5.0
great place for 2 couples traveling together
Check in was super easy. Trying to decide who got which unit was super easy because they’re exactly the same. The hard decision was who felt like climbing the stairs to the 2nd floor unit! The location is great, close to just about everything that you’re there for. Getting an Uber was never more than a 3 minute wait for the places you didn’t want to walk to. Never needed to contact the host because everything was perfect!
Submitted by North Port FL on Apr 24, 2026
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thank you for the kind review of Poinciana Paradise! We hope you'll think of us when you come back to Key West!
~ The Team @ HKWVR
5.0
definitely would come back!
We really enjoyed this spot, near Duval but quiet. It was just as described. Clean and well maintained. We rented both floors and spent a lot of time on the patio enjoy the space.
Submitted by Hastings MI on Apr 07, 2026
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
What a nice review ~ we appreciate your taking the time to leave it!
~ The Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
5.0
ideal rental!
We rented this home with another couple. Each of us had a clean, newly renovated private one BR, one Bathroom apartment located a few blocks from Duval St. - close but not too close to the shops and restaurants. We highly recommend!
Submitted by Amherst MA on Mar 12, 2026
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thank you for the kind review of Poinciana Paradise! We hope you'll come again and soon.
~ The Team @ HKWVR
5.0
nice house
The house is separated into 2 unconnected units. Identical units, one upstairs and one downstairs. It was very clean, bright, and had everything we needed. There was a very nice screened porch off the downstairs bedroom, with a ceiling fan. It was in a very good area, walkable to Duval St.
Submitted by Griffin GA on Jul 08, 2025
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thank you for the helpful review of Poinciana Paradise ~ we love your description!
Hope you'll come and stay with us again ~ either at Poinciana Garden (downstairs) or Poinciana Treetop (upstairs) or both ~ Paradise!
The Team @ HKWVR
5.0
great stay for a group!
We met a group of friends in Key West and it was nice to have separate spaces but one place to stay. The back yard area was nice to gather together each day. Close to Duvall and everything we needed. The place was clean, the beds were very comfortable, and the kitchen had everything we needed to grab a quick breakfast.
Submitted by Olympia WA on Dec 17, 2024
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
What a kind review ~ thank you so much! We hope you'll come and stay with us again, and soon!
~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR
5.0
the best of the keys
It was fantastic. Stay easy to get the keys. They helped with transportation to entertainment. The house was incredible. Plenty of space for the family and friends with a bonus Jacuzzi so close to the beach right in the heart of all of the phone. they Amazing sunset beautiful place can’t wait to come bacit was amazing stay easy to get the keys they helped with transportation to entertainment. The house was incredible. Plenty of space for the family and friends with a bonus Jacuzzi so close to the beach right in the heart of all of the fun amazing sunsets beautiful place can’t wait to come back. k.
Submitted by Panorama City CA on Aug 25, 2023
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We can't wait for you to come back either ~ we are happy to hear you had a great time!
~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR
5.0
great alternative to a hotel
We rented both units (top and bottom) and had a relaxing stay. Easy access to everything we wanted to do. Area was quiet and felt safe during our stay. Parking worked for our two vehicles (small and medium SUVs) but think larger vehicles would struggle. Property management was very clear about parking and shared options for larger vehicles. We would certainly return.
Submitted by Lakewood Rch FL on Jul 26, 2023
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We certainly hope you will return and are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Poinciana Pair-a-dise!
You are right that parking is tight and bigger cars are tough in little lanes.
Let us know when you plan to come back!
~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR
5.0
poinciana paradise perfection!
This was our second stay at Poinciana Paradise. It's perfectly located in a quiet alley just 2.5 blocks from Duval. On-site parking is a bonus. The deck on the back of the house has been updated since our last stay and is a lovely place to sit and enjoy the beautiful Key West weather. The property management company is extremely helpful and pleasant to work with. We traveled with another couple, so this property could not have been more perfect for us; we each had our own separate spaces but could sit together on the deck and enjoy drinks or a meal. It's just a great place to stay!
Submitted by Glenwood IA on Dec 13, 2020
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Lori, we are so happy you were once again pleased with Poinciana Paradise and our company. It is a llittle piece of Key West paradise with parking! We look forward to seeing you again soon, Stay well!!
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
great location, cute place
We rented both flats for a couple nights with my family & parents. The location was perfect for us—far enough from Duval St. that we could sleep at night, but close enough to walk everywhere. It's on a tiny, quiet street too, so no traffic.
My only complaint is that the beds were pretty soft & pillows massive, so I didn't sleep terribly well.
Tip if you stay here: if you're planning on using the hot tub later, turn the heat up as soon as you get there, as it takes a while to go from where it was set @ 93 to a proper 104.
Submitted by Mercer Island WA on Apr 26, 2018
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thank you for the feedback, Brad. We are very sorry you did not sleep great during your stay there. For future notice, we can add or remove mattress pads as well as provide different types of pillows for our guests. Keeping on hot tub lid on while heating the hot tub should reduce the length of time to get up to 104!