5.0
adorable house - exceeded expectations
We had 4 people and rented the bottom unit in May. The interior is exactly like the photos and you're instantly in Key West vacation mood. The backyard pool area is gorgeous and we drank coffee out there in the mornings and were tempted back there every afternoon for a few hours of glorious pool time between checking out the town and sights. Loved the convenient location and we did not have any close-by roosters crowing. Upstairs neighbors were friendly and we shared tips on what to do in KW. I suspect, due to the not-low-budget accommodations, that this house doesn't attract the young partying crowd.
A couple of tips: there are some mosquitoes at night but we found a bunch of bug spray under the kitchen sink. Bring hair conditioner - it's not provided and the shampoo is only enough for a couple of days if you have women using it :), also living room chairs are too stiff, not comfy, but couch is fine.
I would highly recommend for all the reasons the previous Reviewers gave and I hope I can go back because, even though Key West is tiny, there's "still so much to be done" and we weren't able to visit the Dry Tortugas this trip!
Submitted by San Jose CA on May 25, 2025
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We are already looking forward to your next stay ~ let us know when you're coming back and we'll be happy to help look into booking a Dry Tortugas trip for you!
Thank you for the nice review ~ and the great tips!
~ The Team @ Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
5.0
happiness
Best Airbnb we have rented in Key West. Charming and well appointed. Location is excellent, unit was clean and nicely decorated. The management was very response and easy. We were missing nothing. We will definitely be back.
Submitted by Kill Devil Hills NC on Apr 30, 2025
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We are looking forward to your next stay! Remember to book directly with us ~ we love that!
~ The Team @ HKWVR
5.0
a jewel in key west!!
Fabulous location, and beautiful, well-maintained home. Very Comfy beds, beautiful/quality decor, quiet neighborhood but within easy walking distance to Duval, nightlife, Mallory square, trolly, restaurants etc. Great parking, but we didn't need to use our car at all!
Pool was wonderful and kitchen was equipped with everything possibly needed. Lots of thought was put into all the little "extras" provided to guests. One of THE BEST Airbnb's we have ever experienced. Will definitely recommend and revisit!!
Quality decor
Loved extras of soap body wash etc
Very well equipped kitchen
Submitted by Sarasota FL on Apr 04, 2025
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thank you for the kind and well thought out review of Sea Conch. We're thrilled you enjoyed your time and hope you'll be back soon!
~ The Team @ HKWVR
5.0
sea conch on southard - awesome property/location
We (3 of us, my wife & son) stayed at Sea Conch on Southard for three nights ....we are frequent visitors of Key West dating back ~40 years and live in FL. This is a very well appointed property and in a prime location. We had the first floor which is secluded from the upstairs so privacy's maintained. The property managers were great to deal with.
Submitted by Venice FL on Feb 26, 2025
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thank you, Mike, for your fabulous review of Sea Conch! We agree that it is an awesome property in an awesome location. We appreciate your kind words and hope to welcome you back to Key West in the future! The Team at HKWVR
5.0
just lovely!
We absolutely loved our stay at the Sea Conch. The location was amazing, close to all the shops and restaurants, and within walking distance of nearly everything. The parking space next to the house was also phenomenal. The inside was charming, spacious, and very comfortable. Our children loved the heated pool out back and we spent many evenings enjoying the beautiful trees and plants and cozy covered patio out back. It was just wonderful.
Submitted by Lake Worth FL on Jan 07, 2025
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
You make your stay sound magical ~ and we are happy Sea Conch was part of that!
~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR
5.0
great rental
We had a wonderful time at this rental. There was ample space for 4 adults. The pool environment was fantastic. The house was clean. The only downside was when there were tenants upstairs, as you could here them walking (or running kids) over your head. We would definitely stay here again.
Submitted by Hanover PA on Jul 02, 2024
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thank you for taking the time to review your stay at Sea Conch! It is a great home and outdoor oasis! We apologize if the guests upstairs were not respectful of the shared space- we could have reached out with a friendly reminder. We look forward to seeing you again in the future! The Team @ HKWVR
5.0
great house and location!
House was very comfortable and looked like the pictures. Concierge service was excellent. Loved the location!
Submitted by Dallas TX on Jun 08, 2024
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We thank you for taking the time to review us so kindly! We hope you'll return to stay with us again, and soon!
~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR
5.0
beautiful home and pool!
The Sea Conch was clean and comfortable. We used the pool every day. HKWR staff was quick to respond to questions and one service request. We will be back!
Submitted by Golden Valley MN on Apr 07, 2024
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thank you for taking the time to review Sea Conch! We strive for guest satisfaction and are happy we were able to quickly assist you. We can't wait to see you again~ Lori & the Team @ HKWVR
5.0
another great stay at sea conch
Wonderful again! Great space, great pool and an amazing location - close to everything but away from the noise! We’ve already booked again for next year!
Submitted by New York NY on Mar 31, 2024
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We love seeing familiar faces walk through our doors! Thank you for the nice review and the return visit.
~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR
5.0
wonderful time was had by all
Second year in a row staying at Sea Conch. Love the location and property. The pool was so relaxing and enjoyable. House is well stocked.
Submitted by Waddell AZ on Feb 21, 2024
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We love seeing familiar faces and know that the 3rd time will be 'the charm', so please make it soon.
~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR
5.0
amazing key west property
One of the best places we have stayed in Key West! The property was perfect. It housed 4 adults comfortably and provided a super convenient location within walking/biking distance of everything we did. The backyard was incredible. We spent a few days hanging out by the pool instead of going out because it was so enjoyable! Hands down a top not choice for a Key West vacation!
Submitted by Pensacola FL on Nov 14, 2023
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Wow! What a great review of Sea Conch! So happy to know you enjoyed the home and the pool area. Please tell us when you'll be back ~ we like seeing happy, familiar faces!
~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR
5.0
absolutely amazing vacation rental
Our stay at the Sea Conch is our best experience yet visiting Key West! The home was immaculately clean, beautifully decorated, and well-furnished! Historic Key West Vacations is our new favorite rental company! Thank you for providing such a fantastic Key West Experience!
Submitted by Proctorville OH on Oct 04, 2023
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
You like us! You really like us! We like you too and agree Sea Conch is amazing. We hope we'll see you again, and soon!
~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR
5.0
amazing place!
Check in was easy, staff was wonderful. Place was immaculate! Had a wonderful stay and do very much recommend!
Submitted by College Park GA on Sep 28, 2023
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thank you so much for the kind words about us and Sea Conch! We hope we'll see you again, and soon.
Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR
5.0
we enjoyed our long weekend!
Very relaxing! Short walk to Duval - very convenient location. Clean, comfortable, beautiful pool area, etc. we enjoyed our vacation and we will definitely be back.
Submitted by Tampa FL on Sep 26, 2023
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We will be counting the days until we see you again! We're here year round so you can come anytime.
~ Jennifer & Team @ HKWVR
5.0
haven in the heat
The place was perfect. Vacation with teenage grand daughters. Their first visit to Key West. While hot the location was great, the pool was beyond perfect, the rooms, beds, and all other amenities could not have been better.
Submitted by Little Rock AR on Jul 16, 2023
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We're so happy you enjoyed your vacation time with granddaughters! The pool is perfect for summertime (and granddaughters) and we hope you'll come and spend more time here making memories for everyone.
~ Team HKWVR
5.0
excellent service and comfort
Our week was perfect! The house was amazing, the pool refreshing, the beds very comfortable, and the charm exactly what we were looking for. Thank you Susan for helping get us checked in and settled! Customer service was excellent! Thank you so much.
Submitted by Fultondale AL on Jul 10, 2023
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We are so happy you enjoyed Sea Conch and had an amazing time. That's our goal ~ a home away from home and some great memories to take with you! Come make some more memories with us, soon! (and we agree Susan is pretty great, too!)
~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR
5.0
lovely stay in old town!
We would rent this lovely two bedroom unit again. Great combination of charm, comfort and location. The interior was clean and well maintained and the pool area was beautifully landscaped.
Submitted by Keene NH on Jun 21, 2023
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We are so happy to hear you'd come back and see us again. We will hold you to this! Thank you for taking the time to review us so kindly.
~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR
5.0
a wonderful retreat
First, I don’t think you can find a better location, near Duval, close to restaurants and shops. We rented bikes but ended up walking most places. Second, the house is spotless! We were there with another couple and were very comfortable. We chose to cook supper most nights using the grill which was, also, spotless! The kitchen is well appointed with sharp knives! The staff was very kind offering suggestions for sites and dining! We really enjoyed having a pretty much private pool! The cleaning folks were very good and kept both the outside and inside clean. Thanks for a great vacay!
Submitted by Berkeley Springs WV on May 17, 2023
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thank you so much for your review of Sea Conch! Our team works hard and appreciates your comments. We hope to see you again soon in sunny Key West! Lori and the HKWVR Team
5.0
first trip to key west
The unit was very neat and clean. And the location was excellent about a block and a half away from Duvall, which is the center of the entertainment District. The pool in the backyard was an excellent benefit. Even when one of the renters from upstairs was outside. We both enjoyed the pool, and did not really Interfere with one another the only negative was we had four people one person was sleeping on the couch and had to go through the bedrooms. Do use the bathroom at night. But definitely enjoyed this day and would return again.
Submitted by Holts Summit MO on Feb 09, 2023
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thank you for your honest review. We wish we would've known about the 5th guest so we could have described the bathroom situation better. Come and stay with us again ~ we're looking forward to it.
~ Jennifer @ HKWVR
5.0
a+++
We absolutely loved our stay! Perfect location, perfect home! We will definitely be back!
Submitted by Longview TX on Feb 02, 2023
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your time at Sea Conch and hope you're coming back soon! We're here waiting!
~ Jennifer & the HKWVR team
5.0
wonderful
It was easy check in, they gave a pamphlet on the things to do and just so very friendly.
Submitted by Bolivar OH on Nov 16, 2022
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Well, thank you! You were super friendly too! :)
Come back again and let's do it all again.
~ Jennifer @ HKWVR
5.0
everything exceeded expectations!
Our family stayed in the first floor apartment of Sea Conch for four nights in July. Everything about the rental exceeded our expectations. The place was spotless. The first floor had a full kitchen, a huge dining/family room, two full sized bedrooms with attached bathrooms. The back yard pool area was like a botanical garden. The location was very quiet, but only a couple of blocks from Duval Street, Fausto's and several great restaurants.
Submitted by Tallahassee FL on Jul 28, 2022
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Gigi, thank you for your review of the Sea Conch. It is a lovely rental and the parking space is a great amenity too! We are glad you enjoyed your time here with your family and hope you can come back again to make even more memories!
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
great stay!
We had a wonderful stay at Sea Conch. The location is perfect. The back yard with pool is a little oasis in downtown Key West. We could walk or bike everywhere. Definitely recommend.
Submitted by Trumansburg NY on May 06, 2022
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We are so happy you enjoyed your time at Sea Conch and in Key West! We can't wait for you to come and stay with us again, and soon!
~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR
5.0
great stay, great staff
The home was beautiful, in an amazing location and the office staff was amazing!
Submitted by Noblesville IN on Mar 28, 2022
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thank you kindly! We think you're pretty amazing too! We hope you're making plans to come and see us again, and soon!
~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR
5.0
slice of paradise
Loved our stay in the lower unit of Sea Conch. Great location and nice pool. Private bathrooms in each bedroom. Fully stocked kitchen. Best, however, was Susan in Historic Key West Vacation Rentals. She made the check in process easy. We arrived in the morning, so she stored our bags and gave us great lunch recommendations while we waited for check in.
Submitted by Bellbrook OH on Mar 26, 2022
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We are so happy you enjoyed your time in Key West and at Sea Conch ~ and we agree, Susan is awesome! :) Come and stay with us again; we love seeing happy, familiar faces.
~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR
5.0
can't wait for next year!
Everything from start to finish was exceptional! Historic Key West Vacation Rentals was wonderful to work with. We've stayed in KW a number of times and this was, by far, the most perfect location there is! We walked everywhere! And the house was simply beautiful. We loved sitting on the front porch, the back porch and spent A LOT of time in the pool area. We hated leaving and booked for next year before our last day! See you next year, Sea Conch. We can hardly wait.
Submitted by Fredericksburg VA on Feb 23, 2022
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We can't wait to see you, either! We love seeing familiar, happy faces. I'd say come and see us again, and soon ~ but you're already coming!
~ Jennifer & Team HKWVR
5.0
january sea conch
Great
Submitted by Greenwood IN on Feb 13, 2022
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
We're happy you enjoyed your time at Sea Conch and hope you're already making plans to come and see us again, and soon! We like happy and nice familiar faces. :)
~ Jennifer & Team Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
5.0
luxury in key west
We had a wonderful time in Key West celebrating our friends wedding. The staff at Historic Key West Rentals was phenomenal. They went above and beyond to make sure that our stay was perfect from beginning to end. Would definitely stay with them again. 10/10.
Submitted by Columbus OH on Oct 27, 2021
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Patrick, thank you for the review. It is a lovely place and the pool is a nice addition too. We are happy you were pleased with everything and hope you will come back again. Always fun to be had in Key West!
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
key west vacation
Awesome. Loved the property
Submitted by Baton Rouge LA on Oct 17, 2021
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
David we are pleased you enjoyed your stay at the Sea Conch. It is is a great location and the pool is an oasis! Key West is an amazing place to visit and we hope you come back again soon!
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
excellent stay in key west
Had an excellent stay at one of the finest places we have ever been to.
The House was spacious, super clean with every amenity once could possible need.
The grounds with the all the plantings was beautiful and made you feel very secluded with the pool a refreshing option after a hot day walking in KW. The neighborhood around the house is nice and quiet with many quaint KW style homes, but still only a 5-10 minute walk to the all the music, shopping and dining on Duval St.
Would highly recommend the Sea Conch for people looking for a great place to stay.
Submitted by Cheshire CT on Sep 17, 2021
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Todd, we are so happy you were pleased with the Sea Conch and the pool is a welcome addition after a day of activities. Please come back to Key West whenever you can. More adventures await you !
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
wonderful trip to key west
GREAT property just off Duval St. - in the heart of Old Town. The accommodations were very nice and we enjoyed the pool. We loved it! The only negative would be the sound of walking from the renters upstairs.
Submitted by Mobile AL on Aug 22, 2021
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Jane, thank you for your review of the Sea Conch. We're sorry your neighbors upstairs were heavy walkers. However we are happy you loved the pool and accommodations! It is located in a great area. Please visit this paradise again soon!
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
smooth painless process, exceeded my expectations
Booked a property for a few buddies for a fishing trip and had an amazing time. Property was well maintained, clean and great location!
Submitted by Howell NJ on Apr 13, 2021
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Frank thank you so much for your review of the Sea Conch. The relaxing pool is a great way to end the day! We are pleased you were happy with everything and hope you can come back soon!
Cindy & the HKWVR team.
5.0
better than the pictures!
We rented the bottom floor of this house which is two bedrooms and two baths. It was beautifully decorated, in an excellent location, and the pool was just heaven. The location of the house is very central and you can walk to all the hotspots. Only 2 blocks from Duval street. We rented a car because we drove from Miami, but did not use the car at all during the week. We rented bikes and either biked or walked everywhere. There is also a food market, and a CVS nearby, and we did make our own meals at least once a day. The house shares the pool with the two upstairs smaller units. We met our neighbors several times and they were very friendly, so hanging out at the pool together once or twice it was no big deal. The rental company was very responsive and provided a lot of good advice on restaurants and activities. They helped me book the bikes and a sail and snorkeling boat excursion. We were so sad to leave, and plan to return as soon as possible. I would stay here again in a heartbeat. The only possible downside to this place is that you can hear people walking above you upstairs.
Submitted by Chantilly VA on Apr 05, 2021
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Catherine, thank you for such a nice review of the Sea Conch. It is a great property and sharing the pool with 2 other units is a plus and its a nice size! We are happy you were pleased with us as well and hope you can come visit Key West again soon!
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
heavenly
As much as we love biking and walking Key West, this home made us lazy. Leaving the tropical backyard and heated pool was hard to do. House was spotless and thoroughly equipped.
Submitted by Pensacola FL on Feb 22, 2021
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
William, we are so happy you had a great time at the Sea Conch and enjoyed the outdoor oasis so much. It is a hidden gem. Please come back next year and soak up more of the wonderful Key West weather!
Cindy & the HKWVR teaam
5.0
excellent location and home!
We had a fantastic stay at this lovely home with our family of 5. We brought our blowup mattress and had plenty of comfortable sleeping for all. Kitchen was great as was outdoor grill for our meals. Home was short walk to plenty of shopping and restaurants. Highly recommend!!
Submitted by Lakeland FL on Jan 01, 2021
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Christina, thank you so much for your review of Sea Conch. We are happy you enjoyed your stay and were able to walk around and take it all in. Hoping you can come back soon for more fun in the sun!
Cindy & the HKWVR team. CC
5.0
sea conch is very relaxing!
Very nice house in the heart of Key West. The house is spacious and very comfortable. The kitchen is beyond well equipped. Very comfortable beds with an abundance of linen and extra towels. Baths are spacious and very comforting, with great showers. The pool area is well adorned with plenty of lounge chairs and tables. The whole back yard is a tropical paradise. Hard to imagine you are in the middle of Key West!
Submitted by Punta Gorda FL on Dec 12, 2020
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Warren, we are so happy you were pleased with your stay at Sea Conch. It is a lovely property and a very relaxing place to be. Please come back and visit for more Key West adventures when you can.
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
awesome little house
This very well kept home was in a wonderful location. The rocking chairs on the front porch made for los of “local” conversations. The pool in a virtual Forrest in the back was wonderful...also with lots of chairs for morning coffee, etc. on top of this it is a couple blocks off of Duval and right in the middle!
Submitted by Montgomery TX on Dec 08, 2020
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Valerie we appreciate your review of Sea Conch and are so glad you had a good time. It is a great property and so close to all things Key West! Please come visit again when you can and stay well!
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
great place! great management company...
The rental property was better than expected and the property management company was top notch. They checked in with us (via text) throughout our stay to ensure we were having a great time during our visit.
Submitted by East Moline IL on Nov 30, 2020
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Terry, thank you for your Sea Conch review. We are happy you were pleased with the property and our company! Please come back again for more Key West fun when you can!
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
amazing stay!
This rental was absolutely perfect. Gave us the relaxation and tropical oasis feeling that we wanted but only a short walk to all the nightlife and restaurants! It was spotless when we arrived. Would recommend for a family, group of friends or really any type of group honestly! The company was so great to work with, answered all my questions very timely and were always available with recommendations and anything we needed!
Submitted by Kirksville MO on Oct 21, 2020
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Brooke, Thank you for your review of the Sea Conch and us! We are very happy you had such a great experience. That is what we aim for ! We hope to see you again in the future for more Key West fun.
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
great place to stay in key west
We've been going to Key West for years, and usually stay at some of the great b&bs. This time we found this house (convenient to Duval, but not too close). It's fantastic. The backyard, with the pool, is a nice, secluded retreat. Everything is walkable from here. The living area and kitchen were perfect for the two couples that stayed there. The communication from the property manager was fantastic!
Submitted by Denver NC on Jan 30, 2020
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
John we appreciate your review of Southard Comfort and are happy you were pleased renting a home. It is nice not to be bothered by anyone else and have your own space. This property is the perfect spot to unwind and relax. We hope to see you again! Stay warm!
Kind Regards,
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
front porch kinda vacation
We came to relax and relax we did!! The front porch has 4 rocking chairs which we sat in hot hours, quite street but lots of foot traffic to keep front porch Sutton’ entertaining!! Lol! Also spent lots of time in the backyard pool, feels very isolated With the tall greenery. The best part was when we did want to go do something Duval was just 2 streets away!! We walked most everywhere. Great location. The absolute only negative was that you you could hear every footstep of the upstairs neighbors BUT that’s just a historical house for you.
Submitted by Claremore OK on Dec 29, 2019
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Thanks for your perfect review of Sea Conch. It's so close to Duval St. for seeking out fun, but so relaxing in the lush garden backyard with beautiful pool. People watching from the front porch is a good way to pass time. We look forward to your next visit to Key West.
Smiles,
Mary Ann and the HKWVR team
5.0
great time with friends at fantasy fest 2019
This property was in a great location. It was close to Duval Street. The property was very clean. We also used the pool. I would recommend this place for up to 6 guest. It was very comfortable.
Submitted by Naples FL on Nov 13, 2019
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Doreen thank you for reviewing the Sea Conch. We are pleased you enjoyed your stay and could enjoy the pool. It is in a very convenient location. Please come back again soon and we hope you have a Happy Holiday season!
Warm Regards,
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
sea conch was a wonderful experience!
This was our first time renting a house in Key West. We normally stay at the Casa Marina or The Reach but wanted a different experience. I am happy to say it was our BEST lodging experience ever in Key West! We will definitely be staying there again��
Submitted by Monroe NY on Nov 05, 2019
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Stacey we are so happy you enjoyed your stay at the Sea Conch. It really is a lovely property & conveniently located. We hope to see you again soon!
Warm Regards,
Cindy & the HKWVR team
5.0
key west getaway
The House was perfect, comfortable, great location
Submitted by Ocean Springs MS on Oct 24, 2019
Response from Historic Key West Vacation Rentals
Hi Crystal! We're so happy the Sea Conch was perfect for your Key West vacation. It's so close to Duval St. , but then you can go home to relax, jump in the pool and enjoy the lush private backyard. Thanks for your 5 star review and we are looking forward to seeing you again.
Smiles,
Mary Ann and the HKWVR team