice place

Submitted by New Berlin WI on Jan 31, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the nice words about Horse Conch! Don't wait too long to come back. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Queen Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

this house was amazing!

Every detail of the stay was perfect. Nice location that made it easy to reach everything. House was clean and well-equipped. Communication with the owner was always timely and professional. We've used this company before and we'd gladly stay in their homes again.

Submitted by Lebanon VA on Jan 31, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love seeing happy, familiar faces and can't wait to see yours again! Please make it soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Seas The Day! - Weekly Rental

5.0

highly recommend

This is such a cute and cozy condo. Patio is fantastic for relaxing. Great location. Walkable to most everything. Quiet escape at the end of the night.

Submitted by Fort Worth TX on Jan 30, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It sounds like you got to enjoy the best of Key West by staying at Seas the Day! Hope we'll see you again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Serene Lily - Weekly Rental

5.0

truman annex

Wonderful place to stay! Two blocks to the excitement of Duval but the Annex will make you feel a world away from Duval! Easy walking to Mallory Square. Historic Key West Vacation Rentals were easy to work with & were available when needed. The house was perfect & well appointed.

Submitted by Westerville OH on Jan 28, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So happy you enjoyed your time at Serene Lily ~ hope we'll come and see us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect!

We had a wonderful two weeks in Chavez house! The home was perfect, location great. HKWV was professional and prompt with all concerns and requests we had. Special thanks to Aubrey and concierge Cindy!

Submitted by Waukesha WI on Jan 27, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind words about Chavez House ~ we hope you're already making plans to come and see us again, and soon. You know we'd love to help make that happen. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

a perfect gated condo

We loved the condo, and it's great appliances and furnishings. Bed was super comfortable. Perfact location for Duval Street.

Submitted by North Myrtle Beach SC on Jan 27, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you loved La Maisonnette and hope you'll come and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

paradise in what felt like a home in the center of it all!

It was such a wonderful property. One of the cleanest places I've ever booked from AirBnB.
Location was perfect to walk to and from Duval, but far enough to be quiet. The pool was warm and having an outdoor shower/men's room was a nice feature. This house is perfect for three couples, or a large or extended family.

Submitted by Hillsboro NH on Jan 26, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the nice words about our lovely Southard Comfort! We hope you'll use your vacation time with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

relaxing retreat

We had a wonderful, stress free, vacation start to finish...The team at Historic Key West Rentals are wonderful, so friendly and helpful! They set up our bike and golf cart rentals, so everything was ready to go when we arrived. The texts and emails for check in and check out and communication in between was appreciated, everything was so seemless! The house we chose was perfect for us, and the pool was so refreshing during my daily swim! I can't thank this team enough for the wonderful experience we had!

Submitted by Sandusky OH on Jan 25, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It sounds like you had an idyllic time at Southard Comfort! Please know that you are welcome back anytime (and we hope it's soon). Thank you for the kind words! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Seas The Day! - Weekly Rental

5.0

seas the day

Awesome!
Condo is small but as nice as can be. Everything you need is there and no more. No dressers in either bedroom so you basically live out of the suitcase but I think this is typical of Key West. Outside deck is big and gorgeous with plenty of vegetation and lots of privacy. Only 1/10th of a mile from Truman Annex park to walk in and just a few blocks from Duval. Close to everything but quiet at night. HKWVR was great. They let us drop our bags off when we got there until we could check in. Check in was available an hour early. Had and issue with water backing up in the dishwasher. Called and they had if fixed in no time while we were out and about.

Submitted by Cuyahoga Falls OH on Jan 22, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You make us and Seas the Day! sound amazing ~ thank you! We think you're a great guest as well. Please come and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

beautiful, clean, central location, quiet street

Beautiful condo. Had everything I needed. Good amount of space. Extremely clean. Quiet street but close to everything. Highly recommend.

Submitted by Naperville IL on Jan 22, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Well thank you for the kind words about Horse Conch! We hope you'll come and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Serene Lily - Weekly Rental

5.0

paradise in truman annex

This home is perfect. Everything is first class and extremely clean. The beds are comfortable and it was nice having a washer and dryer. Great location. Convenient to Duval Street and many KW attractions.

Submitted by Jasper GA on Jan 22, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We think you were a first class guest as well! Thank you for taking the time to review us so kindly. We hope to see you again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

wonderful property in a great location

Villa Josine was exactly as advertised. It is a well-kept property, the landscaping added privacy and a lush tropical feel to the outdoor spaces. The pool area was clean, pool was heated which was important in January, and pool towels conveniently located next to the deck sliding doors. The outside covered porch was wonderful for drinks or dining, well lit and with cooling ceiling fans.
Inside, 4 en-suite bedrooms however one has 2 twin beds, and since we were 3 couples it wasn’t an issue, but convenient if traveling with children. Beds were very comfortable, sheets were crisp. Ceiling fans in the bedrooms also. Plenty of towels in the bathrooms. The stairs up to the 2 upstairs bedrooms are a little narrow and steep, be careful.
Washer and dryer worked just fine.
The kitchen/living/dining area is very generously sized and nicely furnished. It functions especially well to be able to have guests enjoying the sitting areas while someone is in the kitchen and yet still part of the group. Large fridge and freezer, microwave, coffee machine, blender, oven all in excellent condition and worked well. The new Weber Genesis grill on the pool deck was fabulous.
Kitchen supplies were good, enough glasses, dishes etc for at least 8 and plastic glasses for poolside.
The location is a quiet one-way narrow street and if you have more than one car, (2 small ones will fit in the driveway though) you might have to hunt for parking spaces. The quiet street is lovely. Walkable to Duval.

Submitted by Incline Village NV on Jan 22, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

I love a good review of a home so we can see how we're doing! And it sounds like Villa Josine was the perfect place for you! Please tell us when you're coming back ~ we love seeing happy, familiar faces. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Rooster Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

we loved it!!

The property was exactly as described, cozy and comfortable, with a beautiful and very private back porch, yard and pool. We had everything we needed, and the staff was super-friendly. Very close to restaurants and activities.

Submitted by Montclair NJ on Jan 21, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What kind words for Rooster Conch. We love that pool and are glad you enjoyed it. Please come back again, and often! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

very satisfied

Total satisfaction

Submitted by Chestertown MD on Jan 19, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Very glad! Hope you'll come back again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

exceptional family holiday vacation

We loved everything about this wonderful rental property. Spacious and clean with a great layout. The design of the outside deck and pool creates an integrated feel for the whole property. Childproof locks on all doors were perfect to ensure our two small grandkids were kept safe. It's located in a a quiet part of Old Town with easy access to any of the main tourist destinations. We decided to rent a 6-person golf cart rental and had a blast navigating Old Town. The staff at HKWVR were all extremely professional, responsible and helpful.

Submitted by West Hollywood CA on Jan 19, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so kindly for the nice review of Southard Comfort (and us!). Southard Comfort is a great home and we're glad you enjoyed making some family memories there. And so glad you got a golf cart ~ walking, biking, golf carting around Key West is the best way to see everything! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Grand Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

fantastic family home

We took our adult kids n spouses and loved staying here. Everyone had their own rooms w private bathroom. It was a gorgeous home. Extremely comfortable furniture in den n kitchen for all of us to gather n play cards or snack. The pool was wonderful to relax n laugh after long busy day before dinner

Submitted by Temple GA on Jan 18, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You explained exactly how Grand Maison should be stayed in! It's great for families or groups who need their space, but together. Please come and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

well kept secret amidst the action!

From start to finish, this experience was top-notch! The host quickly emailed to confirm the no-refund policy, make a suggestion about travel insurance, and explain amenities. There was ongoing communication prior to the arrival, including status updates day of. The house is perfectly located and impeccably appointed. We found that the pizza restaurant owners next door knew the owner and spoke as highly of not only her personality but also the location. It aligned with everything we experienced. Communication was prompt, clear, and accurate. This location ensured maximum privacy right while being conveniently located to all attractions.

Submitted by Birmingham AL on Jan 16, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear that you enjoyed your time at Cloud 9. We love hearing about a good, happy experience. Please come and stay with us again and make some more memories. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

5 star home

Dreaming on Duval is a beautiful home with so many special is amazing from top to bottom; front to back...the pool is perfect too!!

Submitted by Glen Allen VA on Jan 15, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for noticing the care we put into Dreaming on Duval. We feel it's a great home as well! Please tell us when you'll be back ~ we'll be here! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

great week

This property is beautiful inside and out. Amenities were exceptional especially the ice machine on the back deck. A second fridge would be a good addition if possible. Location on Duval is perfect, close enough to walk to multiple attractions but far enough from the hustle and bustle of the crowds.

Submitted by Springfield OH on Jan 14, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

An ice machine is super important for cold porch drinks! We're glad you appreciated it. We hope you'll come and stay with us again ~ soon? ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

you won't find better than this.

The home was gorgeous inside and out and the location was perfect. Would highly recommend and rent again.

Submitted by Shorewood IL on Jan 13, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are looking forward to seeing you again! Please hurry back ~ we like seeing happy, familiar faces. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Maisons de Luxe - Nightly Group Rental

5.0

key west christmas

We rented both properties and it was perfect. We consisted of grandparents, three sets of parents and two sets of cousins-four years old and younger. The houses and pool provided us with a great base. The location gave us everything else. There were so many food, drink and entertainment options that we could walk to. We will be back.

Submitted by Warwick NY on Jan 12, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are expecting you back now ~ all of you ~ anytime! Thanks for being great guests! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect

The property, the living quarters, the location, was all perfect. The process was smooth and professional. The living area was clean, attractive, updated, and comfortable. The location was perfect - one block from Duval Street, walking distance to everything. The courtyard is a very nice place to relax and meet a few neighbors. We’ll definitely try to stay here the next time we go to Key West.

Submitted by Broken Arrow OK on Jan 11, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We would love to see you again, anytime! La Maisonnette is a great home and in a great location. We'll see you soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

lily's pad the perfect key west paradise!

We can't say enough about this experience! the property is absolutely beautiful and perfectly located with all the amenities. We will stay here again! Not to mention that Key West Historic Vacation Rentals were so wonderful to do business with, so kind, friendly and thoughtful with all the communications and information. Our only critique is that the upstairs suite was a bit hot.

Submitted by Port Deposit MD on Jan 08, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review Lilly's Pad ~ we appreciate your taking the time and for letting us know about the upstairs. We will definitely look into that! Please come back and let us know how we did. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

lovely, clean, great location

This is a fabulous rental and I would definitely return. It’s a pretty house very close to restaurants and shops on Duval Street but its own little oasis. The yard with the small but wonderful “dipping pool” and lovely outdoor seating is peaceful and beautiful and the house was extremely clean and well designed. The management company was highly responsive and helpful. I highly recommend this rental.

Submitted by Upper Montclair NJ on Jan 08, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Chick-a-Pea Cottage and can't wait to see you or your friends! Thank you for the kind review. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Rooster Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

cozy spot

The Rooster Conch is a perfect lil spot! I love that it’s quiet and cozy and right down the street from some of my favorite restaurants and shops ❤️

Submitted by Lexington KY on Jan 07, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy that you enjoyed your stay at Rooster Conch! It is a great space, indoor and out! Come see us again in beautiful Key West~ Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

solaris garden

Very charming place. We would love to stay again.

Submitted by Lakewood CO on Jan 07, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review Solaris Garden! It's a gem in a great location. We can't wait for you to come back to sunny Key West! ~Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect rental for our december stay

We stayed three nights (2 adults and a 1 year old) and the location and unit could not have been better. Everything was clean and nicely updated, and we were close to Duval but escaped the noise. The folks at Key West Vacation Rentals were also super friendly and accommodating. Would definitely rent from them again!

Submitted by Port Orange FL on Jan 07, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your great review Meghan! Horse Conch is a great home in a perfect location. We are happy that you were happy with our service! Come and see us again in fabulous Key West~ Lori and the Team at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

christmas family trip

Cloud Nine was the perfect place for our family Christmas vacation. The location was ideal for all the events, and using a golf cart to get around was great.

Submitted by Cleveland GA on Jan 06, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for reviewing Cloud 9. It's a fabulous home in a prime location. Come see us again in beautiful Key West! ~Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great location, cute house!

Location and amenities were just like the pictures and description. My husband and I enjoyed staying at the cottage for an anniversary trip. Would definitely return for another get away!

Submitted by Forest Park IL on Jan 04, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you Rachelle for your kind review of Potter's Cottage. It's a great home and location. Come and see us again in sunny Key West! ~Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Solaris Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place to stay in key west!

We spent 6 nights here and found it the perfect base of operations for a holiday in Key West. Centrally located and walkable to everything. In a quiet residential area off the beaten path but again steps to everything. We would definitely stay here again.

Submitted by Annapolis MD on Jan 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Well we definitely want to see you again! Thank you for the kind review of Solaris Garden ~ you now have your own vacation home here with us and are welcome any time! ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

loved this cozy cottage

Potter's Cottage was in a great location and was perfect for our 5 day New Year's vacation. It was very clean, well-appointed and had everything we needed. We enjoyed the pool too! We liked that it was just a block off the quieter end of Duval, and we easily walked or biked to everything we wanted to do. The room with the pullout couch had doors for privacy and was just big enough for the bed unfolded, but my 5'11" son said it was very comfortable, and he was happy in there. One thing to note is the steps to the upstairs bedroom are steep, so this is not a cottage for someone who has issues with stairs.
We really appreciated the help of the wonderful staff at HKWVR planning our first trip to Key West!

Submitted by Washington DC on Jan 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Happy New Year! Thank you for taking the time to review Potter's Cottage so kindly. We are looking forward to your next visit ~ you always have a vacation home with us! ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Casablanca Too - Nightly Rental

5.0

christmas in the keys

This was the perfect stay for my holiday! The location is convenient, walking distance to everything you need. The area does get a bit noisy on the weekends but it's tolerable. The space is cozy yet maintains a light and airy feel. The hosts were wonderful and very responsive when I had a maintenance issue. The hot tub was a real treat and it was great having a designated parking space for my car. Highly recommend and reasonably priced, I would stay again!

Submitted by Ft Lauderdale FL on Jan 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again ~ we love seeing happy, familiar faces. Thanks for being a great guest! ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Casablanca Too - Nightly Rental

5.0

nice place and great location.

The time we spent in Key West was great, even with only one good day of sunshine. Our rental was clean, comfortable and well located. We rented a car but honestly it was a waste of money. We walked to practically everywhere we wanted to go on Key West except Fort Zachary. Next time we visit we will rent bikes. The only negative about the location at 817 White street is the traffic. We enjoyed sitting on the front porch in the evenings but the traffic got quite loud at times, not enough of a turn off not to visit this place again.

Submitted by Lewisburg TN on Dec 31, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Casablanca Too and hope you're making plans to come and stay with us again (that hot tub). We're also glad you got to enjoy some Key West life by being on the porch! That's the best way to observe our world. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

great location

My husband and our teenage daughter spent a few days in Key West recently. This rental is in a perfect location for seeing sights, eating and shopping all within walking and/or biking distance.

Submitted by Elmhurst IL on Dec 31, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are happy you enjoyed your stay at Poinciana Garden and hope you'll come back and stay with us again, and soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

great home!

The house was perfect for a large group of various ages and in a great location!

Submitted by Charlotte NC on Dec 31, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a great way to explain Dreaming on Duval ~ we agree! We hope we'll see you all again ~ you now have a vacation home in Key West. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

christmas family week at key west - 2023

Wow, what a great rental in paradise. All previous reviews are spot on, great rental with no surprises. All the standard stuff you expect to be great is. Plus some personal peeves I have with older properties were non-existent. For example, all sink drains...drained. The propane grill had propane and was cared for and set up for proper use. The ignitor worked. The pool was indeed properly heated. Our air temp during the day was low to mid 70's...the pool was 94 --- so, so comfy. Plenty of pool towels, Ice machine worked great. On street parting was no problem, two great restaurants (Mangia Mangia and Bob's on Margaret) right next door. And so on...

In short super property and super responsive guest focused rental management company.

Submitted by Leland NC on Dec 31, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Well, thank you! We're blushing for all the kind words, but agree that Chavez House is an amazing home. Please come and stay with us again ~ you are always welcome to come and make some more memories with us! ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect location!

Beautifully renovated home in an excellent location. We were less than a block from some of our most favorite Key West restaurants.

Submitted by Pittstown NJ on Dec 30, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That sounds like an ideal location for you! Please come and stay with us again ~ we love to see happy, familiar faces. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Fair Winds at the Foundry - Weekly Rental

5.0

great location

We loved the location. The condo was clean worked well for our family of 4. Historic Key West did a great job of keeping us apprised of the check-in process, kept our bags when we arrived early and coordinated our bike drop off. Very happy with our stay. We will be back.

Submitted by Meridian MS on Dec 28, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time and that we met (exceeded?) your expectations! Please come and stay with us again, anytime, but hopefully soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place to spend a few days in key west

Had an outstanding stay. The place was perfect for my wife and I to have a great 5-night stay during the Christmas holiday. The rental is situated within an one-mile walk of all the Key West highlights and restaurants. Crucial for a Key West stay is the parking at this unit. Parking is $5/hour around Key West so the ability to park and walk/bike/scooter is great. The unit was exactly as pictured in the ad and has all the basics to support a stay of up to four. The unit was also clean on arrival. We did not use the pull out, but the bedroom mattress was very comfortable, and the two split unit HVACs kept the place very cool when set to 72F. The laundry allowed us to pack a little lighter since we were able to wash our laundry mid-stay, and the machine and dryer were large capacity and newer models. The unit is also on a “side street” allowing for a quieter stay at night but only a few blocks to all the Key West action of Duval Street and Old Town. The host organization communicated by text several times during our stay to check on our needs and offered their concierge services. Can’t say enough good things. We will definitely use this host organization for our next stay.

Submitted by Aiken SC on Dec 28, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time in Key West and at Poinciana Treetop and hope you're already making plans to come and see us again, and soon. We love the way you described the home ~ it's nice to 'hear' a true guest perspective on our homes. We're here waiting for all your holiday stays (and more!)! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

great location!

This was our 2nd time staying at the Poinciana and we'll definitely be back. Perfect spot for a couple, with an additional pull-out sofa for a child. The location is ideal...walking distance to the hustle and bustle of Duval, but situated on a very quiet street so you can get away from it all and get some sleep. Less than a mile to Higgs Beach in one direction or Mallory Square in the other. Hot tub was a huge bonus.

Submitted by Nokomis FL on Dec 27, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We were so happy to see you again and hope you're already making plans to come back for that charming 3rd visit! Thanks for being a great and loyal guest. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

great location!

What you see is what you get! This house was perfect for our get away w/our college girls before the holiday. Fantastic location, nice pool, we really enjoyed the porch in the early mornings, slept well, couldn't ask for more :-) I even began to like the rooster that shocked me bright and early on the first morning...lol!

Submitted by Lexington KY on Dec 22, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You got to meet the bonus rooster? That's amazing! He only comes out for special guests! Come and stay with us again. We're always happy to have him crow for you again. Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

wonderful stay!

We loved our cottage, and it was close to everything. The cottage was very clean and had everything we needed. We loved sitting on the front porch and watching the people walk by. We would stay here again!

Submitted by Centennial CO on Dec 18, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

And Potter's Cottage is always yours when you're ready to come back and make some more memories! We love seeing happy, familiar faces! Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

a wonderful property

Cloud 9 was one of the best properties my family has ever rented. From the location to the cleanliness to the amenities, this home was perfect! The management company maintained constant communication. Would absolutely rent this home again!

Submitted by Lake Charles LA on Dec 18, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love hearing how nice Cloud 9 is because we wholly agree with you! Please just tell us when you're coming back ~ you always have a home with us. Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Pair-A-Dise - Nightly Rental

5.0

vacation dec. 2023

My husband and I traveled with another couple. The property was perfect for that. We had our own space and so did they, yet we could gather together outdoors in a shared space. Great location and it was a quiet neighborhood!

Submitted by Brockway MI on Dec 16, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you all enjoyed your time at Solaris Pair-a-Dise! We hope you are already making plans to come back and stay with us again ~ at Solaris Cottage, Solaris Garden or all together at Pair-a-Dise. Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

amazing key west experience

Excellent home in a fabulous location! We had our own oasis in the middle of the island.

Submitted by Billings MT on Dec 12, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love how you put that ~ "your own oasis". Perfect description! Hope you're making plans to come and stay with us again ~ we'd love to have you. Anytime! ~Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place to stay in key west

Rental was perfect. Great location. Very clean. Porch was great for morning coffee. Communication with staff was very fast and everyone was very nice.

Submitted by milford MI on Dec 12, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you ~ we think you are nice, too! Hope you'll come back and see us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

key west rental

The property is gorgeous, very well maintained, and in a perfect Key West location. Highly recommend.

Submitted by Fort Lauderdale FL on Dec 11, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Hope you're already making plans to come back and stay with us again, and soon! We want to hear more about how great Horse Conch is. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

key west girls trip

We had a great time staying at the butterfly cottage! It was 10 to 15 minutes from everywhere we wanted to go. We really enjoyed the hot tub too.

Submitted by Raleigh NC on Dec 11, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Happy you enjoyed the hot tub ~ and the location, too! We get a lot of nice comments about Butterfly Cottage. Thank you for giving us another!. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

fun on dural

Sweet little hideaway in a perfect location. Staff helpful with every thing.
Blue Heaven was a treat for dinner and the French pastry gem on Duval is perfect for breakfast

Submitted by Stuart FL on Dec 08, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Petite Maison and can't wait to see you again! Thank you for being a great guest! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Seas The Day! - Weekly Rental

5.0

excellent experience at seas the day

My son, daughter-in-law, and I made a last minute vacation change and were blessed to find and select the Seas The Day VRBO. We had a cruise planned planned for 4 months, and 1 1/2 days to departure, Carnival notified us of the cruise cancelation due to ship engine problems.
The condo was in a great location of all activities on and around Duval Street, and the warm where we could watch the World Offshore boat races. We didn't need a rental car, as we could easily walk to most of the island. The condo was clean, with a wonderful patio, and all the basic amenities, washer/dryer, kitchen, iron, hair dryer, and 3 televisions.

Submitted by Casa Grande AZ on Dec 06, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So happy you had a great time in Key West and enjoyed your time at Seas the Day! We love that you enjoyed walking around the island ~ the free Duval Loop Bus is also always a great way to get from one end to the other. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Villa Azul - Monthly Rental

5.0

november getaway

Everything was perfect with the unit and the keyless system made check-in/check-out easy. House was extremely clean, up to date, and very functional. A nice touch was that all of the light switches are labeled. The parking space is also a huge plus in Key West. A couple of suggestions which would be nice are:

Provide a couple of beach chairs for beach visits.

Trim back the overgrowth on the pool deck and back yard area. There was virtually no sunshine available and the pool strainer filled up with dropped foliage every day.

Great stay and highly recommend.

Submitted by Sandusky OH on Dec 06, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We appreciate your taking the time to review us so kindly and with some great suggestions. I'm happy you enjoyed your time and hope you'll come back and see what we've done. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

friend trip

The house was amazing and very clean. Location was perfect and within walking distance from everything we did. The staff at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals were so helpful and accommodating. They were easy to get in touch with and so kind.

Submitted by Paragould AR on Dec 06, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you! You're too kind to say we're so kind. Hope you're already making plans to come and see us again! Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Casablanca Too - Nightly Rental

5.0

fabulous!

Wonderful location, accommodations lacked nothing; even sent a tech out on a Sunday to see why one of the TV’s wouldn’t turn on. Highly recommended!!

Submitted by NORTH PORT FL on Dec 06, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Wow! We sound as wonderful as you are. Hope you'll come and see us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Tropical Dream - Monthly Rental

5.0

escape to paradise

Wonderful home in a great location. Easy walk to some great neighborhood restaurants. Plenty of room for all. The folks at Historic Key West Rentals were very responsive and accommodating. Have used them several times before with no issues or disappointments. Will reach out to them again for our next visit. Miss Key West already.

Submitted by San Antonio TX on Dec 05, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We were so happy to see you again, and Key West misses you, too! Hurry back, please and thank you. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect location

The Butterfly Cottage was perfect for out stay on Key West. It is strategically located right in the middle so you can walk everywhere. The cottage is the perfect size for 4 adults, with lovely outdoor space so we could enjoy the evenings in the hot tub. We would definitely stay here again. The communication was the best and we had no issues with the house.

Submitted by Orange Beach FL on Dec 01, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you Julie, for taking time to review Butterfly Cottage. It is a great home in the perfect location! We look forward to your next stay with us~ Lori and the Team at HKWVR

Tropical Dream - Monthly Rental

5.0

wonderful stay

We had a great time at this wonderful house. Perfect location, great space, and all the amenities. Great to be able to easily park and close enough to everything that we never moved the car again after. Porches are great for people watching. The few issues we had were quickly dealt with by the great team at HKWVR. Can't wait to come back next time I can justify leaving home for a month :)

Submitted by Washington DC on Nov 28, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That is exactly what we mean by 'live like a local' for the month ~ park once and don't look at your car again. It's the joy of island living! We hope you'll come and make some more memories with us. Maybe you can work from 'home'? Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

cute little place

The house is very cute and clean. Nice location, close to all the fun but not too close so it's nice and quiet. Staff was really responsive to any requests. I will definitely say the bed needs to be replaced. It sagged in the center really bad and my husband kept rolling over on me. We will definitely stay again.

Submitted by Lake Stevens WA on Nov 28, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the honest review and we will definitely check into the bed situation. Hope you'll come and see our improvements. Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

key west cottage

What a fantastic, little romantic cottage... Right off Duval Street with access to everything especially the marina where we spent most of our time... Perfect little one bedroom with a small kitchen and TV room for that romantic weekend getaway...
The cottage had everything... Wi-Fi, plenty of cooking utensils, although we went out every night... Everything was perfect, including a very easy, remote contactless check in... Kim at the home office was fantastic to work with... Everybody was very easy, and I am definitely going to stay in that same cottage next year when we’re back for the powerboat races... Highly recommend and a very happy customer.

Submitted by Brick NJ on Nov 28, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time with us and are already making plans to come and stay again! Thank you for the kind review ~ and we like our fantastic Kim as well. Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

excellent key west vacation

We were very happy with our overall experience and a large portion of our satisfaction was due to our stay at the Historic Key West vacation rental.

Submitted by Overland Park KS on Nov 27, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love to hear that we were part of your experience and memories! Please come and stay with us at Chick-a-Pea Cottage again, anytime! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect gorgeous home!

This gorgeous house really did feel like a home! The owners of obviously put meticulous care into curating and decorating this house, which made it feel more like a home during our vacation. It was a great location for getting to restaurants and shops. We enjoyed the pool and the lush vegetation outside every day.

Submitted by New Lennox IL on Nov 27, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Villa Josine ~ a good experience is so important for a good vacation and making memories! So, hurry back! You need to be here again soon. ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

pristine cottage with an awesome location!

My husband, parents and I decided to spend Thanksgiving in Key West and were delighted with Butterfly Cottage! We couldn’t get over how clean it was when we arrived. Just two blocks off Duval, it was super convenient but also nice and quiet!

Submitted by Delray Beach FL on Nov 27, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We're so happy you noticed the hard work our housekeepers put into cleaning our homes. They deserve most of the credit for our guests' incredible stays. Come back and stay with us at Butterfly Cottage again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Villa Azul - Monthly Rental

5.0

key west gem

Villa Azul was perfect for entertaining all of our family and friends who stayed with us throughout the month. Located on a very quiet/private street and really close to the seaport and Duval. The backyard was very private with lush landscaping and a beautiful pool area. The pool was heated which made it easy to swim on the chillier evenings. The house has a great layout for multiple guests to have their own privacy. Super clean home and the staff at HKWVR was very accommodating to all our requests, definitely top notch service and attention. I would 100% rent this beautiful home again.

Submitted by Redington Shores FL on Nov 26, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Wow! We thank you for the kind words about your 'living like a local' stay at Villa Azul! We hope you're already making plans for your next stay ~ it's a great place to stay, summer or winter (or fall and spring!). Just hurry back! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

no car required and still quiet

The space was exactly as described. It was clean, complete, and comfortable with an authentic old Florida feel. It would be a great place for a couple, but I was there with my daughter and was easily able to sleep on the sofa comfortably. Fousto's Food Market, bars and restaurants are all within easy walking distances. Cars, scooters and golf carts were not part of the experience we wanted and this place worked well for that purpose.

Submitted by Wyndmoor PA on Nov 25, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Solaris Garden! Please come back and stay with us again ~ we love seeing happy, familiar faces. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Casablanca Grande - Nightly Rental

5.0

fantastic space

Very clean and the duplex for two couples was perfect!

Submitted by Groton CT on Nov 21, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind words about Casablanca Grande! Casablanca Nightly and Casablanca Too are great together (Grande) or separately for individual couples. We hope we'll see you all again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great house and location

Rented this house for a 3 night stay for our annual guys' fishing trip. 6 guys in their 50's stayed here comfortably. The house was perfectly located to walk to everything we needed. Didn't even bother to rent a car for our stay. The house was clean, well organized, and the small pool in the back was perfect for cooling off. Highly recommend!

Submitted by Plymouth MI on Nov 14, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You are right ~ Chick-a-Pea Cottage is great for the guys or the girls, or both! Even though there is parking here, it's so convenient to walk or ride bikes or take the free Duval Loop Bus... ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Reel Paradise - Monthly Rental

5.0

awesome!

Wonderful place. Well kept, great location, extremely responsive property managers. Will definitely be back

Submitted by Fort Mitchell KY on Nov 14, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the nice words about Reel Paradise. We are so happy you came and lived like a local with us for the month, and we can't wait to see you again! ~ Jennifer @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

amazing key west property

One of the best places we have stayed in Key West! The property was perfect. It housed 4 adults comfortably and provided a super convenient location within walking/biking distance of everything we did. The backyard was incredible. We spent a few days hanging out by the pool instead of going out because it was so enjoyable! Hands down a top not choice for a Key West vacation!

Submitted by Pensacola FL on Nov 14, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Wow! What a great review of Sea Conch! So happy to know you enjoyed the home and the pool area. Please tell us when you'll be back ~ we like seeing happy, familiar faces! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect house!

The layout, furnishings and decor in this home is all well thought out and perfect! Historic Key West Vacation Rentals goes above and beyond with communication.

Submitted by Hendersonville NC on Nov 14, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Well, that is just so nice to hear! We love our Lilly's Pad and can't wait for you to come and stay with us again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

great home & location

Great location near all of the Key West activities yet in a quiet well kept neighborhood. Home was spotless & well stocked. Management company was outstanding & provided great tips for restaurants, bars, & activities. We will definitely book this property again on our future visits to Key West. Thank you.

Submitted by Naples FL on Nov 14, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

How nice to hear you had a good time at Poinciana Garden! We can't wait for you to book again, and we hope it's soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Maisons de Luxe - Nightly Group Rental

5.0

the best of the best!

This property was absolutely perfect for our Key West stay. We had enough space for everyone -rented both spaces. The house was full of charm and character. No details were spared. It’s in the prime spot and we even had a private chef for dinner who had ample space and stocked kitchen. The pool and deck area was used the most and provided enough space to hang out comfortably. All of the rooms had their own private bath so that was an extra perk. We really enjoyed being close to everything! We hope to be back!

Submitted by Moncks Corner SC on Nov 14, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Wow! Thank you for the awesome review! We are so happy to hear you had a nice time and took full advantage of Maisons de Luxe's many amenities. Hope you'll make it back again soon. Remember ~ Grand Maison can sleep up to 8 and Petite Maison 4, so come all or come in smaller groups! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Chick-a-Pea Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

a great stay in an amazing house

From booking to check out, communication was excellent. Very helpful and friendly.

Submitted by Brick NJ on Nov 13, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We like to hear nice things about Chick-a-Pea... and about us! Thank you for taking the time to say so. We hope you're already making plans to come and see us again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Maisons de Luxe - Nightly Group Rental

5.0

beautiful property in great location

We loved this property! With 10 guests we had plenty of indoor and outdoor space to relax and enjoy each others company. This property is located on the quiet end of Duval near great restaurants! Highly recommend!

Submitted by Kernersville NC on Nov 13, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy everyone had a great time at Maisons de Luxe! Everyone needs to come back again and make some more memories! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

just like the pictures!

The unit was beautifully furnished and updated. Although it was very clean, it did have a musty smell. Very comfortable stay, location ideal and the courtyard was a quaint retreat away from the activity of Key West.

Submitted by White Bear Lake MN on Oct 18, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at La Maisonnette! Please come and see us again, and soon. We like seeing familiar faces! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

literally on "cloud 9"

Our October trip to "Cloud 9" was clearly one of the best ever. From booking the trip and interacting with the professional management team to spending several days in a true Oasis, there is not a better place to stay in KW. House was spotless, in ideal location, very well stocked and extremely comfortable for all of us. I wish I could find one criticism, but honestly, I cannot. This IS the place to stay in KW.

Submitted by Fair Oaks Ranch TX on Oct 14, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We can't find any criticisms about you, either! We hope you'll come and stay again ~ Cloud 9 will be like your very own vacation home! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Southard Comfort - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect home for a perfect girl's trip!

This was the perfect home for our girl's trip! 3 Beds? check. 3 Baths? check. Pool? check. Counter space for all of our wine and vodka? check. We really enjoyed the home, it's amenities and our time in Key West!

Submitted by Atlanta GA on Oct 13, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Well next time we hope we're invited! So glad to hear you enjoyed your time at Southard Comfort and we hope you'll all come and see us again, and soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Maisons de Luxe - Nightly Group Rental

5.0

fall vacation

Excellent facility, ideally located, easy walk to downtown. Great bedroom/bath combination.

Submitted by Peachtree City GA on Oct 10, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so glad you enjoyed your time at Maisons de Luxe! Please come and stay with us again, anytime. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Poinciana Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

key west getaway

Great rental, property was in great shape. A block and a half from Duval St., we never used our car the whole stay. Everything is walkable. Easy check in and out. Would definitely stay again.

Submitted by Oconomowoc WI on Oct 09, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Poinciana Garden ~ and we agree parking once and walking (or biking, riding the free Duval Loop Bus) is the best way to get around our little island! Please come and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

absolutely amazing vacation rental

Our stay at the Sea Conch is our best experience yet visiting Key West! The home was immaculately clean, beautifully decorated, and well-furnished! Historic Key West Vacations is our new favorite rental company! Thank you for providing such a fantastic Key West Experience!

Submitted by Proctorville OH on Oct 04, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You like us! You really like us! We like you too and agree Sea Conch is amazing. We hope we'll see you again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect location

Cloud 9 is gorgeous! With three beautiful bedrooms and baths, it was perfect for 3 couples looking for a getaway. The pool area was dreamy, and the location couldn’t have been better. Loved every second!

Submitted by Johns Island SC on Oct 04, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Cloud 9 and hopefully you will be back to make some more memories with us! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

amazing place!

Check in was easy, staff was wonderful. Place was immaculate! Had a wonderful stay and do very much recommend!

Submitted by College Park GA on Sep 28, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind words about us and Sea Conch! We hope we'll see you again, and soon. Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Queen Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place to stay in key west

Truly enjoyed the property! Well maintained, staff very responsive before and during the stay. Fantastic location! Pool area is awesome. Lots of seating and privacy.

Submitted by Bloomington IL on Sep 26, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so kindly for the nice review of Queen Conch. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope you'll come and put your toes in the pool again. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

excellent location - perfect for 2 couples

The Butterfly Cottage was perfect for 2 couples spending a long weekend. The Cottage was clean and well stocked. The location was close enough to Duval and centrally located but far enough from the nighttime noise.

Submitted by Slidell LA on Sep 26, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Butterfly Cottage is definitely great for 2 couples, or a small family, and we're happy you enjoyed your time there! Please tell us you're making plans to come back! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

we enjoyed our long weekend!

Very relaxing! Short walk to Duval - very convenient location. Clean, comfortable, beautiful pool area, etc. we enjoyed our vacation and we will definitely be back.

Submitted by Tampa FL on Sep 26, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We will be counting the days until we see you again! We're here year round so you can come anytime. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect house rental for key west

This house was wonderful, the pool was nice and it was the perfect location for our trip of three couples to Key West. They had all of the things we needed and there is nothing I would changd.

Submitted by Raleigh NC on Sep 25, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Cloud 9 ~ it's definitely a fan favorite. Please let us know when you can come and stay with us again. We love seeing familiar faces. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Solaris Pair-A-Dise - Nightly Rental

5.0

best vacation ever

Amazing place to stay. SO nice having 2 separate homes. Gives you privacy from the other party but still allows you to come together for dinner and drinks. Clean, spacios...perfect home, close to everything! We will absolutely stay here again. Do yourself a favor, if you're traveling with another couple, family members or even teenage kids, this place is perfect!!!!

Submitted by Grand Ridge FL on Sep 04, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a perfect way to describe Solaris Pair-a-Dise and we appreciate your taking the time to do so! Please come and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Poinciana Paradise - Group Rental

5.0

the best of the keys

It was fantastic. Stay easy to get the keys. They helped with transportation to entertainment. The house was incredible. Plenty of space for the family and friends with a bonus Jacuzzi so close to the beach right in the heart of all of the phone. they Amazing sunset beautiful place can’t wait to come bacit was amazing stay easy to get the keys they helped with transportation to entertainment. The house was incredible. Plenty of space for the family and friends with a bonus Jacuzzi so close to the beach right in the heart of all of the fun amazing sunsets beautiful place can’t wait to come back. k.

Submitted by Panorama City CA on Aug 25, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We can't wait for you to come back either ~ we are happy to hear you had a great time! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Villa Josine - Nightly Rental

5.0

villa josine

One word, EXCELLENT. Thank you

Submitted by Hunsterson Nantwich on Aug 25, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Two words back ~ Thank you! Come and stay with us again! ~Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Ashe House - Monthly Rental

5.0

perfect key west experience

I can’t say enough about the quality of communication and attention to detail provide by the property manager for Ashe House. The house itself is wonderful as well, and equipped with everything you could need. Eleven stars out of ten!

Submitted by Houston TX on Aug 22, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the nice review! We hope to see you again soon! Come and make some more memories with us. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

Butterfly Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place to stay—clean, relaxing and close to everything!

We had a family of 4 and this small hose offered everything we needed! It was super clean and comfortable. Plus it was within walking distance to all the cool things to do in downtown Key West. We really enjoyed our stay and this rental played a big role in that!

Submitted by Niceville FL on Aug 18, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear about your trip! Come and make some more memories with us, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Rooster Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

great home in a great location

This was a great home in a great location. KWHV is a fabulous business to use for your Key West vacation. Very helpful and kind and fabulous customer service all around. We will definitely be using them again for future stays in KW.

Submitted by Durham CA on Aug 17, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the nice review of Rooster Conch ~ and of our staff! We hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Poinciana Treetop - Nightly Rental

5.0

poinciana treetop

Our stay at Poinciana Treetop was awesome! We loved the location and convenience. Very close to Duval Street. The place was very clean, stocked with everything we needed, and very comfortable! Checking in and out was easy, and the Property Manager gave us a lot of great info for dining and entertainment. 5 stars all the way around!

Submitted by Mount Dora FL on Aug 15, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love to be helpful because we feel our hometown is fun to share with guests. Hope you'll come and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

perfect

We loved our stay at Cloud 9. Property is beautiful, well maintained and very private. Pool is lovely and larger than we expected. Everything was perfect and we are looking to book again next year. HKWVR were friendly and great to work with. Any questions were answered quickly and easy key pick up and dropoff. Also lots of great suggestions for sightseeing and restaurants.

Submitted by Mason OH on Aug 13, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love being helpful to our guests while sharing our homes and town. We're glad to hear you're coming back to stay with us! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Fair Winds at the Foundry - Weekly Rental

5.0

perfect!

Absolutely perfect rental for our family of 4. Amazing location, everything you need!

Submitted by Chicago IL on Aug 12, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

So nice to hear that you enjoyed your time at Fair Winds! Please bring the family back soon and make some more memories. ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

nice little house in perfekt location at key west

We have been there as a familiy if 4 adults and enjoyed our stay very much. Key west is beautiful and the house is perfectly located to get to nice beaches, Duval street, Sounternpoint and hemmingway house. The kitchen is a little small and we missed a pot for cooking but this is solved by the rental office in the meantime.

Submitted by Kassel HE on Aug 12, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love to be able to solve a little issue and make things better! We hope you'll come back and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Queen Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

best place to stay in the keys

Best location, super clean, homey and spacious. Chickens live in the yard, it was great

Submitted by Lakeland FL on Aug 09, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed yourself (and the chickens) at Queen Conch! Please come and stay with us again, and soon. Remember that Queen Conch can accommodate the whole family or smaller groups with Sea Conch, Rooster Conch and Horse Conch. ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place to stay !

This house was perfect for my wife and I to celebrate our 9th wedding anniversary. We would love to go back this winter for another stay.

Submitted by Valparaiso IN on Aug 08, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It sounds like you need to come and stay with us for all the anniversaries! We hope to see you again this winter. ~ Jennifer @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

La Maisonnette, Nightly Rental

5.0

beautiful courtyard

Lovely, very clean townhouse in a convenient location.
Would stay there again. Only downside is parking.

Submitted by Fredericksburg VA on Aug 08, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of La Maisonnette! And yes, because it is in such a convenient location we always highly recommend that guests consider using all the great alternate methods of getting around Key West so they can park once and enjoy! ~ Jennifer @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Grand Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

beautiful property but...

This place is amazing- absolutely what we expected based on the photos. If you are considering this spot- book it! This place deserves a 15 on a scale from 1 to 10 for its location! literally a few feet from the Duval strip, the home is spacious, comfortable and clean.
The beds are comfortable, the outdoor pool and terrace were very attractive, the Bbq is a plus.
However, we didn’t give a five star because, unfortunately, it had zero kitchen or bathroom basics!
Most of us arrived from an international location and honestly, we didn’t appreciate to be told to go to the nearest supermarket upon arrival to buy salt, pepper and olive oil. This property is not on a cheap side, You would think, they would have minimum basics available.
We have stayed in a lot of cheaper homes with a few and sometimes a lot more of basics for guests to enjoy, especially the international guests.
It also lacked of communication with the rental company, we called several times to find out how to turn on the outdoor fans and only received an answer the next day.
So, overall, this was a great stay and perfect on the location side and the quality of the home, just make sure to travel with sugar, salt & pepper, oil, body soap and shampoo.
Should you have any questions, relax, the company will call you on island time.

Submitted by Quintas del Carmen Quintana Roo on Aug 02, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you kindly for the honest review of Grand Maison, we appreciate your taking the time to do so. We agree that Grand Maison has the perfect location! We do supply salt and pepper (but not oil) as well as soap. We would have been happy to replace them if we missed something. We just want to make sure you understand that we care about our guests and are sorry you didn't feel that from us. ~ Team Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Inn Cogneato Cottage - Monthly Rental

5.0

great visit!

We had a lovely visit and Inn Cogneato had everything we needed. The property was well-maintained, up-to-date, comfortable, and close to everything. Our daughter especially loved the pool. The management company was very helpful, responsive, and communicated frequently.

Submitted by Zionsville IN on Jul 31, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your month living like a local at Inn Cogneato! And we love to hear that we were helpful as well. That's very nice to know! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Solaris Garden - Nightly Rental

5.0

cozy little cottage

We enjoyed every minute at Solaris Garden. Will definitely return. Very pleased with Historic Key West Rentals.

Submitted by Canton GA on Jul 27, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for taking the time to review us ~ we hope you're making plans to come and see us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Cloud 9 - Nightly Rental

5.0

family birthday

Great!!!!

Submitted by Grand Junction CO on Jul 26, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We think you are pretty great too! Please come back and see us again! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Dreaming on Duval - Nightly Rental

5.0

absolutely wonderful

the house is huge and we absolutely loved it. It was so comfortable and right in the heart of things. Would stay here again in a heartbeat.

Submitted by Houston TX on Jul 26, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Our heart is beating fast waiting for your return to Dreaming on Duval! We love to see happy, familiar guests! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Poinciana Paradise - Group Rental

5.0

great alternative to a hotel

We rented both units (top and bottom) and had a relaxing stay. Easy access to everything we wanted to do. Area was quiet and felt safe during our stay. Parking worked for our two vehicles (small and medium SUVs) but think larger vehicles would struggle. Property management was very clear about parking and shared options for larger vehicles. We would certainly return.

Submitted by Lakewood Rch FL on Jul 26, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We certainly hope you will return and are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Poinciana Pair-a-dise! You are right that parking is tight and bigger cars are tough in little lanes. Let us know when you plan to come back! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

great house in quiet location

We had a great time - house is close enough to walk to most things or take the free air conditioned bus for the rest. Great Italian on the corner and plenty of other delicious restaurants/cafes within a couple of blocks. A/C works great and each room has its own unit - beds were comfortable; bed linens were not the best. And in classic Key West style, there is a rooster who walks the neighborhood each morning doing his patrol! We did bring our own pool Floats and outdoor speaker and did not see that the home had either.

Submitted by Greenville SC on Jul 25, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so glad you enjoyed your time (and the rooster) at Chavez House! Please come and stay with us again, and soon. ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Lilly's Pad- Nightly Rental

5.0

couldn't have been more pleased

We couldn't have been more pleased by this rental. It was clean, renovated, charming, and super close to Duval (the sane side). You're only a short golf cart jaunt to the madness, though. The pool and back patio area were awesome. And aside from the roosters letting themselves be heard early in the morning, this property is really quiet. We'd love to stay there again.

Submitted by Tampa FL on Jul 23, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind words about Lilly's Pad! We love this home and are so glad you did too. Please come and stay with us again, soon! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Petite Maison - Nightly Rental

5.0

great place to stay!

Very convenient to Duvall Street, the Southern Most Point, the butterfly museum, Hemingway House and the Key West Lighthouse. The house was exceptionally clean and was well stocked with everything we needed to enjoy our stay. Our family also rented Grand Maison so we had the whole property. It was great for the 10 of us. Parking around Key West is tough, so don’t waste time getting a rental car, just Uber. They are readily available and the cost is usually $10 or less.

Submitted by Winston-Salem NC on Jul 23, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the great review ~ and we agree with everything you said! Ubering (and bikes or golf carts) are the best way around the island and Petite Maison, while it has a parking spot, is just seconds to all the cool things to do in Key West. Come and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Chavez House - Nightly Rental

5.0

great house!

Great location. Beautiful house.

Submitted by Nashua NH on Jul 21, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the nice words about Chavez House! We hope you're already making plans to come and stay with us again. ~ Team HKWVR

Sea Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

haven in the heat

The place was perfect. Vacation with teenage grand daughters. Their first visit to Key West. While hot the location was great, the pool was beyond perfect, the rooms, beds, and all other amenities could not have been better.

Submitted by Little Rock AR on Jul 16, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We're so happy you enjoyed your vacation time with granddaughters! The pool is perfect for summertime (and granddaughters) and we hope you'll come and spend more time here making memories for everyone. ~ Team HKWVR

Casablanca Too - Nightly Rental

5.0

casablanc too

Home was very tidy and organized. The space was large enough for myself and very easy to "keep". Would definitely stay here again, hands down!

Submitted by Miami FL on Jul 15, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Casablanca Too. We hope you know that we love seeing familiar faces so please come and stay with us again, anytime! ~ Team HKWVR

Horse Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0

just as pictured

I stayed in one of the upstairs apartments and it was just as pretty as the pictures. Sparkly clean with nice decor, comfy and quiet although it’s 2 blocks from Duval St. The backyard is paradise and I had the pool to myself. I walked to the pier and along the docks the first night. On day 2 the apt mgr had a bike delivered and that was even better. I biked to my boat tour an.d Ft Zachary beach and shopping and threw towel and gifts in the bicycle basket. Now my brother and cousins want to stay in the Conch house too. The only downside is the inconvenience of picking up and dropping off keys at their office which is a mile away and in a commercial area with very little to walk to. They have absolutely no flexibility with checkout time so I had 4 hours to kill between dropping off my keys and ubering out to my flight.
Other than that I’d recommend it.

Submitted by Dayton OH on Jul 13, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It sounds like you had a lovely time at Horse Conch and we thank you for taking the time to review! We do have check in and out at the office (as well as luggage storage so you don't have to carry your stuff around with you) because we like being accessible to our guests; we have a large staff that is already in place for cleaning and maintenance so a late check out is rarely an option. We utilize every minute to keep our properties up to our high standards! We hope you'll come and stay with us again soon! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

Rooster Conch - Nightly Rental

5.0