5.0
april vacation
Perfect day for up for 2 couples. Spacious, immaculate, quiet. Very private deck surrounding back of house. 2 blocks off of Duval in the center of Old Town you can walk everywhere. Convenient outdoor laundry, shower. We’ll be back for sure.
Submitted by Fairfax VA on Apr 19, 2025
5.0
wonderful
We had a relaxing and fun filled vacation in Key West. Our cottage was adorable and beautifully maintained. Plus the location was perfect. It’s close to Duval St with all the fun shops and restaurants but it’s on a quiet side street.
Submitted by Wyncote PA on Mar 04, 2025
5.0
don't pass this rental up...
Perfect for our 10 day vacation... all on one floor, newly renovated with top of the line furnishings and equipment. Two bedrooms, two baths, both with walk in showers. It's in a quiet location in walking distance to many sites and restaurants. We enjoyed many meals on the wrap around deck with table and chairs in shaded areas. Good customer service from the property managers.
There's also an outdoor grill, hot tub, and parking.
We've already booked for 2026!
Submitted by Bethesda MD on Feb 28, 2025
5.0
butterfly cottage
This was a lovely rental. The kitchen was fully stocked and the bedrooms were very comfortable. We loved having the hot tub! Plus, the location was close to great restaurants and shopping.
Submitted by Omaha NE on Jan 14, 2025
5.0
great place to stay!
We enjoyed the Butterfly Cottage, it was beautiful and we enjoyed our coffee every morning on the deck.
Submitted by Chester VA on Dec 02, 2024
5.0
great long weekend - butterfly cottage in key west
Wrapping up a fantastic stay at Butterfly Cottage. One couple plus our friend. Total comfort for three. Would have also been fine with a fourth. Let’s just say that we couldn’t keep talking about how well done this layout was. Two king ensuite bedrooms. Kitchen with island and every conceivable necessity for a weekend trip. Coffee maker. Ice maker. Disposal. All drawers were labeled. All outlets were labeled. All doors had these little clear wall bumpers to protect but also prevent mishaps. The wrap around deck was great. Privacy if we wanted individual sides of the deck. Multiple sitting areas, a hot tub, exterior laundry. Off street parking. We were told parking for a small car. We rented a small SUV which fit fine. But we also had a few scooters we rented on island and a four seater cart. Room for all vehicles. Attentive staff via text message not so much because we needed anything but because they just checked in on us periodically. Even accommodated an early check in. All in all a great stay at a great property. We’ve used other rental companies in the past but will 100% be booking them again.
Submitted by Pittsburgh PA on Nov 25, 2024
5.0
butterfly cottage beauty
Awesome place to stay! It was beautifully done and very close to everything.
Submitted by Tampa FL on Sep 09, 2024
5.0
best little rental in kw
We loved the Butterfly Cottage. It was super convenient, completely updated and precious. The beds were extremely comfortable and the outside sitting area was a great place to wind down. We would definitely stay here again!
Submitted by Denham Springs LA on Sep 04, 2024
5.0
kw getaway
Perfect hide away and perfect location
For all activity. House is new. Clean and outstanding.
Submitted by Pembroke Pines FL on Jul 29, 2024
5.0
key west getaway
We met some friends down here and had the best time! Butterfly Cottage is absolutely adorable and in a great location within walking distance to everything!
Submitted by Castle Hayne NC on Jul 10, 2024
5.0
perfect key west stay
This place was perfect. Clean, close enough to walk everywhere, has everything and great beds. I would recommend this place to anyone.
Submitted by Huntertown IN on Jun 29, 2024
5.0
butterfly cottage
Perfect, beautiful place to stay, super clean..and of course location, location. We were able to walk everywhere! Loved it!
Submitted by Newnan GA on May 14, 2024
5.0
april vacation
Great rental with a convenient location.
Submitted by Southington CT on Apr 28, 2024
5.0
perfect peaceful location.
Property located close to Duval but located on a quiet side street. The property was spotless and updated and the rental company made everything effortless.
Submitted by Vestal NY on Apr 07, 2024
5.0
will definitely rent from hkwvr again!!!
Clear instructions throughout the stay. Excellent response when looking for specific things to do in KW, plus an excellent guide was provided for what was going on during our stay!
Submitted by Mineral Bluff GA on Apr 02, 2024
5.0
butterfly cottage
Awesome house, location, and staff
Submitted by Dakota Dunes SD on Mar 24, 2024
5.0
great cottage in old town key west
Pristine 2 bedroom cottage in great old town Key West location. Quiet neighborhood (other than occasional roosters, but those are everywhere) within walking distance to the many restaurants, bars, attractions in Key West. Immaculately finished spaces inside and outside. Loved it!
Submitted by Burtonsville MD on Mar 01, 2024
5.0
best vacation rental ever
Everything was perfect
Submitted by Mount Pleasant SC on Feb 19, 2024
5.0
beautiful, well-appointed, comfy, great location
Fantastic 2 Bdrm house with private deck, grill, hot tub. Well-appointed kitchen, comfortable beds, 2 full baths, clean. Quiet location, but easy walk to Duval St. Been to Key West many times and this was the best rental I have found.
Submitted by Warwick RI on Feb 07, 2024
5.0
butterfly cottage
This is a wonderful cottage: comfortable, quiet, clean & conveniently located. Everything we wanted to see was within an easy walking distance. The cottage itself was very cosy & cute. We wouldn’t hesitate to stay here again and would highly recommend it!
Submitted by Hot Springs National Park AR on Feb 01, 2024
5.0
key west girls trip
We had a great time staying at the butterfly cottage! It was 10 to 15 minutes from everywhere we wanted to go. We really enjoyed the hot tub too.
Submitted by Raleigh NC on Dec 11, 2023
5.0
perfect location
The Butterfly Cottage was perfect for out stay on Key West. It is strategically located right in the middle so you can walk everywhere. The cottage is the perfect size for 4 adults, with lovely outdoor space so we could enjoy the evenings in the hot tub. We would definitely stay here again. The communication was the best and we had no issues with the house.
Submitted by Orange Beach FL on Dec 01, 2023
5.0
pristine cottage with an awesome location!
My husband, parents and I decided to spend Thanksgiving in Key West and were delighted with Butterfly Cottage! We couldn’t get over how clean it was when we arrived. Just two blocks off Duval, it was super convenient but also nice and quiet!
Submitted by Delray Beach FL on Nov 27, 2023
5.0
excellent location - perfect for 2 couples
The Butterfly Cottage was perfect for 2 couples spending a long weekend. The Cottage was clean and well stocked. The location was close enough to Duval and centrally located but far enough from the nighttime noise.
Submitted by Slidell LA on Sep 26, 2023
5.0
great place to stay—clean, relaxing and close to everything!
We had a family of 4 and this small hose offered everything we needed! It was super clean and comfortable. Plus it was within walking distance to all the cool things to do in downtown Key West. We really enjoyed our stay and this rental played a big role in that!
Submitted by Niceville FL on Aug 18, 2023
5.0
the perfect key west cottage
We made the drive through the keys with another couple, staying at various hotels and resorts. Arriving in Key West, we received a friendly welcome to pick up our keys to The Butterfly Cottage. It was easy to find and perfect in every way for the 4 of us. Great furnishings, everything you need, clean, new, beautiful. Better than another hotel. Great location just a couple blocks away from Duval-which was also perfect because it was quiet at night. Highly recommend this beautiful Key West cottage.
Submitted by Coppell TX on Jun 15, 2023
5.0
great house, great location.
This was a great house for two couples. Completely renovated. Nicely appointed. Great location.
Submitted by Coral Gables FL on Jun 01, 2023
5.0
loved our butterfly cottage
The home is perfect, close to everything, clean, well kept, updated and we'll equipped. The communication was outstanding ahead of the trip as well as during the trip. We would definitely stay here again!
Submitted by Bastrop Texas on May 22, 2023
5.0
we loved it!
10 year anniversary trip!
Submitted by Eros LA on Mar 17, 2023
5.0
butterfly cottage
We thoroughly enjoyed staying here! Very close to everything, but far enough from noise and crowds. The cottage was in wonderful condition and very clean
Submitted by Brentwood TN on Mar 11, 2023
5.0
best key west stay.
Everything about this home was perfect. We were totally pleased and would stay again.
Submitted by Seguin TX on Dec 24, 2022
5.0
wonderful home
This home was above and beyond all our expectations. It was beautifully decorated along with every attention to detail. The kitchen had everything thing you could need and the bathrooms were stocked with more than enough for our 4 day stay.
We will definitely book this house again.
Submitted by Galveston TX on Nov 08, 2022
5.0
key west long weekend
Our first time staying in Key West and everything was great! VRBO makes the process super simple. We liked the Butterfly Cottage for its size and location. I would choose it for every visit.
Submitted by Newark DE on Oct 11, 2022
5.0
amazing property and staff
Amazing time visiting this cottage and the staff made it so simple
Submitted by St. John FL on Aug 02, 2022
5.0
great weekend getaway!!!
Centrally located and cozy 2 BR 2 Bath cottage in a very private street.
Walking distance everywhere!!!
Submitted by Coral Gables FL on Jul 21, 2022
5.0
exceeded even highest hopes!
Beautifully renovated, incredible location, fully stocked kitchen, pleasant and very warm check-in and text communications with management staff, and even a parking space! Can’t wait to return!
Submitted by Frisco TX on Jun 28, 2022
5.0
perfect location and adorable home!
The house is as close to perfect for a rental for our needs. Remodeled, walking distance to almost everything and lovely private back deck/hot tub area. The only complaint that we have is one no one can help, the roosters. They start crowing around 5am and it seems to be all day long! We've stayed in hotels on the island before and never had that problem but staying on a local street, there is this issue. Ear plugs, noise app, box fan or something provided by the rental would be amazing. Next time we come we'll be better prepared. Otherwise loved our stay!
Submitted by Charlotte NC on Jun 14, 2022
5.0
butterfly
We enjoyed our stay in Key West and the Butterfly Cottage. The cottage was very clean and functional for two couples. Its proximity to Duval street and other attractions made it a great place to land everyday.
Submitted by BOZEMAN MT on May 22, 2022
5.0
butterfly cottage perfection
Perfect cottage!!!! Like brand new everything!!! Clean! Stocked! Close to everything!!!
Submitted by Paragould AR on May 04, 2022
5.0
great!
Only one downside - AC return in master bedroom. Was quite noisy
Submitted by Oak Ridge TN on Apr 06, 2022
5.0
amazing stay at the perfect location
The hosts were friendly, attentive, and communicated with us from the moment we reserved the property. They were helpful and shared lots of resources about the area. The location was perfect for getting to Duval Street but just far enough away that it was quiet at night. Would stay at this location again in a heartbeat.
Submitted by Lebanon VA on Feb 07, 2022
5.0
beautiful home
We loved our stay at the Butterfly Cottage. The home was beautiful, contemporary, and very well stocked with items for guests. I think they thought of everything!
Submitted by Longwood FL on Nov 15, 2021
5.0
excellent!
I cannot say enough wonderful things about the rental property AND company! From the moment we arrived, we were treated like we had known the office staff for years. They are top notch - kind, professional, organized, knowledgeable. The property itself is immaculate. It has been recently renovated and is very clean, comfortable, stylish, quiet, but close enough to walk to everything. We would definitely stay in the same home again, but we loved the rental company so much, we’d like to see what else they have to offer!
Submitted by Midlothian VA on Oct 26, 2021
5.0
butterfly cottage is a great place to stay in key west!
Butterfly Cottage is nicely done. The accommodations are comfortable for two couples. It is furnished well and comfortable. The location is convenient to all of the Key West attractions and easy walking. It is a great place to stay.
Submitted by New Port Richey FL on Sep 05, 2021
5.0
perfect place
This cottage is a perfect stay. It was the cleanest place we've ever stayed and the appointments were the most thoughtful. The kitchen supplies were exactly what we needed and that is usually NOT the case.
Submitted by Morganton NC on Aug 26, 2021
5.0
key west butterfly house
Wonderful! The house was worth every penny we paid for it. It was in a great location, clean, and had all the amenities we needed.
Submitted by Burr Tidge IL on Jul 13, 2021
5.0
paradise
Such a relaxing 2 weeks. The newly renovated home is gorgeous and has everything you need. The outdoor shower and hot tub were especially nice. The staff at Historic Key West Vacations were very helpful and informative.
Submitted by Battle Creek MI on Apr 27, 2021
5.0
butterfly
wonderful need ice cubes
Submitted by Wellfleet MA on Apr 10, 2021
5.0
beautiful cottage
This newly renovated cottage is perfect. Centrally located in Old Town, stocked with everything needed for 1 or 2 couples. We really enjoyed the gorgeous deck and hot tub. Would definitely stay here again.
Submitted by Warren PA on Apr 04, 2021
5.0
amazing!
The Butterfly Cottage is completely renovated beautifully! In fact, my daughter wants her bathroom at home to be remodeled like the en suite to her room at the cottage. Spacious for our family of four - parents and two teenagers. Loved the outdoor deck area with hot tub. Kitchen was easy to use. Stocked with all the accessories we needed. Great location. We biked everywhere. Enjoyed the swing, listening to the roosters and watching the cats walk by. We feel lucky we found this rental!
Submitted by Columbus IN on Mar 25, 2021
5.0
perfection!
This cottage is absolutely perfect! Beautifully remodeled in a great location. Extremely clean and comfortable. Historic Key West Vacation Rentals is by far the most accommodating leasing company we have worked with and Cindy was always there for last minute concierge services. Not one complaint!
Submitted by Brenham TX on Mar 17, 2021
5.0
walker brown
Butterfly cottage is ideal in every way! It’s well appointed! The outdoor patio area is beautiful! I enjoyed the hot tub! The linens are very comfortable! The kitchen tools were more than sufficient for cooking and entertaining! The cottage is a 5!!!
I loved staying here!!! Thanks!!!
Submitted by Carrboro NC on Feb 25, 2021