Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

5.0

the great escape!

We decided to celebrate my son's 21st birthday in Key West and we couldn't have found a better place to stay the Potter's Cottage. Great experience, clean and a great location, we highly recommend you stay here when you are in Key West, next time.

Submitted by Saint Petersburg FL on Aug 14, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your great review of Potter's Cottage. We agree it's a fabulous cottage! We hope you're planning your next visit with us~ The Team at HKWVR

5.0

potter’s cottage

Great time! House was clean and well stocked with all our needs and close walking distance to everything. Can’t wait to come stay again!

Submitted by Seminole FL on Jul 29, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are anxiously awaiting your next visit! Potter's Cottage is here waiting for you! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

5.0

cocktail pool is a real treat

We loved our stay at Potter's Cottage. We were a party of four staying in the middle of July, and the highlight for us was gathering in and around the cocktail after sunset to unwind and relax. Perfect.

Submitted by Asheville NC on Jul 29, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice thing to envision! We hope you'll come soon and do it again. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

5.0

june 14 to 20 trip

The location and cleanliness was fantastic

Submitted by Marietta GA on Jun 25, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We think you're fantastic for taking the time to review us so kindly! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

5.0

perfect get away

The whole process from reservation to check out was flawless. The home was exactly what we were looking for and more. Close enough to walk to restaurants and museums, close to the Duval Loop bus route which made getting around town a breeze. The home was tastefully decorated and the pool and front porch were added bonuses.

Submitted by Davenport FL on May 31, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love your description of your stay at Potter's Cottage and thank you for taking the time to review us! We hope we'll see you again in the future. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

5.0

great trip!

Loved loved loved Potters Cottage. It was the perfect place for our trip and accommodated our family of 5 perfectly.

Submitted by Elizabeth PA on May 17, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice review of Potter's Cottage! Thank you, and we hope we'll see the whole family again! ~ The Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

5.0

loved potter's cottage

This cottage was lovely. Perfectly decorated. Cozy yet spacious enough. We appreciated how very clean it was, too. It was a great location. One block off the craziness, so we could easily walk to Mallory square and all the bars & restaurants. Perfect setting! We rented a golf cart for a few days to get groceries and travel all around the island, but we were fine just walking for the remainder of our trip. The pool was the best! We spent our days enjoying that and the back yard, and enjoyed late-night people watching from the front porch as they strolled by at the end of the night. Would definitely stay here again and recommend it!

Submitted by Charlevoix MI on May 04, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a nice review of Potter's Cottage, thank you! We hope you'll come and stay with us again, and soon. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

5.0

amazing little cottage

Great location the house was clean and very inviting.

Submitted by Hudsonville MI on Apr 10, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

That sounds like the perfect vacation rental to us! Thank you for taking the time to review us so kindly. ~ The Team @ HKWVR

5.0

fabulous place to stay!!

The house was exactly as described and so convenient to everything Key West. The owner was so proactive about suggestions for restaurants and entertainment.

Submitted by Leland NC on Mar 09, 2025

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of Potter's Cottage. We hope you'll return again and enjoy more Key West suggestions! ~ The Team @ HKWVR

5.0

perfect kw stay

Potter’s cottage is the perfect location if you want to experience all kinds of Key West attractions. Everything is walkable from this spot and it was also quiet at night for sleeping. The house was well equipped, clean and provided plenty of space for four adults. We enjoyed the backyard every day of our stay from coffee and breakfast in the morning to afternoon pool time and then late night card playing with cocktails. We had a great time!!

Submitted by Indianapolis IN on Dec 17, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of Potter's Cottage! For everyone who doesn't know, you can see the exact location of the home/s under the calendar/s so you can see how close it is. We are ready for you to come back and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

5.0

potters cottage

Charming cottage-KW vibes! Cottage is in a great location-walkable to Southernmost, action on Duval, great restaurants and Higgs Beach.

A quiet respite as well if you choose. Indoor decor was comfortable and well maintained-especially loved the cozy side library space. The pool was the perfect size with lots of sunny areas and cozy shaded seating-ceiling fans were a huge plus.

Communication from management company throughout the booking and stay was fantastic. We will be back!

Submitted by Newport KY on Nov 07, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are already looking forward to seeing you again ~ you now have a vacation home here in Key West with us! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

5.0

perfect paradise

We couldn't of selected a better rental to stay in. Everything was perfect from location, description of the rental, attention to detail, customer service! I would recommend this location to friends and family! Keep the good work up!

Submitted by Middle Grove NY on Sep 19, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you, Keith, for taking the time to review your stay at Potter's Cottage! We strive for guest satisfaction, attention to detail, and communication- and we are so glad you noticed! We hope to see you again soon in sunny Key West~ Lori and the HKWVR Team

5.0

great accommodation

It was excellent. Cottage was charming.

Submitted by bloomington IN on Jun 18, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We find you charming as well! Thank you for taking the time to review us so nicely. ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

5.0

great lodging pick

This house was perfect for my girls trip for 3. It was nicely decorated, very clean and provided everything we needed. The pool area was a must for an afternoon break, especially since we visited during record high temperatures. Restaurants and shopping was close by so we could walk most places, which we also appreciated. Absolutely perfect in all respects, no negatives. Management company was accessible if needed.

Submitted by Franklin OH on May 21, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It sounds like the perfect Girls' Trip and we hope you'll come again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

5.0

a charming cottage in old town key west

We had a great stay at Potters Cottage! The house is well appointed and wonderfully maintained. It was perfect for our family of 4. There are 2 beds plus three sitting areas with couches (1 pulls out). The furniture inside and out was comfortable! The kitchen had everything we needed to make and serve Easter dinner- we were thrilled. The pool was literally a step away and was a great place to relax and refresh at any time. The washer and dryer were large and easy to use. Two minor drawbacks- the house does not come with parking or a residential permit. We were never able to grab the spot in front of the house. The upstairs bedroom area is accessible by a narrow, step staircase which may be challenging for some travelers. The rental company, Historic Key West Vacation Rentals, was great to work with. We look forward to returning!

Submitted by Moorestown NJ on Apr 05, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Potter's Cottage ~ and thank you for pointing out that the stairs may be steep for some (a common trait of Historic homes). We are already looking forward to your next visit! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

5.0

great time

Lovely home for my wife and me. Close to Duval.

Submitted by North Plainfield NJ on Mar 26, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you Vincent, for your kind words! Potter's Cottage is a great property in a perfect location. We hope you will come back and see us again soon in sunny Key West! Lori and the Team at HKWVR

5.0

perfect stay!!

Absolutely loved this perfectly located, nicely appointed house! So many nice places to sit and enjoy - both indoors and outdoors. Three of us stayed but it would have been comfortable with more people. Will definitely stay here again!!!!

Submitted by New Jersey NJ on Mar 24, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your great review of Potter's Cottage! We love that you enjoyed your time here in Key West and can't wait to see you again soon! Lori @ HKWVR

5.0

perfect place

Clean and cared for house. Great location close to restaurants and bars but still quiet. Stocked with everything you need for a vacation. Communication was simply and very helpful.

Submitted by Arlington MA on Feb 25, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your great review of Potter's Cottage! We agree that the location is perfect and we try to supply all you may need. Come back and see us again soon~ Lori and the Team @ HKWVR

5.0

great stay in a cozy cottage

The cottage was great and the location very walkable. Loved both the front and back porches and having bathrooms on both floors. It was a homey stay, much better than hotel rooms! We loved it!

Submitted by Fairfax VA on Feb 20, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the nice review! Please come and stay with us again! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

5.0

great location, cute house!

Location and amenities were just like the pictures and description. My husband and I enjoyed staying at the cottage for an anniversary trip. Would definitely return for another get away!

Submitted by Forest Park IL on Jan 04, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you Rachelle for your kind review of Potter's Cottage. It's a great home and location. Come and see us again in sunny Key West! ~Lori and the Team at HKWVR

5.0

loved this cozy cottage

Potter's Cottage was in a great location and was perfect for our 5 day New Year's vacation. It was very clean, well-appointed and had everything we needed. We enjoyed the pool too! We liked that it was just a block off the quieter end of Duval, and we easily walked or biked to everything we wanted to do. The room with the pullout couch had doors for privacy and was just big enough for the bed unfolded, but my 5'11" son said it was very comfortable, and he was happy in there. One thing to note is the steps to the upstairs bedroom are steep, so this is not a cottage for someone who has issues with stairs.
We really appreciated the help of the wonderful staff at HKWVR planning our first trip to Key West!

Submitted by Washington DC on Jan 02, 2024

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Happy New Year! Thank you for taking the time to review Potter's Cottage so kindly. We are looking forward to your next visit ~ you always have a vacation home with us! ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

5.0

wonderful stay!

We loved our cottage, and it was close to everything. The cottage was very clean and had everything we needed. We loved sitting on the front porch and watching the people walk by. We would stay here again!

Submitted by Centennial CO on Dec 18, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

And Potter's Cottage is always yours when you're ready to come back and make some more memories! We love seeing happy, familiar faces! Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

5.0

great place to stay !

This house was perfect for my wife and I to celebrate our 9th wedding anniversary. We would love to go back this winter for another stay.

Submitted by Valparaiso IN on Aug 08, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

It sounds like you need to come and stay with us for all the anniversaries! We hope to see you again this winter. ~ Jennifer @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

5.0

perfect in every way

HKWVR did a fabulous job in preparing for our arrival and our departure.
The property could not be any better. The location is fabulous and the amenities at the home are everything that you need to feel right at home.

Submitted by Winter Park FL on Jul 11, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Wow! What a nice review of Potter's Cottage, and we thank you for taking the time to do so. Please come and stay again ~ you will always have a vacation home with us! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

5.0

perfect

This house was amazing for my family. Perfect location just a block off Duval Street (on the quieter end) a block from the lighthouse and Hemingway house. The pool was a added bonus. We would definitely come back. Everyone we dealt with at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals was amazing. Thank you for a great trip!

Submitted by Abington PA on May 21, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your kind review! We love to hear about amazing stays and hope you can come back soon! Lori and the HKWVR Team

5.0

clean, comfortable.little cottage with a pool

It was easy & everything went smoothly. The home was very lovely and cute. Small but relaxing outside area with a small soaking pool. We had everything we needed. Downstairs bathroom nlis huge with large shower. Upstairs bathroom is small, shower requires people not to be very tall, fyi. We had 7 palmetto bugs on night one in the upstairs bathroom, but rental company sent someone to handle the next day and that got rid of them. They arranged bikes to be delivered which was great. It's a great location just a block and half from Hemingway House. Whitehead is a busy street but you wouldn't know itnfrom inside the cottage.. its well insulated. We had a lovely time.

Submitted by Farmington CT on May 17, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your honest review of Potter's Cottage! Life on an island:) We are sorry about your unexpected visitors and glad we were able to help. We are happy that you enjoyed your stay and hope to see you again soon. Lori and the HKWVR Team

5.0

great cottage, great location

Perfect space for a five-night family stay. Walking distance of all major attractions on the island. Rental company was easy to work with. Cocktail pool was a plus. Would note that the stairs to the upstairs area were a little steep but they are sturdy and safe - just may impact bedroom choice during your stay. Cottage is bright and welcoming. Would definitely recommend

Submitted by Buffalo NY on Apr 14, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind and honest review of Potter's Cottage ~ homes built 100 years ago around Key West can definitely have steeper stairs, but that's part of their charm, as I'm sure you saw! Come and stay with us again, any time! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

5.0

perfect location, home

My wife and I had a wonderful stay at Potter's Cottage. Perfect locations steps from Duval but also quiet. Well kept up and the service from the rental company was excellent.

Submitted by Nashville TN on Feb 01, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We thank you kindly for the nice words about us and Potter's Cottage ~ we think you're excellent, too. Come and stay with us again, anytime! ~ Jennifer @ HKWVR

5.0

amazing trip!

My family and I decided to getaway for a quick trip and we couldn't have picked a better place. What a wonderful home and PERFECT location. We were able to walk with my kids to stores, restaurants and activities. The pool and patio area was perfect to relax and enjoy the outdoors. The house was adorably decorated and VERY CLEAN! Thank you and we will be back soon!

Submitted on Jan 09, 2023

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you so much for the kind review! We are so happy you and your family enjoyed your time on Key West and at Potter's Cottage. Please come back and stay with us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

5.0

great spot

Potters cottage was a great spot for our 2 couples. Location was great- close enough for all of the fun, but still removed enough to relax at home with the perfect pool for just cooling off.

Submitted by Lake Orion MI on Nov 07, 2022

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

You're right! Potter's is a great home for 2 couples! It's so fun to be in a historic Key West home with all the amenities. Come and stay with us again ~ we love seeing happy, familiar faces. ~ Jennifer @ HKWVR

5.0

just what we needed.

A buddy and I planned a trip to celebrate our wives’ 50th birthday. We rented Potters Cottage from HKWVR for our stay in Key West. Best move we could have made. Both wives were so happy and the husbands are calling this a Big Win. To a person, everyone that we interacted with at Historic Key West was so friendly and helpful, and most importantly, they joined our mission to make sure the ladies had a great time. The concierge services were top notch and helped with reservations and advice. 10 out of 10.

Submitted by Indianapolis IN on Nov 04, 2022

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy you had a Big Win weekend with and for the wives! That's what we like to hear and what we're all about. Come and stay with us again for another Big Win. :) ~ Jennifer @ HKWVR

5.0

key west 2022

Overall it was great. Fantastic house in a great location - close enough to everything but far enough to be quiet. Beautifully decorated and very comfortable.

The pool needed a good vacuum but it was the fall so leaves are to be expected. But the bottom was not as clean as it could be. Just needed a vacuum and a sweep of the pool deck

Submitted by Parkton MD on Oct 14, 2022

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the kind review of Potter's ~ and yes, we've had a little extra schmutz around Key West after the hurricane, but we're also lucky we didn't get it worse! Next time call us and we'll make sure we send someone right over to take care of it! But we can't wait to see you again. ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

5.0

cutest little cottage

Great location near shops, restaurants, and nightlife. The Duval loop stop right next to the cottage makes destinations out of walking distance easily accessible. The house itself had everything we needed and the pool was an amazing treat after a full day out and about. The two bedrooms and a small side room was plenty of room for my family of 5. We made great memories and we hope to be back soon!

Submitted by Keithville LA on Oct 13, 2022

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love being a part of good family memories ~ that's what we're all about! We can't wait to see you again, and hopefully soon! ~ Jennifer @ HKWVR

5.0

great location! love the pool!!

We loved Potter's Cottage. Great location! We biked or walked everywhere. It was very hot in July and the pool was the perfect way to cool off. Plenty of space for 2 couples. We will be back!

Submitted by Roswell GA on Jul 26, 2022

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Yay! We are so looking forward to your return. We really like seeing happy, familiar faces come through our door. Make it soon, please! ~ Jennifer @ HKWVR

5.0

great place!

Our stay was really good. The place was amazing and we really enjoyed spending time by the pool. You cannot beat its location either. The staff who is managing the property was extremely helpful, kind and professional.

Submitted by Chicago IL on Jul 13, 2022

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

George, We are very happy you were pleased with your stay and with our company.Relaxing by the pool is a great way to wind down after a day of activities & it is a perfect spot! Please visit our wonderful little island again when you can. Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

perfect location in key west

This beautiful cottage home has everything you need and then some. My sister and I were thrilled with the location as there were many restaurants, shops activities right around the corner. There is even a cute little gallery next door. We enjoyed the beautiful backyard relaxing in the pool and spent a good amount of time on the porch “people watching”. There is also a beautiful view of the lighthouse that never gets old. The location was so wonderful that we didn’t even use our car during our stay. The property managers were fantastic & beyond helpful. We can’t wait to book this wonderful property again. Thank you for sharing your beautiful home with us. We had a great time in Key West!!!

Submitted by Portland OR on Jun 30, 2022

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Joyce, thank you for the review. We are so happy you were pleased with the Cottage. The pool & patio is a great little spot to relax after a day of adventures! Key West awaits your return to enjoy more island fun! Cindy & the Historic Key West Vacation Rental team

5.0

great location and very clean!

This house was emasculate and very well maintained. We had everything we needed and within walking distance to Duval. We will definitely be back!

Submitted by Conroe TX on Jun 26, 2022

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We're happy you enjoyed your time at Potter's Cottage. We love a great historic home! Come and see us again, and soon. ~ Jennifer @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

5.0

great vacation!

This is the second time I've rented Potter's Cottage for our Key West vacation. The house is very cute and comfortable with everything we needed. It's within walking distance of many attractions (Hemingway House, Lighthouse, and Southernmost Point) and great restaurants. This year, we spent more time sitting on the front porch watching passersby than we spent in the pool (...not that the pool wasn't great, though.)

The staff was always very helpful and quick to respond to all my questions.

I can't wait to come back!

Submitted by Austin TX on Apr 14, 2022

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We can't wait to see you again! So happy you enjoyed porch time (and yes, the pool is great!)! We're looking forward to your next visit. We're all here for you. ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

5.0

location location location!

Potters cottage is a great place to stay just a few blocks from Duval and some great restaurants like Moondog and Ramshead Siuthernmost. It’s quite comfortable for two couples who want to relax and enjoy the quiet of being off Duval Street while being minutes from all the activity. The staff at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals are the best for being friendly, helpful and willing to assist with any needs to make your stay memorable.

Submitted by Kernersville NC on Jan 28, 2022

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for your review Elizabeth! We are so happy that you enjoyed Potter's Cottage and are always happy to help make your stay perfect! We hope to see you again soon! Lori and the HKWVR Team

5.0

perfect cottage and location

We are so pleased with our choosing of Potters cottage with Historic Key West Vacation Rentals. It was a last minute and quick trip down from GA but we will absolutely be back to Potters Cottage. The location is perfect and our 2 girls had a blast in the pool. It’s small but just right for lounging. The front porch is great for a cup of coffee or glass of wine. The house had everything needed for cooking and serving. If you forget something small, there is a circle K only 2 min walk that has most things. We rented a golf cart from the company across from the circle k and it was perfect to cruise around on. Excited to go back!

Submitted by Saint Simons Island GA on Dec 26, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We can't wait for you to get back, either! And Potter's is a perfect blend of historic Key West and modern everything-you-need. :) Thanks for the helpful hints as well! ~Jennifer & Team HKWVR

5.0

perfect!!

From check in to check out it was a great experience. House is a perfect location to enjoy Key West!

Submitted by Jupiter FL on Dec 11, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Erik thank you very much for your review. It is a beautiful property and the patio/pool area is a nice retreat. We hope you can come back to our unique little island again for more fun in the sun! Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

potter's cottage 2 thumbs up!

Great location! Comfortable, clean, updated and awesome little cottage! Loved everything about it!

Submitted by Long Beach MS on Nov 18, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so thrilled you enjoyed our sweet Potter's Cottage! Come and see us again ~ we love happy guests! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

5.0

exceeded expectations!

Our girls trip to Key West was fabulous. Potter's Cottage was amazing. It was just perfect. We enjoyed lounging by the pool, the amazing location and the homey feel. When the AC was a little slow to cool the cottage, a technician was sent over immediately and the problem was resolved. Super friendly team! We will definitely be back!

Submitted by Selbyville DE on Nov 17, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so happy we met and exceeded your expectations ~ that is *always* our goal!! Please come and see us again, with or without The Girlfriends ~ although it's way more fun with The Girlfriends! ~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR

5.0

great little house for a fun get away!

We truly enjoyed our stay at Porters Cottage! From the booking, to checking in, to checking out; all was smooth. The house is in a great location and provided a fun spot to hang out. The pool is perfect for relaxing and enjoying a cool drink! Would definitely stay her again!

Submitted by Linticum MD on Oct 12, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Melissa, thank you for reviewing Potters Cottage. We are glad you enjoyed your stay here. It is a sweet property and in a perfect spot! Please come back again for more Key West adventures. Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

perfect stay at historic potter’s cottage

Just as described in their description - cozy yet roomy enough. Perfect for our honeymoon. Love the pool right out the door. Close to the Lighthouse and Hemingway’s home.

Submitted by Austin TX on Oct 03, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Well, congratulations on your wedding! We hope you know that you have an anniversary home to come and visit every year! ;) So glad you enjoyed your time ~ and many, many years of happiness to you both. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

5.0

great time in key west

Had a terrific stay! This place was awesome! Clean, bright, and in a perfect location!

Submitted by Watertown CT on Sep 21, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love our little Potter's Cottage and are so happy you do as well (or is 'love' too soon of a word...? :D ) Hope you're making plans to come and see us again, and soon. ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

5.0

perfect!

I rented this adorable little cottage for myself and 3 of my best friends to celebrate our 50th birthdays this year. The cottage is in a perfect location - blocks from Southernmost Point and only 1 block over from Duval Street. It has everything you might need. It was wonderful to come home from a hot day of walking and be able to go straight to the little pool to cool off and have some cocktails and rest before heading out again. Would definitely stay here again!

Submitted by Boynton Beach FL on Aug 04, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

What a perfect place to celebrate 50s!! We hope you'll come for every birthday between now and 60! ;) ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

5.0

great time!

Potter’s Cottage was perfect for my trip with a friend. It’s in a great location - one block off of Duval but still quiet enough for peaceful lounging on the deck and quiet time for sleeping. House was exactly as expected - clean, no maintenance issues and had everything we needed for our stay (beach towels, coffee maker, etc). The staff was amazing - from booking, to getting bikes coordinated and delivered, to checking out. We are already planning a trip next year and plan on using this team again. Thank you!!!

Submitted by Chardon OH on Jul 19, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are so excited you had a great time ~ that is truly our goal, always! And you have your very own vacation home with us in Key West! We'll take care of everything ~ you just show up and have a great time. :) ~ Jennifer & Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

5.0

a wonderful oasis

Our family of four had a great time staying at Potter's Cottage. The kids especially enjoyed the pool as a way to unwind after coming back from outings. Centrally located with plenty of good restaurant options in walking distance.

Submitted by McLean VA on Jun 19, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We love our Potter's Cottage and we are glad you enjoyed it as well! You now have your very own vacation home ~ come anytime! :) ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

5.0

wonderful

this is a wonderful cottage, sparkling clean and beautifully decorated. it is so quiet, you would never know that you are 1 block off of Duvall street. the Management was friendly and helpful. we loved it!

Submitted by South Lake Tahoe CA on Jun 01, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Don't you just love Potter's?? It definitely has a loyal following. People like to think of it as their personal vacation home when they come here. ;) Come and stay at your vacation home again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

5.0

as described.. kinda!!

House was as described. Pictures definitely make it look alot bigger. Great location. No need to rent a car, as you can walk to everything. Outside deck by the pool could have been cleaner. Daily pooping iguanas and pigeons made a mess that we needed to hose off daily. All the rooms were as described. A/C upstairs sounds like a jet plane when on. Very noisy. Overall, would stay here again and would recommend to anyone to stay.

Submitted by Colonia NJ on May 29, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We're happy you had a nice time at Potter's ~ and yes, while we clean up between renters, the iguanas leave their guana. ;) Come and see us again, and soon! ~ Jennifer & the Team @ HKWVR

5.0

great rental

We rented the cottage for 3 days in early May. We loved the place and will likely return with our children in a year. It was only two of us there for our anniversary trip, but the house would be great for two couples or a family of 4-6.

Kitchen is reasonably well appointed, and the grill is new and performed well. Furnishings and bedroom were all good. Linens of good quality. Outdoor shower was lovely and the plunge pool was great—small but deep. The backyard got great sun during the day, but the trees and lanai provide good shade if you don’t want to bake. We have been in key west many times and we always stay on Duval. I was very surprised by how quiet the backyard was at night.

Lastly, the management company was very easy to work with. Fantastic service from them.

Submitted by Dallas TX on May 16, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We're so happy to hear we were 'fantastic' ~ we were just saying the same thing about you! :) Please come and stay with us again. Bring the kids to Potter's or check out some of our other homes. You now always have a vacation home in Key West with us! ~ Jennifer & the Team at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

5.0

loved our stay

Outstanding

Submitted by Springville UT on May 13, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Greg, we appreciate your review of Potters Cottage and hope you enjoyed your time here and relaxed by the pool. Come back soon for more Key West adventures! Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

great place to stay

Rental was clean and very cute. Close to the action on Duval St but on a quiet side street.

Submitted by Slinger WI on May 10, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We're so happy you had what sounds like a nice time! Come and see us again, and soon, please. :) ~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR

5.0

spring break spectacular!!

Enjoyed Potters cottage very much. Central location easy to walk to majority of landmarks on the island. We were a party of five and the layout of the cottage works great did not feel cramped at all. Both the front porch and the back deck with the pool were utilized every day. Again wonderful stay, thanks for the memories!

Submitted by Grand Haven MI on Apr 12, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Gena, we are so happy you were pleased with Potters Cottage. The location and the pool are wonderful! Come back to Key West whenever you can. We miss you already! Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

wonderful stay in key west

Great experience, perfect location, and top notch management company!

Submitted by LOUISVILLE KY on Mar 29, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Sean, thank you so much for reviewing Potters Cottage and our company. It is a great cottage! We are pleased you had a good experience and hope you can come back again for more Key West fun! Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

perfect place to stay in key west

The home is beautifully decorated inside and out with its own little oasis of a quaint backyard area with a pool. Located one block off of Duval, gives you the perfect location to get to where you want to be on the island. Will definitely stay here again!

Submitted by Troup TX on Jan 14, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Bobbi, Thank you very much for your review of Potters Cottage. It make us happy that you were pleased. Come back soon and enjoy the wonderful weather and vibe of Key West! Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

potter's cottage stay over new years

Excellent location, clean, well maintained.

Submitted by Myrtle Beach SC on Jan 05, 2021

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Jeff, thank you for your review of Potters Cottage. It is a block off of Duval and close to most everything. We hope you enjoyed your time here and will come back again! Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

great little house

This was a great house. Had everything we needed and more. Pool was very comforting and help me work out back issues after a long flight. Description and puctures were as advertised. Only thing i would point out is the stairs to second floor were very steep. This place is also right off main road into key west US1. Great location to the best areas of key west without being in the crowded noisy areas. It was nice to have our own place away from COVID possibilities.

Submitted by Willaimsburg VA on Dec 18, 2020

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Richard, thank you for your review of Potters Cottage. With it being a Historic property we cannot change the stairs.However we are so happy you were pleased overall. Come back again when you can and stay well! Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

quaint, comfortable, clean and perfect location

The rental office was superb! Great communication before, during and after our stay. Clean, had everything you could need. Walking distance to most everything but not the noise. Ceiling fans on the covered patio were perfect to keep cool and still sit when it was raining.

Submitted by West Palm Beach FL on Oct 05, 2020

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Susan, we are very pleased you were happy with your stay at Potters Cottage and with us. Please come back again when you can ! Warm Regards, Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

pleasant quaint experience

What an adorable experience. We loved the property! The location is central to everything in Key West. The house is well maintained and SO charming.

Submitted by Miramar FL on Jun 19, 2020

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Jeannie, Potters Cottage is a charming property and we appreciate your is a nice retreat and a great place to relax. Key West is still a great place to visit even with the COVID restrictions.. We are happy you had a great time and hope you can come again without wearing the masks! But safety is the main thing and fun can still be had. You are proof of that! Cindy & the HKWVR team

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Jeannie, Potters Cottage is a charming property and we appreciate your is a nice retreat and a great place to relax. Key West is still a great place to visit .We are happy you had a great time and hope you can come again without wearing the masks! But safety is the main thing and fun can still be had. You are proof of that! Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

lovely stay!

We rented this cottage over NYE with another couple. It is adorable and we really enjoyed our stay. The location is great - just a block off Duval. It was very quiet. The pool was great. Two bedroom and two bathrooms. The upstairs is essentially a loft with a bedroom, sitting area and bathroom. The upstairs bathroom is quite small but it worked for us. The 1st floor bathroom is huge. We will definitely consider returning. Just an FYI - the stairs to the loft are a bit steep so they need to be navigated with care.

Submitted by Severna Park MD on Jan 30, 2020

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Susan, we appreciate your review of Potters Cottage. It is an older home and we are sorry the stairs presented a problem. We will make sure other guests are aware they are steep. Hopefully you rang in the New Year with GUSTO and we wil see you next year! Warm Regards, CIndy & the HKWVR team

5.0

best rental agency evaaaah

We have been coming to Key West for years using different rental agencies and private rentals I have to say Historic Keywest Vacation Rentals is my favorite vacation rental agency there. They responded to a tv issue immediately. They called the next day to be sure everything was perfect. They really do care about their renters satisfaction.

Submitted by Orange MA on Nov 18, 2019

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Pamela, thank you for your kind review of Potters Cottage and us! We appreciate you and are happy you are pleased with our service. We look forward to seeing you again and hope you have a Joyous Holiday Season. Warm Regards, Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

great little "home away from home!"

Potter's Cottage was very clean and well maintained, and exactly as advertised. The kitchen and bathrooms had everything you needed for your stay and the pool, with both shaded and sunny seating areas was perfect! We spent a lot of time in this outdoor area, swimming, lounging, snacking and even grilling our own seafood dinner. Communication with the property management company was easy and response time was very quick. We would definitely stay here again!

Submitted by Centerville OH on Nov 06, 2019

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Cambra, thank you for taking the time to review Potters Cottage. We are pleased you had an enjoyable time here in Key West. Please come back and visit our Island again soon! Warm Regards, Cindy & the HKWVR team

5.0

beautiful cottage & relaxing pool

The cottage is wonderful. My husband and I stayed her for a week while our children were at sea camp. Everything was clean and neat. The interior is update and well done. We were there in early August so we used the pool every day. The location is perfect because it is quiet yet close to all the shops and restaurants and out of the super "touristy" loud bar, bad food scene. I was a little frustrated with the management company on a couple of things but the staff was very helpful and professional. I did not like the deposit process from Key west. I thought $3,000 was excessive and told them I thought that was high and they said they could take a $60 non-refundable fee in lieu of charging my card. I find this just another charge. Also they did not meet us at the unit and we had to drop the key off at their office 10 blocks away. This is very inconvenient when you have luggage as there is as parking is difficult to find so you have the walk. I also think the service fee VRBO now implements since under new management is excessive.

Submitted by Golden CO on Aug 28, 2019

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Hi Shane! Thank you for your great review of Potter's Cottage. We strive to make your vacation perfect, and hope we did everything we could to make it so. We'll definitely take into consideration all that you mentioned. Potter's Cottage is located close to so many Key West fun happenings. How great though to go back home to a private pool. We look forward to your next adventure to our island. Warmest regards, Mary Ann and the HKWVR team

5.0

potter’s cottage

A wonderful time was had in Key West recently. Potter’s Cottage was the perfect choice for two couples. It is a lovely, well appointed property. We couldn’t have survived the July heat without the plunge pool. It was a welcome treat to come to after all of our walking and site seeing. Historic Key West Vacation Rental staff were so helpful and courteous. My only small “grumble” was having to use an offsite luggage storage service for our last day. It would have been much more convenient to leave it at the rental office. I would definitely recommend Potter’s Cottage to anyone visiting Key West.

Submitted by Columbus GA on Aug 24, 2019

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thanks, Cathy, for your 5 star review! We're so happy you found Potter's Cottage perfect and lovely for your stay with us. The pool is a plus any time of year. We are more than happy to store luggage at our office, so please let us know on your next trip to Key West so we can assist you with that. We want your time with us to be hassle free, leaving you time for more fun. We're looking forward to your next visit! Warmest regards, Mary Ann & the HKWVR team

5.0

surprise bday trip for the wife

The house was perfect, from the location, to the relaxing back yard with dipping pool and how quiet it was at night even being one block from Duval. Told my wife she can book this place for the surprise bday get away she plans for me.

Submitted by Yardley PA on Aug 08, 2019

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you Mr. Schafer so glad Mrs. Schaefer with surprised and you both enjoyed Potters Cottage - your vacation home in KW. Look forward to seeing you both on your birthday - Cathi & HKWVR Team

5.0

loved the place

We loved the place very clean.

Submitted by Morrison IL on Apr 07, 2019

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Dear Dave, We are so glad you enjoyed our Potters Cottage! Come back soon! Warm Regards, Yoli and the HKWVR Team

5.0

perfect location

Our family had a great time in Florida, but having a home with a grill to cook outside and pool to relax by was like we had a home there.

Submitted by Lincoln NE on Feb 19, 2019

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Dear Lance, We couldn't be happier that you felt like at home in our cute Potter's Cottage-- please come back soon! Warm Regards, HKWVR Team

5.0

a wonderful stay at potter'

We absolutely LOVED Potter's Cottage. The perfect location and yet still so quiet and relaxing. We lounged by the pool and enjoyed some much needed R&R. When we wanted to take in the sights, everything was a quick walk over to Duval Street. The cottage itself is perfectly appointed with everything you could need. Each room was perfectly decorated and had such a warm and homey feel. We didn't want to leave. Thanks for having us! We can't wait to come back.

Submitted by Virginia Beach VA on Dec 17, 2018

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for staying with us! Brenda and the HKWVR team

5.0

great stay

Great all around - from check in - to check out. This is our second year staying at a home managed by Historic Key West Rentals - and each time the homes have been super clean and nice.

Submitted by Tampa FL on Nov 07, 2018

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you!!! We love our repeat guests and we love how great your experience was all around! We'll look forward to your next visit!!! Brenda and the HKWVR team

5.0

best little house

We spent the weekend here for our friends birthday and this 2 bed / 2 bath home was perfect. Very clean. Well kept. Smack dab in the middle of old town. Walking distance to everything. It was end of July and very hot so coming back from being out and jumping into the dipping pool was ideal. Highly recommend this place to anyone looking for something quiet and cozy. Also, the property management company was very accommodating and thorough.

Submitted by Lauderdale By The Sea FL on Sep 26, 2018

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Hi Katherine! Thanks so much for your review. We're happy you stayed with us! We look forward to you staying with us in the future again : ) Gabriela and the HKWVR team

5.0

perfect location, cute house!

The house is located in a great location, is very clean and perfect for 4 or 5 people. The shower upstairs is a bit small, but everything else was absolutely perfect! The pool is a great size for cooling off and taking a quick dip. The rental company was great to work with as well!

Submitted by Scottsdale AZ on Sep 10, 2018

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for this review Tawnya. So glad you all had a good time at charming Potter's cottage. We sure hope to see you next time you visit us in Key West! Gabriela and the HKWVR team

5.0

perfect place!

The cottage was immaculate and well-stocked with needed items (Even sunscreen!). The location was perfect, just a block from the Hemingway House and near Duvall Street and Mallory Square (a bit of a walk to Mallory square, but not bad).

Submitted by St. Ann MO on Jul 02, 2018

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for staying with us, Stephanie! Come back and and see us! -The Historic KW Staff

5.0

loved potters cottage

We were here for a wedding and I shared the home with others in the wedding party. The size, location, and needs were met perfectly for what we needed!

Submitted by Lockport IL on Jun 21, 2018

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us at Potter's Cottage! Thank you for the valuable feedback, we hope you come back again! - The HKWVR Staff

5.0

the perfect spot!

Potter's cottage was the perfect property for our family. It was spotless and in a great location to walk to most of the sights in Key West.

Submitted by San Antonio TX on Jun 10, 2018

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Mr. Fleming, Thank you very much for your review. We are very happy to hear you were very pleased with our lovely Potter's cottage. We look forward to seeing you and your family on your next visit to Key West! Gabriela

5.0

key west wedding weekend

We were 5 adults traveling to Key West for a weekend wedding and Potters Cottage was great for our stay. One single adult slept on the (never really comfortable but manageable) pull out sofa in the den and the other two couples each had a bedroom. The beds were very comfortable. The cottage was spotless and well equipped!! Very nice decor and again so clean!! Great location to everything. We would stay there again.

Submitted by Hilton Head Island SC on Apr 24, 2018

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thanks and what a pleasure to have you join us. If ever vacationing in Key West please look us up. We would love to have you back!

5.0

paradise relaxing

Wonderful; did not want to leave

Submitted by Williamsville NY on Mar 19, 2018

5.0

potter's cottage

Perfect house for our family of 6. Everything worked for us, Great location one block off Duval. We will be back!

Submitted by Collegeville PA on Mar 03, 2018

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thanks for joining us! Keep us high on the list planing for next year. We appreciate the score across the board and the time spent posting a comment, See you soon...

5.0

great vacation

wonderful home away from home, perfect for the 4 of us, loved the pool area

Submitted by Altoona IA on Feb 27, 2018

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thanks Mr. Ferguson. We appreciate the high score across the board. Please feel free to look us up if ever back to Key West.

5.0

potter’s cottage

The cottage was charming and beautifully decorated. Plenty of room for two couples. It was spotless and very well equipped with a starter supply of paper products and soap etc. The location is perfect and you can walk or ride bikes to everywhere. The backyard is so private and the pool is heated to perfection. Beds great too.
Danny(concierge for Historic Key West Properties) could not have been nicer or more helpful! He and the owners went above and beyond to make sure that we had a great vacation! Highly recommend this place!

Submitted by Boylston MA on Feb 19, 2018

5.0

great week

We had a great week in KW.

Submitted by Windsor Heights Iowa on Jan 14, 2018

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Mr. Knau , A very big thanks goes out to you for joining us again. We are exceptionally excited to see you again next year. Thanks again!

5.0

potters cottage key west

Potters Cottage was the perfect relaxation destination! It was very centrally located to all the attractions in Key West, was clean, and though the pool is very small, we thoroughly enjoyed its peaceful, private setting. Potters Cottage has all of the comforts of home. We will most definitely be going back!

Submitted by Jefferson City MO on Nov 29, 2017

5.0

potters cottage review

3 nights a patters cottage on Witehead st

Submitted by Cary NC on Sep 08, 2017

5.0

my happy place

Potter's Cottage was wonderful! It had everything you could possibly need, even a shy iguana that would peak through the trees every now and then. The pool was a life saver on those hot and humid August days. My only caution is that the stairs to the loft bedroom are quite steep and narrow. I slept up there (the bed was great), but stayed downstairs any other time. The bonus room made a great changing area. My son and I can not wait to return next year!

Submitted by Centerville IN on Aug 16, 2017

5.0

outstanding vacation rental, perfect location

Beautiful home. This is clearly a home the owner cares about, well furnished and decorated, not just cheap furniture and a few posters. The home is beautiful, well furnished and comfortable. Historic Key West Vacation Rentals was a pleasure to deal with, responding quickly to any questions, check-in and check out was quick and helpful. House was as described and better. House can easily and comfortably sleep 6. Kitchen is a good, workable size. Downstairs bathroom shower is huge, upstairs shower is on the small side but fine. Smart TV with cable (we appreciated being able to log in to our Netflix acct when we wanted to watch a particular movie) in the living room, cable tv in each bedroom. Pool and patio are the gems. Large plunge pool, covered and uncovered patio areas with overhead fans (we're from the NW, not used to the humidity in Key West, the pool was a Godsend), very private, lots of chairs and loungers.Washer and dryer are located outside in a cabinet, very quiet. One caution, the stairs to the upstairs bedroom are steep and narrow, would not be great for the elderly or young children. House is very close (a couple of blocks) to the Hemingway House, Lighthouse, Southernmost Point, DuVal Street, great restaurants and the best conch salad on the planet (Johnson's Grocery, trust me). We could not have been happier with the house or Historic Key West Rentals. This one is a gem.

Submitted by Vancouver WA on Jul 29, 2017

5.0

great time

Loved the cottage had a great experience. The only thing that would make it better would be softer bed, (very stiff,) and cooler temp in the pool. Don't know if the pool was heated or it was the sun? Oh and maybe Salt and Pepper and sugar packets.

Submitted by Monroeville Pa on Jun 27, 2017

5.0

ricciardella getaway

It was great. Potters Cottage was wonderful.

Submitted by Brookeville MD on Jun 14, 2017

5.0

potter's cottage was fabulous

Check in was quick and easy, the cottage was exactly as described, in great condition with helpful amenities, and right in the heart of where you want to be in Key West! Fantastic!

Submitted by Midland TX on Jun 07, 2017

5.0

perfect

We (two couples) spent the Memorial Day weekend in Key West at the Potter's Cottage.
It was everything that we wanted and more. The unit is located at a great location and, despite being on Whitehead (a busy street) there was no annoying street noise.
The kitchen was well-equipped, the rooms comfortable and the pool was fabulous.
I would highly recommend it!

Submitted by Winter Park FL on May 31, 2017

5.0

my recent stay

Everything was ready for us upon our arrival. House was perfect and very clean. Location was fantastic, walking distance to Duval Street and the Southernmost Point. Only complaint would be parking.

Submitted by Leavenworth Kansas on May 19, 2017

5.0

potter's cottage

We recently stayed at Potter's Cottage on our first ever trip to Key West. It was the perfect place for us! The property is perfectly located for people who want to be walking distance to all the major attractions but want a little space from all the noise of upper Duval. The Cottage is charming. It is beautifully decorated with all the amenities you need. The pool and patio are a perfect place to relax at the end of a busy day sightseeing. My only qualification would be for people with limited mobility or who have trouble climbing stairs. The master bedroom is wonderful but the stairs are quite steep so if that would be an issue it might not be the best place to stay. Otherwise it was perfect. Danny was our concierge and helpfully gave us several suggestions of places to eat and they were all fabulous.

Submitted by Madison MS on May 15, 2017

5.0

potter's cottage

Fantastic cottage. Just far enough off Duval, but close enough by bike. Perfect property for our family. Master suite is ideal. Our 2 daughters had their space as well. Updated appliances, cutlery, TVs, patio furniture, towels, bathrooms... hesitant to share such a glowing review as we want to come back.

Submitted by Fort Worth TX on Mar 23, 2017

5.0

a relaxing week

This was our 2nd stay at Potter's in 3 months. This is a wonderful cottage, with all the amenities you would ever need. The house is ideal for 2 couples with one bedroom downstairs and one upstairs providing some additional privacy. There is a wonderful deck and covered area around the pool (we spent more time here then in the house!). The management company provided us with 2 nice lounge chairs for the pool, as the other seats are chairs and not designed for sunbathing. The house is in an ideal location just a block off Duval St and a block from Hemingway's home and the lighthouse. You are very centrally located here making it a easy walk to anywhere in old town. We will be back to Potter's cottage again!

Submitted by Dunn NC on Feb 03, 2017

5.0

potters cottage

Wonderful cottage with delightful fenced in deck/pool/lanai area. Loved the front porch for coffee in morning and people watching at night. Perfect distance from Duval and other amenities. Comfy cottage and nicely decorated. If you have bad knees, plan on staying in the ground level bedroom. Stairs to upstairs are a bit steep but fine if you're in shape.

Submitted by East Troy wi on Feb 02, 2017

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Thank you for the wonderful review! It was a pleasure to have you stay with us at Potter's Cottage!

5.0

amazing!

We had the most amazing time in Key West. Potter's Cottage is spotlessly clean, well equipped, beautifully furnished and in walking distance to everything. It was perfect for us (2 couples)and we can't wait to come back. Thank you!

Submitted by Bamberg BY on Jan 08, 2017

5.0

our stay in potter's cottage

Very cute and very well laid out cottage.

The location is perfect, but not too close to the tourist areas to be loud.

The plunge pool is a good size, and I recommend the option of having it heated in the winter.

Perfect for two couples and even a fifth person, with the little side room.

Submitted by Atlanta GA on Dec 12, 2016

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Hi Paul! Thanks so much for taking the time to post your review from your recent stay at Potter's Cottage. It sounds like you truly enjoyed your time spent during your Key West vacation. Please give us a call the next time you come to visit, we are happy to have you back!

5.0

potter's cottage in key west

Our rental experience was acceptable even with a couple of issues. We would recommend this agency. We will consider using them when we vacation in Key West again (like next year). We especially were thankful for the cleanliness of the house. We enjoyed the decor and furniture inside and outside. It was very cool and tropical! Having upper end quality bed collections, towels, etc. is ideal for us. The location was quiet. We enjoy walking so the distance to Sloppy Joes, etc. did not bother us. Sure wish the pool was bigger. Then Potter's Cottage would be perfect. The managers were great, friendly and had attention to details. Yea!

Submitted by Nashport OH on Aug 22, 2016

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Hi Kay! We're glad to hear that the the home was clean and you enjoyed the decor. Thanks for recommending us as a vacation rental agency. You can give us a call anytime and we'd be more than happy to accommodate you on your next trip to Key West.

5.0

great cottage in a great location

Our family of five recently rented the Potter's Cottage for a week in July. We knew that it was on the smaller side, but there was actually plenty of room for all of us. We loved the location, which was an easy walking distance to restaurants, etc. on Duval, as well as several beaches that we enjoyed. The pool was a great addition due to the very warm weather. It was great to have Phil to make suggestions and assist with our reservations for dinner, etc.. He is a great asset to HKWVR. On our next visit to Key West, we would definitely rent this cottage again.

Submitted by Palmyra PA on Jul 21, 2016

Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Hi Roni! I'm so happy you and your family enjoyed Potter's Cottage for a week in July. Having a pool in Key West really makes a difference! I agree about your statement regarding Phil, he is an amazing person and a big part of HKWVR's success. Please come back to Key West soon, we miss you already!

5.0

potters cottage review

We thought the property was lovely and we loved the location. On several occasions the neighbors behind caused quite a disturbance. The guest bedroom mattress is hard as a rock which not quite so comfortable. Would like a TV or at least some type of speaker to be able to enjoy music on the deck around the pool. Loved the front porch and enjoyed people watching. Would definitely stay there again!

Submitted by Princeville IL on Mar 15, 2016