Row Wrapper 2

Potter's Cottage - Nightly Rental

4.7931
(29 Reviews)

Capacity

2 Bedrooms
2 Bath
Sleeps 6

Search Availability

About

Historic Old Town Location - Private Pool - Steps from World Famous Duval Street and the Ernest Hemingway Home!

Debating between the comfort of a chic hotel and the thrill of more authentic accommodations? You will get the best of both worlds with this cozy 2 bedroom home, currently available for up to 6 guests.

Potter’s Cottage is located in the heart of Old Town – Key West’s colorful historic district. 1 block from world famous Duval Street and 1.5 blocks from the historic home of the legendary writer Ernest Hemingway. This highly desirable location is in the Gallery District of Duval Street. You'll be close enough to enjoy all of the restaurants and nightlife Duval Street has to offer, while still quiet enough for relaxation and rest.

This super cute home boasts all the amenities you would expect from a luxury hotel including a concierge and high speed Wi-Fi. At the same time, you can live like a local by taking advantage of the fully equipped kitchen. Enjoy the privacy our tucked-away location affords smack dab in the middle of Key West’s oldest neighborhood. The first floor French doors open to the private heated dip pool, covered lanai dining area, and ultra comfy shaded outdoor lounge area.

Potter’s Cottage (a nod to the building’s origins in 1918 as an artisan potter's shop where beautiful bowls and other pottery items were created) comes fully furnished with a King sized bed, a Queen sized bed, bed linens and towels, a modern kitchen, and 2 private bathrooms. There is also a "bonus" room with a sleeper sofa. It’s the perfect size for 2 couples or up to 5 travelers. Comparable rooms and suites downtown run upwards of $700 per night, and they don’t have half the character of this hidden gem.

When you are ready to venture out, Potter’s Cottage is conveniently located minutes form Key West’s major attractions – including sun kissed beaches, 5 star restaurants, museums, galleries, shopping, and of course the famous Duval Street nightlife. Potter’s Cottage offers limitless opportunities to explore the city by foot. You’ll find our neighbors warm and welcoming. And if you need help organizing your adventures, simply ask. Your vacation rental includes a free concierge service who knows the city like the back of his hand.

***Managed by Historic Key West Vacation Rentals***

Features

Amenities

  • Satellite / Cable
  • Television
  • Heated Pool
  • Private Pool
  • Full Kitchen
  • Coffee Maker
  • Dishwasher
  • Microwave
  • Toaster
  • Cookware
  • Dinnerware
  • Central Air
  • Air Conditioning
  • Ceiling Fans
  • Linens
  • Washer & Dryer
  • Ironing Board
  • WiFi High Speed Internet
  • Iron
  • Hairdryer
  • Cable TV
  • WiFi High Speed Internet

Location

  • Historic Old Town
  • Near Beach

Type

  • House

Length of Stay

  • Nightly and Weekly

Availability

Key
#Night Available#Night Unavailable#Arrive Only#Depart Only
April 2018
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
 
7
 
8
 
9
 
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
 
17
 
18
 
19
 
20
 
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
 
May 2018
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
 
7
 
8
 
9
 
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
$399 /nt
17
 
18
 
19
 
20
 
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31
 
 
June 2018
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
 
2
 
3
 
4
$399 /nt
5
$399 /nt
6
$399 /nt
7
$399 /nt
8
 
9
 
10
 
11
 
12
$399 /nt
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
 
17
 
18
 
19
$399 /nt
20
$399 /nt
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
$399 /nt
25
$399 /nt
26
$399 /nt
27
$399 /nt
28
$399 /nt
29
$399 /nt
30
$399 /nt
July 2018
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
$399 /nt
6
$399 /nt
7
$399 /nt
8
$399 /nt
9
$399 /nt
10
$399 /nt
11
$399 /nt
12
$399 /nt
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
 
17
$399 /nt
18
$399 /nt
19
$399 /nt
20
$399 /nt
21
$399 /nt
22
$399 /nt
23
 
24
 
25
 
26
 
27
$399 /nt
28
$399 /nt
29
$399 /nt
30
$399 /nt
31
$399 /nt
 
August 2018
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
$399 /nt
2
$399 /nt
3
$399 /nt
4
$399 /nt
5
$399 /nt
6
$399 /nt
7
$399 /nt
8
$399 /nt
9
$399 /nt
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
$399 /nt
14
$399 /nt
15
$399 /nt
16
$399 /nt
17
$399 /nt
18
$399 /nt
19
$399 /nt
20
$399 /nt
21
$399 /nt
22
$399 /nt
23
$399 /nt
24
$399 /nt
25
$399 /nt
26
$399 /nt
27
$399 /nt
28
$399 /nt
29
$399 /nt
30
$399 /nt
31
$399 /nt
 
September 2018
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
$399 /nt
2
$399 /nt
3
$399 /nt
4
$399 /nt
5
$399 /nt
6
$399 /nt
7
$399 /nt
8
$399 /nt
9
$399 /nt
10
$399 /nt
11
$399 /nt
12
$399 /nt
13
$399 /nt
14
$399 /nt
15
$399 /nt
16
$399 /nt
17
$399 /nt
18
$399 /nt
19
$399 /nt
20
$399 /nt
21
$399 /nt
22
$399 /nt
23
$399 /nt
24
$399 /nt
25
$399 /nt
26
$399 /nt
27
$399 /nt
28
$399 /nt
29
$399 /nt
30
$399 /nt
 
October 2018
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
$549 /nt
2
$549 /nt
3
$549 /nt
4
$549 /nt
5
$549 /nt
6
$549 /nt
7
$549 /nt
8
$549 /nt
9
$549 /nt
10
$549 /nt
11
$549 /nt
12
$549 /nt
13
$549 /nt
14
$549 /nt
15
$549 /nt
16
$549 /nt
17
$549 /nt
18
$549 /nt
19
$549 /nt
20
$549 /nt
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
$549 /nt
29
$549 /nt
30
$549 /nt
31
$549 /nt
 
November 2018
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
$549 /nt
2
$549 /nt
3
$549 /nt
4
$549 /nt
5
$549 /nt
6
$549 /nt
7
$549 /nt
8
$549 /nt
9
$549 /nt
10
$549 /nt
11
$549 /nt
12
$549 /nt
13
$549 /nt
14
$549 /nt
15
$549 /nt
16
$549 /nt
17
$549 /nt
18
$549 /nt
19
$549 /nt
20
$549 /nt
21
$549 /nt
22
$549 /nt
23
$549 /nt
24
$549 /nt
25
$549 /nt
26
$549 /nt
27
$549 /nt
28
$549 /nt
29
$549 /nt
30
$549 /nt
 
December 2018
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
$549 /nt
2
$549 /nt
3
$549 /nt
4
$549 /nt
5
$549 /nt
6
$549 /nt
7
$549 /nt
8
$549 /nt
9
$549 /nt
10
$549 /nt
11
$549 /nt
12
$549 /nt
13
$549 /nt
14
$549 /nt
15
$549 /nt
16
$549 /nt
17
$549 /nt
18
$549 /nt
19
$549 /nt
20
$549 /nt
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31
 
 
January 2019
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
$599 /nt
7
$599 /nt
8
$599 /nt
9
$599 /nt
10
$599 /nt
11
$599 /nt
12
$599 /nt
13
$599 /nt
14
$599 /nt
15
$599 /nt
16
$599 /nt
17
$599 /nt
18
$599 /nt
19
$599 /nt
20
$599 /nt
21
$599 /nt
22
$599 /nt
23
$599 /nt
24
$599 /nt
25
$599 /nt
26
$599 /nt
27
$599 /nt
28
$599 /nt
29
$599 /nt
30
$599 /nt
31
$599 /nt
 
February 2019
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
$599 /nt
2
$599 /nt
3
$599 /nt
4
$599 /nt
5
$599 /nt
6
$599 /nt
7
$599 /nt
8
$599 /nt
9
$599 /nt
10
$599 /nt
11
$599 /nt
12
$599 /nt
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
 
17
 
18
$599 /nt
19
$599 /nt
20
$599 /nt
21
$599 /nt
22
$599 /nt
23
$599 /nt
24
$599 /nt
25
$599 /nt
26
$599 /nt
27
$599 /nt
28
$599 /nt
 
March 2019
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
$599 /nt
2
$599 /nt
3
$599 /nt
4
$599 /nt
5
$599 /nt
6
$599 /nt
7
$599 /nt
8
$599 /nt
9
$599 /nt
10
$599 /nt
11
 
12
 
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
 
17
 
18
 
19
 
20
$599 /nt
21
$599 /nt
22
$599 /nt
23
$599 /nt
24
$599 /nt
25
$599 /nt
26
$599 /nt
27
$599 /nt
28
$599 /nt
29
$599 /nt
30
$599 /nt
31
$599 /nt
 

Map

Reviews

Key West Wedding Weekend

Reviewed on2018-04-24 by from Hilton Head Island, SC United States

Updated on 2018-04-24
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
We were 5 adults traveling to Key West for a weekend wedding and Potters Cottage was great for our stay. One single adult slept on the (never really comfortable but manageable) pull out sofa in the den and the other two couples each had a bedroom. The beds were very comfortable. The cottage was spotless and well equipped!! Very nice decor and again so clean!! Great location to everything. We would stay there again.

Home away from home

Reviewed on2018-04-03 by from State College, PA United States

Updated on 2018-04-03
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
This was a perfect place for our first extended stay in Key West. It was comfortable and met all our needs. The location was perfect, close to beaches, restaurants and 1 block from Duval street. Having Phil to help us navigate deliveries, reservations, etc. was such an added plus! Thank you Phil! Thank you Potter Cottage for a memorable vacation!

Horrible beds

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from lewisville, NC United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
2
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
2
Great house, pool and location. Unfortunately, our trip was totally ruined by the hard, uncomfortable beds. We even made our kids switch rooms after two night of no sleep. Unfortunately, the other bed was just as bad. My wife ended up sleeping on the couch. Buy some better mattresses and I would love this house.

Potter's Cottage

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Fort Worth, TX United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5
Fantastic cottage. Just far enough off Duval, but close enough by bike. Perfect property for our family. Master suite is ideal. Our 2 daughters had their space as well. Updated appliances, cutlery, TVs, patio furniture, towels, bathrooms... hesitant to share such a glowing review as we want to come back.

A relaxing week

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Dunn, NC United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
This was our 2nd stay at Potter's in 3 months. This is a wonderful cottage, with all the amenities you would ever need. The house is ideal for 2 couples with one bedroom downstairs and one upstairs providing some additional privacy. There is a wonderful deck and covered area around the pool (we spent more time here then in the house!). The management company provided us with 2 nice lounge chairs for the pool, as the other seats are chairs and not designed for sunbathing. The house is in an ideal location just a block off Duval St and a block from Hemingway's home and the lighthouse. You are very centrally located here making it a easy walk to anywhere in old town. We will be back to Potter's cottage again!

Potters Cottage

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from East Troy, wi United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
Wonderful cottage with delightful fenced in deck/pool/lanai area. Loved the front porch for coffee in morning and people watching at night. Perfect distance from Duval and other amenities. Comfy cottage and nicely decorated. If you have bad knees, plan on staying in the ground level bedroom. Stairs to upstairs are a bit steep but fine if you're in shape.

Amazing!

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Bamberg, BY Germany

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4
We had the most amazing time in Key West. Potter's Cottage is spotlessly clean, well equipped, beautifully furnished and in walking distance to everything. It was perfect for us (2 couples)and we can't wait to come back. Thank you!

Our stay in Potter's Cottage

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Atlanta, GA United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4
Very cute and very well laid out cottage. <br/><br/>The location is perfect, but not too close to the tourist areas to be loud.<br/><br/>The plunge pool is a good size, and I recommend the option of having it heated in the winter.<br/><br/>Perfect for two couples and even a fifth person, with the little side room.

Potter's Cottage in Key West

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Nashport, OH United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4
Our rental experience was acceptable even with a couple of issues. We would recommend this agency. We will consider using them when we vacation in Key West again (like next year). We especially were thankful for the cleanliness of the house. We enjoyed the decor and furniture inside and outside. It was very cool and tropical! Having upper end quality bed collections, towels, etc. is ideal for us. The location was quiet. We enjoy walking so the distance to Sloppy Joes, etc. did not bother us. Sure wish the pool was bigger. Then Potter's Cottage would be perfect. The managers were great, friendly and had attention to details. Yea!

Great Cottage in a Great Location

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Palmyra, PA United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
Our family of five recently rented the Potter's Cottage for a week in July. We knew that it was on the smaller side, but there was actually plenty of room for all of us. We loved the location, which was an easy walking distance to restaurants, etc. on Duval, as well as several beaches that we enjoyed. The pool was a great addition due to the very warm weather. It was great to have Phil to make suggestions and assist with our reservations for dinner, etc.. He is a great asset to HKWVR. On our next visit to Key West, we would definitely rent this cottage again.

Potters Cottage Review

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Princeville, IL United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4
We thought the property was lovely and we loved the location. On several occasions the neighbors behind caused quite a disturbance. The guest bedroom mattress is hard as a rock which not quite so comfortable. Would like a TV or at least some type of speaker to be able to enjoy music on the deck around the pool. Loved the front porch and enjoyed people watching. Would definitely stay there again!

Home away from home

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from State College, PA United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
This was a perfect place for our first extended stay in Key West. It was comfortable and met all our needs. The location was perfect, close to beaches, restaurants and 1 block from Duval street. Having Phil to help us navigate deliveries, reservations, etc. was such an added plus! Thank you Phil! Thank you Potter Cottage for a memorable vacation!

a

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Quincy, IL United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
a

Potter's Cottage

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Madison, MS United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
We recently stayed at Potter's Cottage on our first ever trip to Key West. It was the perfect place for us! The property is perfectly located for people who want to be walking distance to all the major attractions but want a little space from all the noise of upper Duval. The Cottage is charming. It is beautifully decorated with all the amenities you need. The pool and patio are a perfect place to relax at the end of a busy day sightseeing. My only qualification would be for people with limited mobility or who have trouble climbing stairs. The master bedroom is wonderful but the stairs are quite steep so if that would be an issue it might not be the best place to stay. Otherwise it was perfect. Danny was our concierge and helpfully gave us several suggestions of places to eat and they were all fabulous.

My recent stay

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Leavenworth, Kansas United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
Everything was ready for us upon our arrival. House was perfect and very clean. Location was fantastic, walking distance to Duval Street and the Southernmost Point. Only complaint would be parking.

Perfect

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Winter Park, FL United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
We (two couples) spent the Memorial Day weekend in Key West at the Potter's Cottage.<br/>It was everything that we wanted and more. The unit is located at a great location and, despite being on Whitehead (a busy street) there was no annoying street noise.<br/>The kitchen was well-equipped, the rooms comfortable and the pool was fabulous.<br/>I would highly recommend it!

Potter's Cottage

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Collegeville, PA United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
Perfect house for our family of 6. Everything worked for us, Great location one block off Duval. We will be back!

great vacation

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Altoona, IA United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
wonderful home away from home, perfect for the 4 of us, loved the pool area

Potter’s Cottage

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Boylston, MA United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
The cottage was charming and beautifully decorated. Plenty of room for two couples. It was spotless and very well equipped with a starter supply of paper products and soap etc. The location is perfect and you can walk or ride bikes to everywhere. The backyard is so private and the pool is heated to perfection. Beds great too.<br/>Danny(concierge for Historic Key West Properties) could not have been nicer or more helpful! He and the owners went above and beyond to make sure that we had a great vacation! Highly recommend this place!

Great week

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Windsor Heights, Iowa United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5
We had a great week in KW.

Potters Cottage Key West

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Jefferson City, MO United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
Potters Cottage was the perfect relaxation destination! It was very centrally located to all the attractions in Key West, was clean, and though the pool is very small, we thoroughly enjoyed its peaceful, private setting. Potters Cottage has all of the comforts of home. We will most definitely be going back!

Key West

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Canton, GA United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
We did not get to Key West due to Hurricane Irma. We were very disappointed, but kept everyone in the Keys and the entire state of Florida in our prayers. We would love to visit, stay in Potter's Cottage, and have the opportunity to share our experience with others. Looking forward to it, and hope it will happen. The star ratings are only for the purpose of submitting this form, as it will not send without being completed.

Potters Cottage review

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Cary, NC United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
3 nights a patters cottage on Witehead st

My Happy Place

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Centerville, IN United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4
Potter's Cottage was wonderful! It had everything you could possibly need, even a shy iguana that would peak through the trees every now and then. The pool was a life saver on those hot and humid August days. My only caution is that the stairs to the loft bedroom are quite steep and narrow. I slept up there (the bed was great), but stayed downstairs any other time. The bonus room made a great changing area. My son and I can not wait to return next year!

Outstanding Vacation Rental, Perfect Location

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Vancouver, WA United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
Beautiful home. This is clearly a home the owner cares about, well furnished and decorated, not just cheap furniture and a few posters. The home is beautiful, well furnished and comfortable. Historic Key West Vacation Rentals was a pleasure to deal with, responding quickly to any questions, check-in and check out was quick and helpful. House was as described and better. House can easily and comfortably sleep 6. Kitchen is a good, workable size. Downstairs bathroom shower is huge, upstairs shower is on the small side but fine. Smart TV with cable (we appreciated being able to log in to our Netflix acct when we wanted to watch a particular movie) in the living room, cable tv in each bedroom. Pool and patio are the gems. Large plunge pool, covered and uncovered patio areas with overhead fans (we're from the NW, not used to the humidity in Key West, the pool was a Godsend), very private, lots of chairs and loungers.Washer and dryer are located outside in a cabinet, very quiet. One caution, the stairs to the upstairs bedroom are steep and narrow, would not be great for the elderly or young children. House is very close (a couple of blocks) to the Hemingway House, Lighthouse, Southernmost Point, DuVal Street, great restaurants and the best conch salad on the planet (Johnson's Grocery, trust me). We could not have been happier with the house or Historic Key West Rentals. This one is a gem.

Great Time

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Monroeville , Pa United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
4
Services from rental manager
4
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
Loved the cottage had a great experience. The only thing that would make it better would be softer bed, (very stiff,) and cooler temp in the pool. Don't know if the pool was heated or it was the sun? Oh and maybe Salt and Pepper and sugar packets.

Ricciardella Getaway

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Brookeville, MD United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4
It was great. Potters Cottage was wonderful.

Potter's Cottage was Fabulous

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Midland, TX United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5
Check in was quick and easy, the cottage was exactly as described, in great condition with helpful amenities, and right in the heart of where you want to be in Key West! Fantastic!

Paradise Relaxing

Reviewed on2018-03-29 by from Williamsville, NY United States

Updated on 2018-03-29
Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4
Wonderful; did not want to leave